3 ms·
Sorry, but 'why men tend to react to statements like “men are rapists” by saying “hey, wait a minute, not all men are like that.” Because it’s of course true –
by cafard 12y ago
Sorry, but 'why men tend to react to statements like “men are rapists” by saying “hey, wait a minute, not all men are like that.” Because it’s of course true – the majority of men are not rapists, wouldn’t dream of being rapists, abhor rapists, would cut off social ties with anyone found to be a rapist immediately, etc. But since option 1 is totally not available (rapists are indefensible) and option 3 feels intuitively like a bad choice in the long term, many men will pick option 2, and make the obviously true statement that “hey, you’re exaggerating quite a bit there, not all men are rapists”.'
doesn't really answer it. The missing quantifier in "men are rapists" reads as "all" not "some". To suggest that of course the person uttering the statement meant "some" is to suggest a want of familiarity with the English language that I find unlikely. And of course, prefixing "some" makes it all less exciting, doesn't it?
- swombat 12y ago"Black people are thieves" illustrates pretty well why the "some" cannot be taken for granted, even when it's logically evident. Have a read through Scott Alexander's article if you still need more convincing: http://slatestarcodex.com/2014/05/12/weak-men-are-superweapons/ http://slatestarcodex.com/2014/05/12/weak-men-are-superweapo...
- cafard 12y agoPerhaps my own ear needs adjusting, for I can't tell whether you are agreeing with me or not. For the record, I agree with you, the "some" cannot be taken for granted.
- lhnz 12y agoStop. "Weak Men Are Super Weapons" is truly worth a read. It's not one-sided, it doesn't pick fights and it's quite fair to both sides. Smearing language on a subset of a group can rapidly cause long-term smearing on the larger group and it's completely expected and fair for innocents to want to protect themselves from the effects of this. I'll quote from the article: So the one problem is that people have a right not to have unfair below-the-belt tactics used to discredit them without ever responding to their real arguments. And the other problem is that victims of nonrepresentative members of a group have the right to complain, even though those complaints will unfairly rebound upon the other members of that group. I strongly recommend that everybody in the tech community reads it. It's not enough to just look at what people believe, take offence and respond before understanding them. You have to treat people with respect and be careful not to unduly tar each other with the same brush.