4 ms·
It's instructive to review the comments from the original posting on HN (e.g., The science is rather sound on this...): http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=813
by mhb 17y ago
It's instructive to review the comments from the original posting on HN (e.g., The science is rather sound on this...):
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=813103 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=813103
- jacquesm 17y agoI run a chat server dedicated to RE and we had our 'hoax' flag up just about immediately. Kudos to Craig for taking the time and effort to put this one to rest. Every couple of weeks there is some piece in the news about some renewable energy breakthrough by some teenager, and every time it is either a hoax, it doesn't scale, it produces piddly little bits of power, the economics don't work out or they misunderstood the physics (or any random combination of these). I'm really happy that kids are interested in renewables, it's a fantastic way to get into science and it is also good to have consciousness raised about our 'footprint'. But I really wished that the press would fact check this stuff a bit more, one of these days somebody is going to have a real breakthrough and the public will react with 'meh', just another hoax. Looking for renewable energy source in unlikely places (the windbelt for instance) is interesting because there are plenty of opportunities to get press and sometimes even funding, even if your physics is lousy. The hope humanity has for solving our dependence on oil coupled with dirt cheap renewable energy is what fuels this kind of response. In practice, engineering is hard and it pays off to do your homework. I'm curious if the kids that did this will now go on the defense or if they will own up to what the did. And if the dailymail will issue a retraction.
- mhb 17y ago...one of these days somebody is going to have a real breakthrough and the public will react with 'meh', just another hoax. http://xkcd.com/570/ http://xkcd.com/570/ and its title attribute.
- biohacker42 17y agoFor what it's worth, I recall the top HN comment initially being something about the paper printing hoaxes.
- jacquesm 17y agoyou are correct. http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=813116 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=813116
- spoiledtechie 17y agoAny chance you can throw out info on that chat server?
- jacquesm 17y agoSure: twelve.truetech.com:6667 #otherpower enjoy. It tends to be a place people use to get answers about something specific and then we never see them again or they get 'stuck'. Traffic is fairly low but there are always people lurking.