Nothing is more efficient than, like me, frequently replying to email with "r" and typing my response. That which I'm replying to is directly above, so I'm not

Nothing is more efficient than, like me, frequently replying to email with "r" and typing my response. That which I'm replying to is directly above, so I'm not sure I follow what you are looking for. I don't know that this extension purports to "fix" reply. I don't recall Gmail's reply ever working much differently than it does -- an inline textarea under the thread. Unclear what you are gaining from shift-click replying. Anything but inane... and hardly anything near one of the worst UIs... very revisionist.