3 ms·
Why are the race and ethnicity numbers U.S. based, but the gender numbers are global?
by oh_sigh 12y ago
Why are the race and ethnicity numbers U.S. based, but the gender numbers are global?
- guard-of-terra 12y agoMost of the world does not operate on rigid and sometimes funny ("hispanic", come on) set of "races" like US do. Rather, people have more dynamic nationalities and ethnicities which are harder to classify.
- oh_sigh 12y agoMy question was really going the other way - why don't they release their gender numbers for the US only? My conspiratorial feeling is because they are even more male dominated in the US than globally.
- coldcode 12y agoThe US has bizarre classifications that make no sense anywhere else. Why are people from Spain Hispanic but not from Portugal, why are Mexicans Hispanic even if they are descended from Aztec people. The idea that all Asians are the same is equally insane. Even White is a stupid concept that has no meaning. If I came from Spain I'm hispanic but if I came from just over the border in France I'm white. If I come from South Africa and move to the US I'm either African-American or White depending on my ancestry even if it goes back 2 centuries. It's a dumb concept that mostly makes sense to anyone. Yet it persists in these strange classifications that have no basis in any scientific system.
- foolrush 12y ago“Yet it persists in these strange classifications that have no basis in any scientific system.” It is likely even woven into scientific systems. This is precisely what Foucalt referenced in his “The Order of Things.”