3 ms·
If services like Uber and Lyft simply decided to be a cab company with excellent technological underpinnings, people would have been quite happy with them and t
by rhizome 12y ago
If services like Uber and Lyft simply decided to be a cab company with excellent technological underpinnings, people would have been quite happy with them and they would have been quite profitable.
In SF, this is absolutely not the case. Uber and Lyft simply would not be able to "decide to be a cab company" at all. Total non-starter.
Taxi drivers require a medallion to pick up passengers, and those are strictly limited by law. They are also already all taken by existing cab companies, either directly or through renting them from the actual medallion holders, and there's a 10+ year waiting list for a medallion unless you have $250K to purchase one from an existing holder (who wants to sell).
- aetherson 12y agoYou don't understand the dynamic of medallions in SF. Medallions in SF are owned only by taxi drivers, not by cab companies. You must drive a cab 800 hours per year in order to own a medallion. You can't own multiple medallions. Taxi fleets, in SF, provide vehicles, dispatch services, insurance, and maintenance, as well as basically being intermediaries for medallions. Driver-owners with medallions rent their medallions to the fleet, who then hand them out to their drivers who are not owners, to give them the legal right to act as a taxi for that shift. The fleets get revenue (typically) through gate fees, which is basically a fee each driver pays when they take the vehicle off the lot. You do not have to sign up to get a medallion in order to be a fleet -- nor can you own a medallion. You'd need to either attract several medallioned drivers to your fleet (hardly impossible: make them a better offer than their current fleet -- they aren't owners or otherwise locked into their existing fleet), or, perhaps better if you want to make a big entrance into the market quickly, buy out one of the existing fleets and continue its arrangement with its medallioned drivers. I take no position on whether it would have been a good idea for Uber or Lyft to do something like this -- I'm just saying that there is not a mandatory 10 year waiting period or anything.
- rhizome 12y ago* You must drive a cab 800 hours per year in order to own a medallion.* This is 16 weeks of 5-day 10-hour shifts, and about one-third of the existing medallions are pre-Proposition K medallions that do not have a driving requirement. However, the medallions are in valid 24 hours a day. I didn't say there was a mandatory 10 year requirement for driving a cab, that would be silly. However, there is a 10+ year waiting list for a person to get their own medallion, which promotes them out of the gate-and-gas rat race.
- pbreit 12y agoPrevious poster's description sounds more accurate. Yes, they cost 250k. Yes, there's a 10+ year waitlist. Yes, groups of medallion holders own valuable assets. Yes, medallions are shared by drivers.