6 ms·
That doesn't mean no one proofread it. These days I think it's more common to have the apostrophe in the possessive pronoun can to omit it. I've even seen peopl
by baddox 12y ago
That doesn't mean no one proofread it. These days I think it's more common to have the apostrophe in the possessive pronoun can to omit it. I've even seen people defend their usage as deliberate. I suspect we're near the end of it even being considered a "rule."
- matthewmacleod 12y agoI don't think that's true - I've not seen a single style guide that suggests that!
- baddox 12y agoI made no claim about what style guides suggest. I merely claimed that deliberately using "it's" for both forms is increasingly common in written English.
- sqs 12y agoMy bias is to doubt that, but I could be convinced by data. Do you have any evidence that such usage is deliberate?
- baddox 12y agoNo, I do not have any evidence on the portion of uses that are deliberate. But it doesn't have to be deliberate in the sense that the writer is consciously trying to change the trend. Trends change slowly and "naturally," sometimes even due to misunderstandings of the earlier usages. For example, the word "apron" is widely considered correct and standard, but it arose from a misunderstanding of the phrase "a napron" (from Old French "napperon") as "an apron."
- Mandatum 12y agoIt's = Shortended "it is" "It is wide angle lens" doesn't work.
- jjw1414 12y agoIs that true? A statement like, "Drive Tom's car" is grammatically correct, but I don't think it is expanded to "Drive Tom is car".
- _puk 12y agoIt's possessive in that instance.
- zacharycohn 12y agoUsually, -'s can mean either singular possessive or a contraction for "- is." "It," however, is a special case. "Its" is possessive, and "It's" is reserved only for the contraction of the phrase "It is."
- jerhinesmith 12y agoThat's because "Tom's" is possessive in this case. The possessive form of "it" is "its" (no apostrophe). The way I remember it: if you can substitute "his" or "hers" for "its", then don't use an apostrophe.
- wuliwong 12y agoI like that, I'll use it. I still forget it's vs. its.
- baddox 12y agoThis is precisely why I think usage is changing and will continue to change. The current "rule" (which isn't really a rule, since there is no official governing body of the English language) is an unnecessary and arbitrary special case. The meaning can nearly always be easily understood from context.
- cgriswald 12y agoYou are completely mistaken. "Its" isn't violating the apostrophe rule at all. "Its" is a possessive pronoun just like hers, theirs, his, ours, mine.
- hockeybias 12y agoNor have I seen it. Its use is being butchered here. It's a problem.
- qu4z-2 12y agoIn that case I'm looking forward to the days of he's and her's!
- wuliwong 12y agohahahha. they's?
- baddox 12y agoThe difference there is that the pronunciation of those special possessive forms is clearly different than the corresponding contraction (e.g. "he" vs. "his"), so you're much less likely to make the mistake in written English.
- qu4z-2 12y agoI'd argue that depends on your accent. I'll grant you that "he's" is probably a bit tricky, but I can totally see people writing "hers", stopping, looking at it, "Hm, ownership... apostrophe!". EDIT: To be clear, I'm not greatly bothered either way; I got over my prescriptivism a while ago. I'm just curious whether the trend will continue.