6 ms·
Just curious, what would you have done to fix the root issue -- handling a large number of H1B requests? One answer is well why should there be a cap. Well the
by rdtsc 12y ago
Just curious, what would you have done to fix the root issue -- handling a large number of H1B requests?
One answer is well why should there be a cap. Well there is a cap and one reason is probably because opening the gates wide open will skew the job market in US. For better or for worse it is hard to say but if you ask those in US they might say for worse.
So there is a cap. (And obviously it is being pushed against, there is demand, you wanted to work for Apple, others want to work for other companies and so on). So how to you fix the problem?
I can see these things as possible solutions:
1) First come first serve. That would be interesting, each year on a midnight of a particular date. Some server or some office in DC will will swamped with thousands of instantaneous requests. In less than 1 second it will all be over. Those with servers closer to the facility or those that have better synchronized clocks will win. Or put everyone in a long queue maybe and just wait year to year. Watch the queue extend for decades.
2) Make it an auction. So now each spot initially costs some processing fee to handle. Then well do first come first serve but increase the fee according to the demand. Maybe it takes $2k for initial spot. And $200k for last available.
> Since the job required me to be in Cupertino, the deal simply fell through.
Shouldn't you also blame Apple here too, at least just a bit. Presumably if there is this huge talent pool abroad they would at least consider opening an office in EU or let you work remotely in some capacity. Tech sector is interesting because that becomes possible (and has been done). I don't quite understand their position either. Here is a global company that they found a top person they want to join their team but well, they can't win some stupid lottery. Well fuck it, maybe they can do something more than just drop the deal? Wondering, what are you thoughts on Apple's position?
- allochthon 12y agobut if you ask those in US they might say for worse. American here. I definitely wish it was easier for high-skilled people in other countries to obtain documents for working here.
- seanflyon 12y agoI agree, but I think general American sentiment is against it. "They are taking our jobs"
- WildUtah 12y agoAn auction is the obvious solution. Submit bids with your application for the fee to be paid yearly to the USA and the highest bidders get the H1-B visas. There's no need to raise the cap and all the Apples and Googles get all the applicants they want. Today the majority of H1-B visas go to Wipro and Infosys and the like for low paid tech grunts; Apple won't have any trouble outbidding them. And those tech grunt companies aren't doing anything valuable for the USA so it won't be any loss to have them struggle. In fact, we should be able to drop the cap to a more reasonable 30-40,000 instead of the recent 85,000. And we should be able to eliminate almost all the paperwork. In the current system, a US government bureaucrat tries to determine if you're qualified when you apply. Applicants hire lawyers to fake, translate, fabricate, apostille, and make up education and work experience that USCIS expects. If applicants are paying cash, we can presume they're qualified and reduce the application paperwork to one page.
- rdtsc 12y agoYeah I suggested it because it seemed like a rather obvious solution. Now not sure if government is just incapable running an auction or there is an obvious flaw in it that I just couldn't see.
- countrybama24 12y agoThey seem to auction off spectrum pretty efficiently.
- hkmurakami 12y agoWith an auction system like that, basically every small business will be out of the picture then.
- hackerboos 12y agoMy thoughts exactly - basically a immigration system for the Fortune 500.
- afafsd 12y agoWhy would that be?
- bduerst 12y ago>there is a cap and one reason is probably because opening the gates wide open will skew the job market in US. Maybe. One of the factors evaluated for h1b approval is whether or not the immigrant's salary is higher than the mean wages for U.S. citizens working in the same SOC category in the same area. "Opening the floodgates" would only serve to skew the average salary upwards for citizens, which is good for skilled labor.
- lsc 12y ago>One of the factors evaluated for h1b approval is whether or not the immigrant's salary is higher than the mean wages for U.S. citizens working in the same SOC category in the same area. You can make many valid arguments for loosening the American immigration laws; but driving up the average wage because that's what the government mandate assumes that companies are irrational. A profit-maximizing company is only going to hire a H1B if they are cheaper than a US citizen per unit work. (You could make an argument that increased immigration drives up wages by generally increasing economic activity in the destination country, sure... but that's a rather different argument.)
- jonny_eh 12y ago> A profit-maximizing company is only going to hire a H1B if they are cheaper than a US citizen per unit work. Not true. What if the company can't find a qualified candidate? Then what they pay will likely be higher than the average worker in that industry. That's how salaries go up.
- AnimalMuppet 12y agoAll right, they are only going to hire a H1B if they are cheaper than an available US citizen per unit work. And you can't say "there are no US citizens available". Of course there are... for the right price. Now you've got a question. Is the price excessive because there are too few US citizen workers available in that field? Or are the companies just being cheap and trying to drive down the price of skilled workers? In an environment of heavy lobbying, with very persuasive people trying to make their case, how can the government objectively tell which is going on?
- davidw 12y ago> if you ask those in US they might say for worse. Rather than ask J Random Dude in the US, you should probably ask someone with a modicum of expertise in the matter, such as an economist, who will tell you that adding people is generally a net positive, rather than a negative. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lump_of_labour_fallacy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lump_of_labour_fallacy 60% of the largest high tech companies were founded by immigrants or their children: http://pando.com/2013/05/29/mary-meeker-highlights-us-immigration-hypocrisy/ http://pando.com/2013/05/29/mary-meeker-highlights-us-immigr...
- tadfisher 12y agoI am a Random Dude, and my first assumption is that bringing a highly-skilled, highly-paid person into this country would result in more taxes being paid and more goods and services being purchased.
- djb_hackernews 12y agoRight, however this is where the details start to muddy the conclusion. The fact is the H1-B visa program is completely abused in order to bring in cheaper employees at the expense of the rest of the community. These H1-B employees have little recourse, limited career potential and supress wages. The uncertainty of their immigration status means they don't buy houses, start families, or participate in the community. The benefits economists suggest don't materialize. Futher, the H1-B program has a negative effect on higher education. The H1-B program allows employers to avoid the H1-B dependent designation if they hire immigrants that possess a masters or higher degree from a US education institution. It is a well known backdoor into the US and drives up the cost of education and pushes the citizens of the US out of the classroom. The employers list a masters degree as a requisite which the citizen doesn't have because they couldn't afford it. Take a look at the UT Dallas enrollment numbers [0]. Nearly 90% of the CS masters students are international, and of the entire engineering school 84% of them are international. It's a mess and it needs to be fixed. [0] http://ecs.utdallas.edu/academics/assessment-docs/2013/2013FallECSEnrollment.pdf http://ecs.utdallas.edu/academics/assessment-docs/2013/2013F...
- bduerst 12y ago
- ulfw 12y agoWell the first thing you could do is to limit H1Bs to American companies (where the HQ is registered and run out of America and where the company is not a subsidiary of an international company). When you look at the distribution of H1Bs, you'll quickly notice that most H1Bs do not go to people working for 'American' companies. Kind of defeats the purpose if you think about it.