4 ms·
Note: Original article title is "A Move to Go Beyond Lists for Content at BuzzFeed", which is not particularly explanitory, which is why I changed it in the sub
by minimaxir 12y ago
Note: Original article title is "A Move to Go Beyond Lists for Content at BuzzFeed", which is not particularly explanitory, which is why I changed it in the submission.
- jedberg 12y agoHonest question: How do we as users know when it is ok to editorialize headlines and when it isn't?
- plorkyeran 12y agoDoes it matter? There's no punishment for having the title of your submission changed beyond wasted whatever effort you put into coming up with a new title. If you feel your title is better, submit it and see if the moderators agree.
- jedberg 12y agoThen why do the site's guidelines specifically state "Please use the original title, unless it is misleading or linkbait."? I'm fine with the mods changing the titles, but I don't like the fact that the rules don't apply equally to everyone.
- dang 12y agoThe rules apply equally to everyone. The article's title is currently "50 Million New Reasons BuzzFeed Wants to Take Its Content Far Beyond Lists". That's obviously linkbait, so we didn't revert the submitter's title.
- mbesto 12y ago> That's obviously linkbait This is a whole new meta that my brain is really having a hard time grokking.
- dang 12y agoSure, it's a meta ironic reference to Buzzfeed linkbait by the NYT, but the point stands. If I ironically mimic somebody screaming, I'm still screaming.
- jedberg 12y agoThe title wasn't link bait -- it was a journalistic choice by the New York Times author to mock BuzzFeed. Once again, I think you guys made the wrong choice. Once again, I'll point out that if you want to do heavy handed moderation, you need to spend more time understanding why something is the way it is, which means you'll need to spend more time doing it. Once again I'll point out that this is why we didn't do heavy handed moderation at reddit -- it's just too hard to get it right.
- burkaman 12y agoEditorialize is not a synonym for change. Editorializing is never a good idea, changing a headline is fine if you think the new one more accurately describes the content.
- jedberg 12y agoThat may be true, but from the guidelines: "Please use the original title, unless it is misleading or linkbait." So now I'm not sure which is ok, because the guidelines clearly state that I am supposed to use the original title. That makes me think that any change would be considered editorializing.
- minimaxir 12y agoThis was an unusual case, that was made more unusual that the headline was changed to make it even MORE confusing. That's why I added the clarification note.