3 ms·
I've thought about getting a 3d printer to mess around with for a long time. But before I drop the money and spend the time, I sit around and try and figure out
by bane 12y ago
I've thought about getting a 3d printer to mess around with for a long time. But before I drop the money and spend the time, I sit around and try and figure out what exactly I'd do with one once I had it.
I don't really have any useful modeling skills, so I'd be reliant on 3d models I could find elsewhere. So I go to http://www.thingiverse.com/ http://www.thingiverse.com/ and to be honest, even at the price of free, I can't find a single thing I'd ever be interested in having sitting around my house. Almost every object available is a novelty statue made by a fan of some geek favorite property, or some incredibly specific part for things I don't own.
I mean, do I really need to invest a couple hundred to a couple thousand dollars and hundreds of hours of my time to print off a low quality t-slot hinge when I could just stop off at my local home deport and pick up a high quality metal hinge for $2.95?
In almost every case where I think it'd be cool to have a printer sitting around in the off chance I really needed to spend $3 in ABS plastic and spend a half hour assembling a lens cap, I can usually find an actual version of the part cheaper and higher quality on-line somewhere and I don't have to muck around with anything.
I'm obviously the wrong kind of audience for 3d printers as they are now. But I don't think I'm that atypical of the general audience that's out there. The economics and ROI on 3d printers don't remotely work out for anybody who's not a tinkerer. Until I can start printing off exact-to-quality copies of my favorite shoes for 1/3rd the store price, or entire working keyboards I don't have to assemble and find electronics. I just don't see much of a general market.
- tmuir 12y agoI think your sentiment is true of technology and tools in general. If you have a pain point that a particular tool solves, then that tool is probably a good fit for you. But if you buy a tool because you've been sold on all of the cool things you _could_ do with the tool, and you weren't necessarily looking to do any of those things before you knew about the tool, then buyer's remorse is almost certain to come your way. 99% of smartphone apps fall into this category. The internet of things, at least currently, is also an example of this. There tons of products out there that solve problems that no one actually has, but can be construed as game-changing with romantic notions and polished marketing.
- Pamar 12y agoPersonally I am keeping an eye on the technology but I haven't decided to buy a printer precisely for that: I know I have exactly one use for it (replacing small plastic part from a piece of furniture) but then I am basically done, and I doubt that just using it once will open up a zillion new ideas for me. But on the other hand, I periodically talk with a few other friends/acquaintances who live in my area and are in more or less the same situation regarding "use cases". The plan is to end up pooling the money, set it in one of our basements and then share it among 4-5 different households (most of the tinkerers at heart).
- photojosh 12y agoMy "Internet of Things" concept is a BT/WiFi appliance power monitor... would be able to detect whenever power usage changed. Use case: you get a push notification when the dishwasher/washing machine/dryer/etc finished. Thoughts?
- jpindar 12y agoThere are wireless power monitors which have their own smartphone apps. I don't know if any of them can be set up to give you that sort of notification, but some of the manufacturers make enough information available that you could write your own app. http://www.belkin.com/us/p/P-F7C029/ http://www.belkin.com/us/p/P-F7C029/ http://developers.belkin.com/wemo/sdk http://developers.belkin.com/wemo/sdk
- Htsthbjig 12y ago"I mean, do I really need to invest a couple hundred to a couple thousand dollars and hundreds of hours of my time to print off a low quality t-slot hinge when I could just stop off at my local home deport and pick up a high quality metal hinge for $2.95?" If you find a 3D printing group, you will spend at most 5 hours to learn how to print something. Nowadays with automatic bed leveling is more like an hour or so. But yeah, if you are not a tinkerer, then it is not for you. But for those tinkering with the world, like architects, engineers, scientists... having a 3D printer is invaluable. We build calibration systems for cameras and recognition that will cost us thousands of dollars each for basically nothing, thanks to 3d printers. It is also amazing for sharing design work. We send a model over the Internet and someone in other country could understand how it works just printing in plastic, while the real piece will be aluminum, steel or carbon fiber.
- bane 12y agoYeah, absolutely, for custom pieces and prototyping, 3d printing is more or less essential these days. I'm concerned about the hype that it gets though "download a car!" and the lack of understanding in the industry at the low end (among people who make 3d printers, investors and consumers) about what it is exactly that they do and how they work. There's a kind of weird hype that they're basically Star Trek replicators: 1) feed in plastic 2) download model from internet 3) print an entire household of goods for next to nothing But with some very rare exceptions, usually in the very expensive SLS levels, final items aren't being produced and the quality, durability and complexity of what gets produced is not yet at what a normal consumer would expect. Even among crap Chinese plastics junk I have all over my house, there's precious few items that a 3d printer can produce end-to-end -- even if I have to do some minor assembly. Nearly every item has some kind of metal spring or screw or lens or circuit board or something in it. There's no way for anybody right now to download a new remote control model and have it print off ready for batteries to go in. The very large number of low-end 3d printer makers and the excited investors makes me think that people don't fundamentally understand these limitations yet. The upside of this of course is that it's very hard for anti-piracy groups to make any kind of reasonable claim that 3d printing is going to put anybody out of business since a half hour looking into the technology reveals the limitations pretty quickly.
- jwatte 12y agoAt some point, the time to print will be 5 minutes. At some point, the set of "highly specific parts" will cover 95% of the things that break in your life. At some point, "search + print" will be faster and cheaper than Amazon prime. We're not there yet. When will we get there? Who will be the leaders when we do? We don't know yet. But I dare anyone to claim in good faith that we won't get there!