3 ms·
If you don't like the "board of industry experts" idea, just go with Feld's second idea: "owns 10% of a company that raised $250K". That's a totally mechanical
by gojomo 17y ago
If you don't like the "board of industry experts" idea, just go with Feld's second idea: "owns 10% of a company that raised $250K". That's a totally mechanical standard, which delegates no decisionmaking outside government.
Further, it should go without saying that other immigration conditions -- non-criminal, etc. -- will still be in effect.
I do think the proposal could be even more simple, though. We could just sell Visas to anyone who's law-abiding and self-sufficient. Then the only dimension for argument between pro- and anti-immigration advocates can be the price.
Start with a small pool and auction them off at a high price. Do a rolling study of taxes paid, jobs created, and services used by those who purchased those Visas. Each year, if prior experience suggests more people entering under this program would have been a net benefit, increase the pool. If the study ever indicates the entrants were a net drain, decrease the pool in following years.
You can even bias the whole process strongly against more immigration, to pander to the paranoid, and it would still address one of the biggest problems facing businesses: the uncertainty of getting a key employee in-country. There would be a relatively predictable price for doing so, which would allow rational planning.
- alain94040 17y agoWe could just sell Visas to anyone Great, so all the rich sons of the Saudi Arabia royal family will buy their green card so they can travel freely, and all the entrepreneurs will stay home.
- gojomo 17y agoRich heirs travel pretty freely already, and under this plan at least we'd get their money. Plus, since such wealthy quasi-tourists create no net cost (and probably create value) with their visits, each year we'd increase the allotment until it reaches the intended audience: productive people we'd rather have here than competing against domestic employers from elsewhere.
- alex_c 17y agoYou can already buy a green card. The price is $500,000 to $1,000,000. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EB-5_visa http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EB-5_visa