8 ms·
I have some difficulties with the issues described in the piece. "A yard is the distance from your sternum to the tip of your outstretched hand." According to
by dalke 12y ago
I have some difficulties with the issues described in the piece.
"A yard is the distance from your sternum to the tip of your outstretched hand."
According to folk belief, it's the distance from the tip of Henry I's nose to the end of his thumb. According to an early definition, "It is ordained that 3 grains of barley dry and round do make an inch, 12 inches make 1 foot, 3 feet make 1 yard."
Who here has an idea of the size of a grain of barley dry and round?
At 39.3 inches, a meter is just slightly longer than a yard, and for "traditional purposes" where the sternum/fingertip approximation is good enough, a meter and a yard can be used almost interchangeably.
Somehow all those people using metric in their daily lives don't feel like they are missing something special by having "ancient, organic" units. (BTW, at what point does something become "ancient"?)
"Or don’t bother, because the definition completely changed in 1960"
The yard definition 'completely changed' in 1959, when it defined as exactly 0.9144 meters. Before then it was different in different countries.
Since the yard is pegged to the meter, this means that the yard is now legally defined as the time light travels in 1/274130223.5952 seconds.
"The first third of the 20th century, for instance, saw some quite serious efforts to rationalize our systems for dates and times."
As well as the 1700s, when France ran under a rationalized calendar, which provided the name for the Thermidorian Reaction. This is part of the same movement that brought us the metric system, so I think it's odd to exclude that very serious effort.
- keithpeter 12y agoUK: we work in Imperial but things are officially priced in metric, except for beer. Petrol is in pence/litre. So you get price per lb and per kg. Lengths are in millimetres on builders plans (to avoid mistakes with decimal points) but road signs are in miles. Makes teaching basic maths to adults a bit more fun... http://sohcahtoa.org.uk/pages/maths_market-metric-proportion.html http://sohcahtoa.org.uk/pages/maths_market-metric-proportion... You would be surprised how many people have issues with decimal place notation still. The low denominator fractions make a lot of sense for a lot of people. French speaking African students of mine will naturally price food in half and quarter kilos.
- dalke 12y agoThe UK is a very odd place when it comes to metrication. My experience in Sweden is that things sold in the 1/2 and 1/4 kg sizes are often measured in grams or sometimes hectograms rather than kg. Meat, for example, is usually given in values which are a multiple of 25 g, even when there's more than 1kg. This bypasses the need to use low denominator fractions.
- kps 12y ago> Meat, for example, is usually given in values which are a multiple of 25 g Those used to be 28g, and called ‘ounces’.
- dalke 12y agoPoint taken, though "usually" also means "not always." For example, http://www.mathem.se/varor/fransyska-o-notstek/fransyska-nat-1220g-ica http://www.mathem.se/varor/fransyska-o-notstek/fransyska-nat... is 1220 grams and https://www.handla24.se/hovslatt/pc-60-288-flskfil-frsk.aspx https://www.handla24.se/hovslatt/pc-60-288-flskfil-frsk.aspx is "about 570 grams". That's 43.6 and 20.4 oz, respectively.
- lotsofmangos 12y agoOunces are also anything from 27.4g, up to 100g, depending on which ounce is being used. There are loads of different ounces.
- allegory 12y agoUK calling here. My Fiat doesn't have mph on the speedo as it was replaced (like most things ln the car it broke). I've been doing conversions for years from miles to km, gallons to litres etc. It's annoying but kmh is easy. I want to drive 200 miles. How much will it cost at 44.9mpg and 135.9ppl? 200 / 44.9 x 4.456 x 1.359 - yep random unit conversion in the middle. Beer is metric as well until they sell it to you. Whilst I understand all the problems I can only assume its an issue with education as doing decimal math is no more difficult than any other. Sometimes its easier especially when comparing or scaling magnitudes.
- seancoleman 12y agoSmall correction: distance light travels in...
- jwecker 12y agoAs you've illustrated, we've come to value precision over intuition. The reason people using metric don't feel like they're missing something without organic units is because people who use the relics of those organic units don't use them in the fuzzy organic sense either anymore. When someone tells me "1 foot long" I expect exactly 12 standardized inches- not something roughly as big as my foot (even though, in my case, my foot is almost exactly 12 inches). In modern times when we want a more organic measure we find ourselves dropping standard units (whether metric or imperial) and using random analogous items instead- like number of empire-state-buildings or 10-paces then turn left, or (more often perhaps but slightly different)- about 3 blocks away. The moment people started caring about whether it was Henry I's nose-to-thumb length or some multiple of grains of barley dry it stopped mattering. I'm very average sized and my pace is almost exactly one yard per step (or, as you pointed out, more or less a meter as well). I would be fine using the term 'yard' in the intuitive or organic sense- but when you're using it to tell me exactly where my property line is I suddenly need precision, agreed on standards, and at that point the question of inches vs centimeters is strictly a question of familiarity (or I suppose, as the article mentions, politics).
- XorNot 12y agoAlso because using the metric system you simply take shorthands. 1 inch? About 2.4 cm as far as anyone cares in a casual sense. A meter is about the length of your shoulder to your hand, or a slightly stretch stride. It's actually easier for me to eyeball a centimeter then an inch because I see and use the centimeter all the time. The idea that the units themselves matter is absurd - when you're eyeballing it, you're eyeballing it.
- allegory 12y agoIsn't this akin to the reddit meme of showing everything next to a banana "for scale" comparing body parts? I.e. non-deterministic and from a scientific perspective, total horse shit.
- jwecker 12y agoTotally. "Science" requires precision because science in many ways is the mechanism by which we learn truths with greater and greater precision. That doesn't mean though that science naturally abhors imprecise "for-scale" measurements though- they just reserve them for illustration and avoid using them for the actual science. (e.g., http://imgur.com/gallery/ESp2j http://imgur.com/gallery/ESp2j - marianas trench scale)
- allegory 12y agoYep can understand that. Its important to visualise values and comparing to reference points is fine. This comes to mind for unit conversions: http://www.weirdconverter.com http://www.weirdconverter.com
- Havvy 12y agoThat was an Imgur meme first. One of the original Imgur memes at that.
- mgkimsal 12y ago"Who here has an idea of the size of a grain of barley dry and round?" It's about a third of an inch.
- lutusp 12y ago> Since the yard is pegged to the meter, this means that the yard is now legally defined as the time light travels in 1/274130223.5952 seconds. s/time/distance/ ?