3 ms·
I've been involved with the Agile movement since before the term "Agile" existed, so I can say with some authority that your managers are idiots twice over. Fi
by wpietri 12y ago
I've been involved with the Agile movement since before the term "Agile" existed, so I can say with some authority that your managers are idiots twice over.
First, I do encourage to start with physical boards, but that's because I encourage teams to work in the same place. Agile methods work best with low-latency, high-bandwidth, always-on communication, and by far the easiest way to get that is by sitting in a dedicated team room. But if it's impossible for the team to be together, yeah, a white board just won't cut it.
Second, the point of all of the Agile approaches is to have teams continuously improve their process in response to local conditions. There is no single Agile process. There are common starting points, and that often includes a white board or a card board because those are very flexible tools that everybody feels comfortable adapting. But if the whole company is supposed to be doing exactly the same manager-dictated process, then it is definitionally not Agile, because of points 1 and 4 in the manifesto. [1]
On a personal note, I want to offer you an apology. It makes me sad that something with such promise for liberating employees and making work better has turned into just another stick to beat employees with. That is the exact opposite of what a lot of the early Agile people intended. I'm very sorry that we weren't more diligent in preventing the movement from getting co-opted by existing power dynamics.
[1] http://agilemanifesto.org/ http://agilemanifesto.org/
- sidcool 12y agoThanks! Another funny thing they talk about is velocity. It's the holy metric for managers. "Why isn't your velocity increasing anymore?" Asked one. I said "Because if we keep on increasing velocity, soon we will hit the speed of light." I had no better response. Also, they tend to compare velocities between teams. Story point estimation technique is fundamentally subjective, and cannot be a point of comparison between two different teams. It's a difficult life, but I get by.
- wpietri 12y agoYes, every bit of that is wrong. If managers put upward pressure on velocity numbers, they will get numbers that go up via point inflation. The right managerial question is: "What can I do to help you solve problems identified in this week's retrospective?" Sadly, modern MBA-style management has some fundamental notions that work against Agile approaches. So you are probably in for more difficulty as they decide what has a higher priority. Feel free to email me if I can be of further service in discussing this.
- sidcool 12y agoSure thanks. You have been of great help!