4 ms·
Speaking to #3, and this is highly anecdotal - I spent 6 years in grad school that was highly ranked (I loathe the ranking system, but that may be irrelevant).
by dnautics 12y ago
Speaking to #3, and this is highly anecdotal - I spent 6 years in grad school that was highly ranked (I loathe the ranking system, but that may be irrelevant). And had about 70 students a year. Over my 6 years, I saw maybe 20 good thesis defenses (my own was not very good). One particular lab was a serial offender; exactly zero of the defenses I saw I thought were worthy of a PhD (although I recall two projects there that I thought were good that were not concluded when I finshed). One of these defenses had a presentation where the introductory slide bulleted six topics of study that the student completed; he presented only four of the six and all of them failed, two of them, as admitted by the student himself, for trivial reasons that could have been solved by merely sauntering over to his committee member's and chatting for five minutes.
This person still has a PhD from a top institution. His boss has several startup companies, all completely rediculous (one of which seeks to eliminate cocaine addiction through something which will probably only make the cocaine addiction worse - it then pivoted to "an emergency drug to administer to accidental cocaine overdoses"). My experiences witnessing thesis defenses as a postdoc at a "mid-tier" research university were not much better.