8 ms·
War in the womb
- Terr_ 12y agoI wonder if/how this relates to premature births.
- biomcgary 12y agoPreeclampsia, a state of too high blood pressure in the mother, is discussed in the article and is one of the leading reasons for medically induced premature births. However, this in only one of several causes of premature birth. A large number of premature births are spontaneous (starting with either labor or membrane rupture) with no known cause and little forewarning. Infection of the membranes also contributes to a large fraction of premature births. If you are interested in this topic, my lab is looking to hire a database specialist (postgres) in Nashville.
- danielschonfeld 12y agoI'm interested in all things biology (tho I have no background in it). What exactly do you need the database specialist to do? what are the problems you are facing? Contact me at downwindabeam at gmail dot com
- Kenji 12y agoIn my opinion, this is the most interesting paragraph: >In primates and mice, it’s a different story. Cells from the invading placenta digest their way through the endometrial surface, puncturing the mother’s arteries, swarming inside and remodelling them to suit the foetus. Outside of pregnancy, these arteries are tiny, twisty things spiralling through depths of the uterine wall. The invading placental cells paralyse the vessels so they cannot contract, then pump them full of growth hormones, widening them tenfold to capture more maternal blood. These foetal cells are so invasive that colonies of them often persist in the mother for the rest of her life, having migrated to her liver, brain and other organs. There’s something they rarely tell you about motherhood: it turns women into genetic chimeras. The whole article sounds so creepy. I never thought you could describe one of the most natural processes in that light.
- biomcgary 12y agoAlthough the article dramatizes the conflict, the tug-of-war over resources is real, which probably is why the placenta is one of the fastest evolving mammalian organs in terms of morphology and genetics. The conflict probably shapes the rate of preterm birth quite a bit. If you are interested in this topic, my lab is looking to hire a database specialist (postgres) in Nashville.
- perlpimp 12y agofacinating
- biomcgary 12y agoSorry to flog a job opening so shamelessly, but I'm a research scientist at Vanderbilt University working on the evolution of human pregnancy with an emphasis on identifying the causes of preterm birth. We are building a database to integrate a large number of experiments with various evolutionary analyses (with a dollop of machine learning on top), which will soon be available online at genestation.org. We're looking to hire a full-time database admin/developer who finds biology interesting, but there is no need for formal training in biology.
- keerthiko 12y agoThat paragraph also triggered the thought "Are humans biologically wired only to love through conflict?" As a race, can we never be rid of the need to fight one another? Are we fundamentally designed to do so? This article tugged on my strings in many ways. Philosphically, scientifically, emotionally, artistically. I liked it a lot.
- gretful 12y agoLife is a struggle. I'm edging more and more towards life NEEDING a struggle to reach it's potential. The struggle must be balanced, but it is necessary.
- Mz 12y agoThere’s something they rarely tell you about motherhood: it turns women into genetic chimeras. I have a genetic disorder and I have given birth to two children, one who has the same disorder and one who does not. In recent months, I have been speculating a bit about the impact those two pregnancies had on my medical condition. So that little snippet was particularly interesting to me because it suggests that having my second child likely left me with little islands of cells which lack my genetic disorder. I already have reason to believe that my pregnancies made me healthier, if only because of the degree to which throwing up for 8 months forced me to eat differently with my first pregnancy and many of those changes in diet became permanent. But this adds some real science to what has mostly been anecdata up until now.
- RV86 12y agoI read this article on Aeon the other day -- for an ostensibly scientific approach, the author spends a lot of energy anthropomorphizing the biological processes. Plenty of what's said is rigorous and fascinating, but I think that style obscures some of it. What's really interesting to me is that in many ways this "adversarial" relationship must actually be looked at as a fairly optimal one as far as evolution is concerned -- after all, our species (and plenty of other mammals) have reproduced and thrived across the world. I'd be very curious to read an analysis of postpartum depression through this lens.
- Retric 12y agoThe 'Optimal' solution would use less energy. The adversarial relationship seeks a different Nash equilibrium.
- andreasvc 12y agoI think that depends very much on the set of goals that are considered as 'optimal'. which is a matter of definition. I would say that for constraints such as robustness and adaptability to the environment the current situation is likely close to 'optimal'.
- Retric 12y ago"By eight months, the foetus spends an estimated 25 per cent of its daily protein intake on manufacturing these hormonal messages to its mother" That's a lot of energy. Further, human mothers have a high chance of death from natural childbirth compared to most mammals. Further the energy costs, pain, and suffering from monthy periods has a lot to do with the conflict, wolves for example don't suffer nearly as much. Realistically it's at best a local optima, but robustness and adaptability are hindered but such inefficiency.
- markburns 12y agoInefficient on an individual level, but the adaptability and robustness is more on a species level. It's probably pretty efficient in that regard. A high risk, high reward strategy that works out well for humans that survive and end up with large brains, but terrible for certain individuals for the reasons previously outlined.
- rosser 12y agoI shared this on Facebook, and my friend who's a perinatologist (a sub-specialist who takes care of moms delivering preterm, moms w severe medical conditions (lupus, kidney failure, heart failure) and fetuses with problems (birth defects, fetuses who need transfusions for anemia) commented, saying, "The fetus is the most successful parasite known to man. Many people even want one!"
- biomcgary 12y agoFrom an evolutionary perspective, this is probably one of the few types of parasites that dramatically improve your fitness (kind of by definition).
- 3am 12y agoFrom a purely technical viewpoint, parasitism is always antagonistic/bad. If not, it's called mutualism or commensalism. Not disagreeing with your real point, just being pedantic. edit: to biomcgary, two points: first - i was taught that parasitism is by definition bad but actual interactions between species can fall along a spectrum of mutualistic and parasitic (and individual and specific effects may differ). second - it really ought to be moot since these terms refer interspecific interaction, right? I did a little googling before this edit, and yes, i see intraspecific brood parasitism and such... anyway, enough digression from me. I just think it's an overly-clever corruption of the actual concept of parasitism to describe a fetus as one. It's like calling a hill a parasite because it takes effort to walk up one.
- biomcgary 12y agoYou may be trying to be pedantic, but, to be meta-pedantic, your point highlights that two different conclusions are reasonable depending on the scale of analysis. At a functional level, a fetus takes nutrients from mom without returning any benefit (thus a parasite), but from the longer term perspective of evolution the relationship is mutualistic.
- rmrfrmrf 12y ago
- personZ 12y agoRelated but incidental, but what's the deal with Aeon? They don't seem to have a revenue model, but I read and enjoy virtually everything they produce. Is there a gotcha coming?
- anigbrowl 12y agoI don't know either; maybe they're funded by a foundation or somesuch. It's under the umbrella of this magazine content firm: http://magculture.com/projects/ http://magculture.com/projects/ While it tends a bit towards the softer and philosophical end of science, the standard of writing is very high and I've found myself coming back again and again for informative and thought-provoking articles. I would be amenable to paying an annual subscription for it.
- 31reasons 12y ago>>Even with the help of modern medicine, pregnancy still kills about 800 women every day worldwide Um..I am not sure about modern medicine part. Most of these women must be in developing countries where you hardly get "modern medicine" on a regular basis.
- biomcgary 12y agoAccording to the World Health Organization, 99% of maternal death is in developing countries [0]. Given that this is likely the same source for the 800 women a day stat, the author is probably being willfully ignorant. [0] http://www.who.int/mediacentre/factsheets/fs348/en/ http://www.who.int/mediacentre/factsheets/fs348/en/
- mqsiuser 12y agoTo say 800 a day (worldwide) is willfully misleading It's catchy and that's the intension of the author (she wants to be heard). There are so many things to put this number into context. 800 a day, oh that's like 3 Jumbo's full of woman crashing each day. I mean woman... how unfair is that... But you know, each second ~3 people die _ohhhh noooo_, nobody should die (ever)
- rmrfrmrf 12y agoThis article is needlessly sensational and has waaaaay too many misleading "chicken and egg" statements. The evolution of the uterus came prior to the evolution of the human embryo, so to say that the uterus "needs" to protect the body against the embryo is untrue; in reality, it was the embryo that needed to adapt itself to its environment. It's these kind of articles that cause misunderstandings about how evolution actually works. If we, the HN community, are interested in furthering our knowledge bases, we need to stop falling for these pseudo-intelligent reskinned BuzzFeed articles.
- sarink87 12y agoI have basically no knowledge on this topic, but my initial reaction before I even read your post was exactly that - there are quite a lot of "chicken and egg" scenarios brought up. Some of the stuff made sense, some of it was (potentially) fascinating, some of it was quite dubious.
- JesseObrien 12y agoWhile I agree with the chicken and egg statements, I think the sensationalism is a Good Thing in this instance. The language of the article and the way the information is presented gives way to some good discussion points and thought projects. If you simply wanted more "facts" and "knowledge" of human reproduction, go read Wikipedia. These kind of articles don't cause misunderstandings, people interpreting the language as fact, do. So long as the reader understands the language in the article, I see no problems with it. Nothing in the article states that the presented information is beyond theory. It's a discussion of those theories with supporting science thrown in where necessary to drive further questions and discussion.
- Natsu 12y agoCan you help me better understand your post? What I got out of it was "so long as the readers understand it's not actually true, it's ok" but I'm not convinced this is the intended interpretation.
- 12y ago
- ryanmarsh 12y agoCan confirm. My new daughter tried to kill her mother by preeclampsia.
- marktangotango 12y agoSorry to hear that, that must have been terrifying. I hope mother and daughter are doing fine now.
- ryanmarsh 12y agoThank you. Yes they are. The doctors were on the ball and pulled baby out as late as they could. Baby is at home fine now and developing normally. She was born at 32 weeks. Because of prenatal steroids her lungs were fully developed.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- guard-of-terra 12y agoThis is where God either doesn't exist or doesn't care about us, so we should stick to our devices AND FIX THEM. Reading the article made me feel shame about not being able to clean up this situation yet.
- andreasvc 12y agoWhat are you talking about? Who's them? What fix are you thinking about?
- facepalm 12y agoThere are even more interesting implications of the "war": women are fertilized inside the body so that fathers can not be sure whose offspring a child is (because the fertilization can not be seen, other than with eggs, for example) - otherwise they might kill the offspring of other fathers (our ancestors would have, that is). Furthermore, women try to hide their fertility as much as possible, other than most other mammals. Iirc that is for the same reason: since men can not be sure when the woman was fertile, they can not be sure who made her pregnant. But if they don't know when a woman is pregnant, why even have sex? And that is why sex is fun. We take it for granted, but apparently it is only fun for very few species. I recommend "Why sex is fun" by Jared Diamond for a fun read... I hope I have remembered correctly (it's been too long since I read it).
- akirk 12y agoI think it is a very important detail to understand that new life has to grow in water. When life moved out of the water, different life-forms discovered a way to take that environment away from the water to have their embryos grow: Birds keep the water in eggs, mammals in their womb. While egg-laying animals create self-contained environments, mammals need much more energy to develop therefore have to be live-fed. So they feed this separate, new creature. Of course they have to protect themselves from them.
- infinite8s 12y agoIf you go even further, our cellular milieu has similar chemical potential as sea water, so we are in effect walking bags of sea water.
- gordaco 12y agoI guess that the situation is even harsher when there is more than one foetus.
- eternalban 12y ago"It's my body". No, it is a parasite and a distinct life form.
- andrzejsz 12y agoThis kind o article suits perfectly as a pro choice propaganda I could only wonder if it was written with support for example Planned Parenthood
- mqsiuser 12y agoWe have huge brains, jo They must be there for a reason I tell you, bro. It's war, you know. "We/I thought about everything and this is what we came up with (interwined with very catchy words to hold your attention)" Could you please do (representative) studies and not assume too much?! Very hurting are some of the cause&conclusion sections... very slim terrain (correlation=/=causation)