3 ms·
I think big music labels are another example of corporations that have been disrupted less than folks here on HN might think. Yes, iTunes changed the music ind
by snowwrestler 12y ago
I think big music labels are another example of corporations that have been disrupted less than folks here on HN might think.
Yes, iTunes changed the music industry, but who got killed? CD retailers, primarily. The bulk of music sold through iTunes is still licensed from big labels. Spotify licenses music from the big labels. Ads, TV shows, and movies license music from big labels. Heck even the most popular videos on YouTube are almost all the official Vevo versions of big-label songs.
Piracy is harming album sales, but because big labels have so much financial leverage over new artists, they have simply started requiring "360" deals for a lot of new contracts, which give them a cut of all revenue streams: not just albums, but also tour revenues, merchandise, media appearances, sync licences (ads and movies), even publishing in some cases.
- mason55 12y agoReminds me of an article on /r/movies the other day about "XYZ didn't kill the movie industry, the movie industry killed itself". Well... no. The movie industry is far from dead and is doing quite well for itself. It even avoided the mistakes the music labels made when they gave Apple too much power (a mistake that they have since recovered from).
- snowwrestler 12y agoSome labels/studios are being hurt by piracy, primarily the mid-size and smaller independents. They have less financial leverage over their artists, but more importantly, many of them choose to limit their relationships with artists to publishing and promotion, so they are more dependent on album sales for revenue. They also tend to more fan-friendly, so they generally choose not to fight against file sharing, etc. even though it hurts them. These are the "middle class" level folks in those industries--making a professional living, but not getting rich. That particular stratum is being eaten away by piracy. At the lower extremes of the industries, piracy is making it easier for new folks to get found and build an audience. But once they want to take the next step, they'll have a harder time staying out of the big company systems than folks 15 years ago. There are just fewer "mid-range" professional options available to them now.
- anigbrowl 12y agoExactly. The labels that have been worst hurt by the digital revolution were the least exploitative ones.
- eruditely 12y agoThese comments need to be hedges. With services like soundcloud and artists publishing their music and directly uploading new albums, a new method for payments that is not an over-extended method of sales and 'representation' based on antiquated physical formats will need to rise, and I welcome it.