3 ms·
Why don't companies hire "idea" people? Is it because they think anyone smart can get good ideas?
In my experience, "idea" people and analytically strong people are different sorts. And so it would make sense to hire "idea" people.
But apparently, few companies agree. They see analytically strong people as strictly better than everyone else.
- Alex3917 19y agoAn idea is only worth something when it's put into a fixed medium. We refer to people by the medium they work with. People who turn ideas into code are called coders. People who turn ideas into writing are called writers. etc.
- amichail 19y agoCoders generally don't turn their own ideas into code. They are given something to work on.
- brlewis 19y agoPut yourself in the position of a company. You decide you need an "idea person" position. You post an opening and collect resumes. How do you decide whom to call? Whom do you interview? How do you decide whom to hire?
- amichail 19y agoI would conduct phone interviews asking people to brainstorm in real-time. I would then invite the most promising candidates to an interview where they would be asked to do more brainstorming in real-time.
- brlewis 19y agoYou, I, or anyone else who attempts this, would make a sincere effort to assess their brainstorming abilities. What we would end up with, though, is an assessment of how similar their ideas are to ours. Ideas like ours will sound best.
- nostrademons 19y agoThe bottleneck is almost always implementation. Therefore, it makes sense to hire more implementation people. If you hired more idea people, you'd just have more ideas that you don't have time to implement. And large companies do hire idea people. That's what corporate research labs and fellowships are for. But you need a really strong track record to qualify for those, because if only a limited number of ideas can make it to implementation, you want to generate only the best ideas.
- amichail 19y agoBottleneck to what? The bottleneck to success is the idea. Without a good idea, you have nothing.
- mrtron 19y agoThe bottleneck to success is not the idea. It is the execution of a idea. Right now, there is a great example of this that is rapidly evolving and you can follow easily. Facebook apps. Do the best 'ideas' for Facebook apps dominate? No, the apps that take any idea and execute well are the ones that tend to dominate. Speed is a big part of the game - the first to market tends to spread the best.
- aswanson 19y agoI used to wonder this myself. The answer I come up with is that companies have a check that they can cash pending execution of a series of finite steps. In a reasonable mature enterprise these steps are defined and one needs a person to execute a subset of these steps. An idea introduces a probabilistic component to this that the person in charge of hiring has not considered because he/she has no incentive to do so. He/she will definitely receive negative feedback if the series of finite steps to the money they are in charge of is not properly executed. In short, no reward and definite risk is bad for a company drone, in general. No straight path to money != good.