9 ms·
At first I thought "oh no, another distraction for Mozilla", but then I sat through the presentation and thought there was some really cool ideas (amazebar!). I
by bane 12y ago
At first I thought "oh no, another distraction for Mozilla", but then I sat through the presentation and thought there was some really cool ideas (amazebar!). In fact, I think it can be simplified and paired down even more. Even better, some of the assumptions here even make the software portable (as in doesn't really need to be installed and could just run off a usb drive/out of my dropbox).
Automatically being in a private/secure mode makes lots of sense to me as well.
Some ideas I don't like:
- get rid of loved sites/bookmarks altogether. Frequent usage should just percolate autocomplete suggestions to the top. This design doesn't really need them, and tbh I've barely used bookmarks in any browser in a long time.
- too much going on in the amazebar, drop all the suggestion (which will quickly get stale, tabs, email search, etc. Just focus on most frequent sites and autocomplete, it feels like the presentation is just burying lots of the clutter that used to take up GUI space in the amazebar.
- please don't default to a "downloads" folder. I've never liked it and before I bother to change it, my downloads folder quickly turns into a "random junk I've downloaded" folder. Forcing me to put it someplace actually is simplifying my workflow. It's almost the first option I change as soon as I install a new browser.
- keep tabs more present, don't bury them in the amazebar
- mmastrac 12y ago> - please don't default to a "downloads" folder. I switched my default download directory to /tmp and haven't looked back.
- the_french 12y agoBut the whole point is that this browser isn't meant for technical people. It's not meant for the kind of people that feel the need for a different `Downloads` folder.
- fournm 12y agoMost of the comments against it here are in this same line. If the concept of NoScript even vaguely makes sense to you, or you've even heard the words "window manager" together, you're probably not the target audience. I'll admit that most of these things (especially no settings) would make it a no-go for me, but I can definitely think of some relatives that I would love to stick on it and then not have to worry about them again.
- grrowl 12y agoI'd think /tmp by default would make sense, effectively your downloaded files would live inside Firefox itself, ready for you to drag/save them out. It's in line with where modern computing is going, making the filesystem less relevant by the day.
- jamesgeck0 12y agoNot if there's any chance that tmp would get automatically cleared out, ever. I've seen people intentionally, cluelessly save work in temporary directories and then get upset when it was nuked at a later date.
- troymc 12y agoI agree with not defaulting to saving downloads in the "downloads" folder. Many people don't really know how to use their file manager. (For years, my mom would open Microsoft Word and organize files there.) Why not default to saving downloads on the Desktop? Where did that file get saved? Oh, there it is!
- nanexcool 12y agoI used to think that too. But then, why have a Downloads folder if you're not going to put Downloads in there? I agree that every once in a while you have to do some cleaning, but that's on the user.
- Laremere 12y agoI think you could have shortened your question to "why have a Downloads folder?" Downloads folders are where files go to sit unused. I personally send everything to my desktop so files won't sit out of sight forever, but I think in a browser which is meant to be simple that asking where they want the file is a good choice. Why defer user action to a time where they have to do a large amount of a boring task when you can ask them to do it right there when they're most likely to know what they want to do with it?
- _pmf_ 12y ago> Why not default to saving downloads on the Desktop? Because defaulting to having 35890 icons on the desktop has its own share of problems.
- weavie 12y agoWhat happened to just asking the user where they want to save it? To download a file I now have to download it, then open Finder, navigate to Downloads and copy the file, navigate to the folder I want to place the download, paste the file. Then navigate back to the folder and delete the file from Downloads .. because Macs don't give you a Cut option.
- Pacabel 12y ago
- krisgenre 12y agoI agree with "- keep tabs more present, don't bury them in the amazebar" Also, default settings are good but "No Settings" seems like a bad idea.
- sdrothrock 12y ago> Frequent usage should just percolate autocomplete suggestions to the top. This design doesn't really need them, and tbh I've barely used bookmarks in any browser in a long time. BECAUSE address bars autocomplete sites I frequently go to, the bookmarks end up being a way to store sites that I go to /infrequently/ and use for reference or only check up on every few months.
- chc 12y agoThat's the same way I use bookmarks. I won't bookmark, say, Hacker News, but I will bookmark a recipe site that I know I'll want to refer to for ideas sometime down the road.
- sdrothrock 12y agoThat's one of my biggest use cases: bookmarking individual recipes. That's a perfect example of something I'm not going to be looking at every day but do want a list of to browse occasionally, or to find specific ones.
- blazingfrog2 12y agoYou may already be aware of this but a fellow HNer operates a service I use frequently for this exact use case called historio.us. I use the chrome extension to add stuff that I might want to revisit and, when I do need to, I have historio.us as a "search engine" in the chrome omnibar. Think of it as your own private search engine.
- frik 12y agoRecipes are static text, you could just save the page (as HTML) on your device. (URLs change all the time, and website vanish) Later, the file can be found with Windows search / Spotlight. I bookmark more dynamic pages, e.g. news articles with comments that will be around for some longer period.
- nitrogen 12y ago
- veidr 12y agoI seldom use bookmarks for browsing/reading things, but they are very useful for opening groups of related pages at once (since modern browsers can open a folder of bookmarks in one operation). E.g., I select Bookmarks → Banking → Open in Tabs and a tab opens for each of my bank accounts and credit card accounts. (Especially handy because such sites tend to be slow.) Autocomplete is a very useful UI for going to a single site, and I personally never use bookmarks for that, but I often use them to open collections of pages together at once.
- olegp 12y agoAgree that Amazebar looks way too cluttered. We are working on something similar at StartHQ (https://starthq.com https://starthq.com) and keeping the search results page simple and uncluttered has been a challenge. We ended up including more images and less text for certain types of results like contacts, for example. Check out the screenshot below if you don't have time sign up: https://www.dropbox.com/s/zbyrhvzf3f4fmsm/visual-search.png https://www.dropbox.com/s/zbyrhvzf3f4fmsm/visual-search.png
- yiyus 12y agoI don't really see the advantage of displaying images. In your screenshot, we see five typical examples: the black head, the poster in the wall, the unknown face, the baby, and the picture with too many effects. How are these pictures better than printing five names?
- olegp 12y agoYou're right, one still needs to include the name on top of the image - that's something I'm working on atm. We did have just text before and images stick out better, making it much easier and faster to determine which is the right result to click. Text is also quite easy to scan in one direction (top to bottom for search results), but having to scan horizontally as well is difficult. With images it's much easier, letting us include more results in the same space.
- acdha 12y agoCurrent versions of Windows and OS X have a standard download folder. Following that convention makes a lot of sense for their target audience since it's what the other browsers do, in the default Explorer / Finder sidebar and avoids confusion with all of the things the average user saves to the desktop.
- gsnedders 12y ago> - get rid of loved sites/bookmarks altogether. Frequent usage should just percolate autocomplete suggestions to the top. This design doesn't really need them, and tbh I've barely used bookmarks in any browser in a long time. Opera tried getting rid of bookmarks with Opium, and very much was forced to go back after the initial release.
- asadotzler 12y agoWhy did they fail? What forced them to go back? What could have been done differently in the implementation to have resulted in a different outcome.
- gsnedders 12y ago> Why did they fail? What forced them to go back Users, in both cases. (I've not been privy to the data in a long time and never for Opium, but I suspect the uninstallation surveys showed it quite clearly from what was said.) The original decision to drop it was based on telemetry showing the majority of users never touching bookmarks. > What could have been done differently in the implementation to have resulted in a different outcome. From what I saw, the public feedback was mostly pertaining to infrequently accessed sites — which is the one case where $YourFavouriteMagicAddressBar doesn't work well. One could certainly experiment with allowing users to in some way tag or add descriptive text to URLs which showed up in the magic-address-bar, but that may well just not work sufficiently.
- frik 12y ago> The original decision to drop it was based on telemetry showing the majority of users never touching bookmarks. Advanced users often deactivate telemetry (for privacy reasons). So you the telemetry statistics cover the normal users. For example: Microsoft made the same mistake and trusted their telemetry statistics too much. That's why they made (in retrospect) stupid and rather unpopular decisions in their recent products.
- GhotiFish 12y agoI like your suggestions, some comments: >please don't default to a "downloads" folder. don't worry, you'd never use this browser. The people who would barely know what a folder is. Actually that's a bit of a problem, those 'evergreen' people he talks about do NOT interact with the filesystem. So one way or another this application will have to open that folder somehow. >keep tabs more present, don't bury them in the amazebar This one I understand. The 'evergreens' I've met in my life don't use tabs. Some do, however, but only in a limited context. It's tempting to think to add a feature that can be exploited for so much gain by us... but for a feature to be used, the UI must pressure the user to use it.