5 ms·

One reason I wish JS had goto

3 points by s3graham 17y ago

deleted 17y ago
[deleted]
jacquesm 17y ago
typedef struct State { int state; int num; } State; int f(State* state, int n) { if (state->state == 0) { // initial call state->num = 0; if (state->num <= n) { state->state = 1; return state->num; } } if (state->num < n) { state->num++; return state->num; } return -1; } And technically you're using 'state' as though it is initialized to '0' anyway, so you might as well do the same for 'num' that changes the code to: int f(State* state, int n) { if (state->num < n) { return state->num++; } return -1; } Or am I missing something ? edit: that's what you get for coding before morning tea ;) edit2: shortened first code a bit further edit3: In javascript this is the closest that I can get to your python example: <script languge='JavaScript'> function f(s,limit) { if (typeof s.num == 'undefined') { s.num = 0; } if (s.num < limit || (s.num == 0 && limit ==0)) { return s.num++; } return -1; } g = {}; while ((t=f(g,10)) != -1) { document.writeln(t + "\n"); } </script> So that's one line extra to declare the variable holding the state for the generator. The 'undefined' trick is pretty gory, but it does do away with the 'location' variable or a need to initialize it. I take it that this does not generalize to your use case though, it is just a 'special case' solution for the python sample you gave, do you have a more complicated sample for a generator that would fail using this simplistic scheme ? Interesting thing you have on the go there, if you succeed in making a fully compatible in the browser version of python I think a lot of folks will be really happy, it would be the ideal learning tool, especially if it would have access to a canvas to draw on. That would be a really nice environment for kids to learn how to program.
apgwoz 17y ago
This is the type of thing you don't need goto for, if you have first class continuations, or properly optimized tail recursion. Continuations would allow you to write your own control structures in much the same way.
didroe 17y ago
Given the Python example in the article: def f(n): num = 0 while num < n: yield num num += 1 what's wrong with: function f(n) { var num = 0; return function () { if (num < n) { return num++; } } }
_ck_ 17y ago
Yeah but then you'd have to deal with raptor attacks http://xkcd.com/292 http://xkcd.com/292

3 points by s3graham 17y ago

deleted 17y ago

[deleted]

typedef struct State { int state; int num; } State; int f(State* state, int n) { if (state->state == 0) { // initial call state->num = 0; if (state->num <= n) { state->state = 1; return state->num; } } if (state->num < n) { state->num++; return state->num; } return -1; } And technically you're using 'state' as though it is initialized to '0' anyway, so you might as well do the same for 'num' that changes the code to: int f(State* state, int n) { if (state->num < n) { return state->num++; } return -1; } Or am I missing something ? edit: that's what you get for coding before morning tea ;) edit2: shortened first code a bit further edit3: In javascript this is the closest that I can get to your python example: <script languge='JavaScript'> function f(s,limit) { if (typeof s.num == 'undefined') { s.num = 0; } if (s.num < limit || (s.num == 0 && limit ==0)) { return s.num++; } return -1; } g = {}; while ((t=f(g,10)) != -1) { document.writeln(t + "\n"); } </script> So that's one line extra to declare the variable holding the state for the generator. The 'undefined' trick is pretty gory, but it does do away with the 'location' variable or a need to initialize it. I take it that this does not generalize to your use case though, it is just a 'special case' solution for the python sample you gave, do you have a more complicated sample for a generator that would fail using this simplistic scheme ? Interesting thing you have on the go there, if you succeed in making a fully compatible in the browser version of python I think a lot of folks will be really happy, it would be the ideal learning tool, especially if it would have access to a canvas to draw on. That would be a really nice environment for kids to learn how to program.

apgwoz 17y ago

This is the type of thing you don't need goto for, if you have first class continuations, or properly optimized tail recursion. Continuations would allow you to write your own control structures in much the same way.

didroe 17y ago

Given the Python example in the article: def f(n): num = 0 while num < n: yield num num += 1 what's wrong with: function f(n) { var num = 0; return function () { if (num < n) { return num++; } } }

_ck_ 17y ago

Yeah but then you'd have to deal with raptor attacks http://xkcd.com/292 http://xkcd.com/292