3 ms·
Both Thoreau and Spooner are out of date in numerous ways. When they wrote on the subject of voting: - Slavery was legal. - Votes were cast publicly (hence th
by snowwrestler 12y ago
Both Thoreau and Spooner are out of date in numerous ways. When they wrote on the subject of voting:
- Slavery was legal.
- Votes were cast publicly (hence the concerns about what is broadcast). The secret ballot was introduced into federal elections at the end of the 19th century, in part to address this concern.
- Only a subset of Americans could actually vote. In addition to the disenfranchisement inherent in slavery, women were denied the vote, and many states had poll requirements like property ownership, taxes, literacy, etc.
In addition, neither argued that people should not vote at all, but rather that a vote, by itself, is not sufficient to enforce morality, justify any given government action, or achieve justice. I agree with them on all of that.
But the argument against complacency in voting is not the same thing as arguing in favor of never voting.
In the end, you clearly don't want to vote, and that is fine with me--I don't think that anyone should be forced to vote!
But that's not the argument you made to kick off this subthread. You didn't say "I don't think I should vote" or "I don't want to vote" or "I think voting would make me feel less rational."
What you said is that "the vote changes nothing" and makes "the voter" less rational. That's a general argument about voting for any given person. I don't think you've proved that point, and I think you've stopped trying to.
edit: copy edits
- glenra 12y agoThat an individual vote changes nothing in the real world almost goes without saying - you can trivially compare the hypothetical world in which that person does vote to the one in which she doesn't. If and only if the outcome changes, marginal votes can be said to have "made a difference". The way it makes the voter less rational is that once you have voted for somebody you become emotionally invested in that candidate. If they lose, you now get to feel bad about their losing. if they win, you can either feel bad about their inevitable advocacy of bad policies and abandonment of election promises...or you can reconfigure your opinions so as to convince yourself that what they actually do is what ought to be done. Being personally invested in candidates makes people dumber. The fact that somebody voted for Obama makes it harder for them to see what a empty suit Obama has been as President; ditto for people who voted for Bush when he was in office. And neither the Bush voters nor the Obama voters can see how SIMILAR the two are. If you want to be able to assess politicians impartially, it's easier to do that if you didn't vote for them. When I cast a vote, I know for a fact that it won't change the outcome of the election but it will change ME. I should therefore only cast a vote if I want the change in myself that I expect that vote to cause.