3 ms·

Ask HN: Why HN doesn't allow markdown?

7 points by 666_howitzer 12y ago

markcrazyhorse 12y ago
I'm not certain but I think its because HN wishes to promote positive up voting not down vote trolling like reddit etc... If its good It will get up voted, if not then just don't upvote it.
- ColinWright 12y ago
  I think the question is about "Markdown," the formatting language. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Markdown http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Markdown http://daringfireball.net/projects/markdown/ http://daringfireball.net/projects/markdown/
  - markcrazyhorse 12y ago
    ah, sorry I read that wrong. I lose internet points dont I? :/
ColinWright 12y ago
What extra formatting would you want? And why? To some extent, fancy formatting only detracts from carefully reasoned arguments. Why clutter the page with more layout? What would you use, and why?
frou_dh 12y ago
The point of markdown is that it's supposed to be perfectly readable in "unrendered" form, so in a sense you can already use markdown in any plaintext context.
Spoom 12y ago
If I had to guess, I'd say it's because they want people to focus on the content of comments, and not their formatting.
noblethrasher 12y ago
Among other things, HN was a test case for programming in Arc, and mostly by one programmer: pg. So the likely reason that HN does not allow Markdown is because there is/was no Arc implementation of Markdown.
- mqsiuser 12y ago
  It is not that there is no markdown / formatting allowed. It just is, that it is so very very limited: https://news.ycombinator.com/formatdoc https://news.ycombinator.com/formatdoc Esp. the "no links in the text-field, but in the comments" It is successful :-) pg knows It would be easy to implement some more primitives (and make them translate into HTML) It MUST be intensional
  - noblethrasher 12y ago
    That logic doesn't quite work in this case. As of 131 day ago, pg was the main programmer on HN. So, while implementing Markdown is easy, it is also the case that: (1) He had very little time (2) Markdown was just one potentially easy feature among many other potentially easy feature. (3) As he stated many times, his focus was on reducing the amount of harmful comments.

7 points by 666_howitzer 12y ago

I'm not certain but I think its because HN wishes to promote positive up voting not down vote trolling like reddit etc... If its good It will get up voted, if not then just don't upvote it.

ColinWright 12y ago
I think the question is about "Markdown," the formatting language. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Markdown http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Markdown http://daringfireball.net/projects/markdown/ http://daringfireball.net/projects/markdown/
- markcrazyhorse 12y ago
  ah, sorry I read that wrong. I lose internet points dont I? :/

ColinWright 12y ago

What extra formatting would you want? And why? To some extent, fancy formatting only detracts from carefully reasoned arguments. Why clutter the page with more layout? What would you use, and why?

frou_dh 12y ago

The point of markdown is that it's supposed to be perfectly readable in "unrendered" form, so in a sense you can already use markdown in any plaintext context.

Spoom 12y ago

If I had to guess, I'd say it's because they want people to focus on the content of comments, and not their formatting.

noblethrasher 12y ago

Among other things, HN was a test case for programming in Arc, and mostly by one programmer: pg. So the likely reason that HN does not allow Markdown is because there is/was no Arc implementation of Markdown.

mqsiuser 12y ago
It is not that there is no markdown / formatting allowed. It just is, that it is so very very limited: https://news.ycombinator.com/formatdoc https://news.ycombinator.com/formatdoc Esp. the "no links in the text-field, but in the comments" It is successful :-) pg knows It would be easy to implement some more primitives (and make them translate into HTML) It MUST be intensional
- noblethrasher 12y ago
  That logic doesn't quite work in this case. As of 131 day ago, pg was the main programmer on HN. So, while implementing Markdown is easy, it is also the case that: (1) He had very little time (2) Markdown was just one potentially easy feature among many other potentially easy feature. (3) As he stated many times, his focus was on reducing the amount of harmful comments.