3 ms·
Dawkins problem is that people stopped asking him for his expertise and started asking for his opinion. He is the victim of society's willingness to appeal to a
by onion2k 12y ago
Dawkins problem is that people stopped asking him for his expertise and started asking for his opinion. He is the victim of society's willingness to appeal to authority[1]. While he's a fantastic scientist and thinker on the topic evolutionary biology, he isn't a particularly great communicator when it comes to everything else. Outside of his subject he doesn't explain his ideas well enough. He should be communicating at the sort of level a layman would need in order to understand what he's talking about, but instead he leaves giant gaping holes in his arguments because he doesn't feel he needs to explain himself in. Consequently he's often misunderstood.
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argument_from_authority#Appeal_to_non-authorities http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argument_from_authority#Appeal_...
- revdinosaur 12y agoI would argue that his ideas, outside his domain, are not communicated well because they are not well-formed. Criticizing him for being boorish and ill-informed about social issues does not take away from him being an accomplished biologist. Assuming that he's just botching the expression of an otherwise worthwhile thought is furthering that appeal to his inappropriate authority.