5 ms·
The future of MIT education looks more global, modular, and flexible
- minimaxir 12y ago> The report recommends that MIT explore more modular approaches to teaching — both online and on-campus. Data from the first 17 MITx and HarvardX courses indicate that only about 5 percent of registrants earn a certificate of completion. I am suspicious of this claim because I recently did an analysis of this data: http://minimaxir.com/2014/07/online-class-charts/ http://minimaxir.com/2014/07/online-class-charts/ The average amount of students who complete classes that they've registered for is about 3.4%, much lower than they indicate: http://minimaxir.com/img/online-class-charts/class-attendance.png http://minimaxir.com/img/online-class-charts/class-attendanc...
- dm2 12y agoI'm one of those people who registers for several online classes but never finish them, or many times never participate at all. It would be helpful if they offered a "degree" of some kind for completing groups of classes. Mixing it with the concept of gamification like Khan Academy does might also help with participation.
- MisterBastahrd 12y agoThere's at least one MOOC offering "nanodegrees" for completing a series of classes, but charging $150 a month to participate is a bit on the high side for something that most employers won't care about. There's a bit of a divide between the benefit of education in general and whether that education will have a meaningful impact on your financial bottom line in the long run.
- damian2000 12y agoEdX offers the "x-series" - https://www.edx.org/xseries https://www.edx.org/xseries - and Coursera offers "specialisations" - https://www.coursera.org/specializations https://www.coursera.org/specializations - they're charged per course. According to them, when you pay the $50+ per course, your completion rate goes up dramatically, to something like 70% - probably due to the fact you've paid something for it.
- incision 12y ago>'It would be helpful if they offered a "degree" of some kind for completing groups of classes.' They do. EdX - xSeries [1] Coursera - Specializations [2] Udacity - Nanodegrees [3] Obviously, no one agrees on what to call these groups. Worse, the length, cost and schedules are equally disparate which isn't a problem specific to groups, but the state of MOOCs in general. One group offering might be 7 classes at $50 each, with each class covering 8 weeks with an estimated effort of 8-10 hours per week. Another is 9 classes at $50 each, with each class covering 4 weeks with an estimated effort of as little as 3-4 hours per week. One group can be completed in as little as three months, another requires a minimum of 3 years. 1: https://www.edx.org/xseries https://www.edx.org/xseries 2: https://www.coursera.org/specializations?utm_medium=topnav https://www.coursera.org/specializations?utm_medium=topnav 3: https://www.udacity.com/nanodegrees https://www.udacity.com/nanodegrees
- frozenport 12y agoWhats worse is the poor quality of the course content compared to the real thing. MOOCs are something else, they should be in the same category as a YouTube video.
- cjrd 12y agoRoger Grosse and I (Colorado Reed) were just chatting about this article: we created http://www.metacademy.org http://www.metacademy.org with this goal in mind. Recently, we've been discussing the future of Metacademy and how we can better work towards building an open, flexible, and modular educational system. I'd love to hear any ideas (if you're in Berkeley, I'm also open for a coffee-chat on this topic!)
- hliyan 12y agoThis is great. I was wondering whether it's possible to have a more formal way of scheduling studying and marking progress (beyond the checkmark, I mean) -- like the ability to create a prioritized list of concepts, set some dates and track completion. And maybe maintain my own little summary notes and maybe even check others' publicly shared notes?
- cjrd 12y agoGreat point - the checkmark is a trivial attempt: quizzes would be better, and as you mentioned, a review schedule. And the "notes" idea is fantastic (or maybe even flashcards with an Anki-like review schedule); we discussed it several months ago but it fell off the radar. Thanks for the thoughtful feedback!
- incision 12y agoVery nice. I'll be using this. * At a glance, some sort of automated progress tracker would be my first request. I'm certain that I'll end up missing sections and/or losing my place and drifting away as long as it's manual. * Offering an estimate time to completion is great. Leveraging those estimates to give me an option to select 'something that will fit in 5/15/60 minutes' from my current topics would be even better. * The site snaps, that's great. * Creating a TOC of the off-site content (video, books) in the overview of each roadmap would be nice. If I decide that I'm going to commit to follow one of these roads I'm going to be looking to source the books and download the videos so that I can watch them on the subway. * Interactive 'exercises' where possible. This is a major plus of the EdX courses I've done - submitting results or complete Python code and getting instant feedback. * Suggested background / prerequisites for a roadmap would be nice as well.
- incision 12y ago>'The report also suggests that MIT consider offering different levels of certification through its online-learning ventures, MITx and edX, and recommends that the Institute redouble its commitment to access and affordability — possibly by increasing MIT’s undergraduate population, which has remained stable for decades despite increasing demand, or by providing flexibility to allow students to complete a traditional undergraduate degree in less than four years.' Personally, I'd hope to see 'differing levels of certification' expanded to the point of offering credit courses for distance learning. Go ahead and differentiate it further from the residential brand than MITx if necessary. I've watched hours and hours of OCW, and completed several courses on MITx with a handful more scheduled for the fall. As a rule, these courses are far more challenging and just plain better than what I pay quite a bit to my state University for. I would jump at the opportunity to pay MIT many multiples more than the pittance they charge for ID Verified courses on EdX in order to take MIT born credit courses. >'The report recommends that MIT explore more modular approaches to teaching — both online and on-campus. Data from the first 17 MITx and HarvardX courses indicate that only about 5 percent of registrants earn a certificate of completion. This and other edX data, the report says, suggest that “students are focused more on learning certain elements of a class and less on completing what has traditionally been considered a module or unit of learning.”' I can't say I agree with drawing or even supporting that conclusion from the poor completion rates. I think the overall completion rates are effectively meaningless - signing up is trivial and instant. I did some crunching of the older stats EdX released a while back and from my foggy recollection even the tiniest measures of intent correlate with dramatically higher completion. More modular courses aren't going to help the 35% of people who sign up but never even look at the courseware - it's already modular for all they know. >'These edX results are in keeping with surveys of MIT’s own faculty and students: In a 2013 survey, 25 percent of MIT faculty, and 40 percent of MIT students, indicated that some of the Institute’s course offerings might benefit from being broken up into smaller modules.' >'The unbundling of classes also reflects a larger trend in society — a number of other media offerings have become available in modules, whether it is a song from an album, an article from a newspaper, or a chapter from a textbook.”' I can't say I agree with the idea of 'unbundling' courses much at all. Personally, getting a 'holistic' understanding of the subject is precisely why I'm pursuing a degree and why I chose to work through books or MOOC courses as opposed browsing tutorials or StackOverflow posts as-needed. I didn't always feel this way. I self taught myself into a career well above my apparent station in life and felt supremely confident that I could go on picking and choosing, learning whatever I needed to know next. Eventually, I realized that the gaps in what I knew did just hold missing facts or techniques, they constituted missing questions too. Things I didn't even know to ask. That's the value of a 'complete' course and education - the foundation and supporting framework that ensures you can always keep building. Interestingly, the median age of people taking courses on EdX is 23-30 and the median age of on-campus students is surely below that. I didn't reach the above epiphany until I was 28 or 29, well into a respectable tower of a career. It would not surprise me if the people who might think they want for $0.99 singles of education are following the same course.
- ottonomy 12y agoThe idea of breaking down courses is really interesting to me, because I think a "course" is a great way to organize content in a field. Let an expert guide you through a series of perspectives. But completing them often takes more dedication than most busy people can muster. By breaking courses down to a more granular level of components, there is a huge chance to recognize people for the pieces they are able to complete and let them string those together in new ways that the traditional course designers hadn't thought of. But there are huge challenges around figuring out how different modules could be fit together into new ways. For instance, the Open Educational Resource repositories have had really slow adoption because of it, even though they have in total a ton of great educational content (and quantities of chaff). I wrote a little bit more about this today, and how digital badges could help a provider like edX crowdsource good organization of many distributed modules. http://remediatingassessment.blogspot.com/2014/08/mit-report-questions-fitness-of-course-metaphor.html http://remediatingassessment.blogspot.com/2014/08/mit-report... I think it's really all about switching to a different metaphor for organizing content and examining the entailments of that metaphor to make sure their internal logic leads you to the values you want to promote.
- mrcactu5 12y agothis is very progressive, but in the MOOC era, schools have also moved much of their content to be accessible only to their students. Education is becoming more open, but also more closed.