6 ms·
How the Web Became Our ‘External Brain,’ and What It Means for Our Kids
- throwaway7808 12y agoDream on. Most likely you and your kids are gonna be wiped out by intellegent machines just in a few decades.
- walterbell 12y agoOr some other kid's human-augmenting machines will make irrelevant the "intelligent" machines.
- c23gooey 12y agoI dont understand how this article can claim that our brains are malleable, but then go on to claim that our children's brain will be wired differently to ours. Surely those two points are incongruous.
- goodcanadian 12y agoYoung brains are extremely malleable. Our brains grow (and we learn fastest) during infancy and toddler-hood with a second, less impressive, burst during adolescence. So, our children's brains are malleable in the sense that they readily adjust to this new reality while their brains are growing fastest, but since the reality during their most formative years is different from the reality during our formative years, their brains will be wired differently. One could argue that this happens to a certain extent with every generation, however, and it is not necessarily a new thing. One might also argue that as technology changes faster, the inter-generational gap grows larger. One might also argue that while our adult brains change more slowly than a toddler brain, they do keep changing which might mean the difference is not so large after all. Interesting questions to be sure.
- walterbell 12y agoNote that evolution depends on random mutations. What's the techno-environmental equivalent to random mutations? Remix culture, open-source software, fan fiction, fair use, cross-corporate IP licensing, emergent outcomes of search engine SEO and Google's top ten revenue categories? If we are going to expose children to technology, should we expose them to open-ended technology with many degrees of freedom and possible innovation, or walled gardens/devices with a limited menu of pre-approved operations?
- imgabe 12y agoHow the Written Word Became Our 'External Brain' and What It Means for Our Kids
- cle 12y agoFrom the article: "Some experts expressed concerns that trends are leading to a future in which most people become shallow consumers of information, endangering society." A key part of this argument is that people are becoming (or are going to become) more shallow than those in the past. But how shallow were people in the past? I have a sneaky suspicion that many of these dissenters are just being nostalgic. Anything beyond their own lifespan is also questionable--how do we know how well people were able to focus in previous generations? Are people _really_ more shallow than they used to be, or does it just feel like that? This whole topic incredibly nebulous, so I question the value of jumping to these conclusions when we don't even have a clear understanding of what we're talking about in the first place.
- sriku 12y agoI recall reading somewhere that when books were invented, people thought they'd degrade the mental ability of people to accumulate and hold "wisdom". Did that happen? And even before that, when writing was first invented, it was some kind of devil magic. Now, where might I begin finding out where this might've been said?
- mjklin 12y ago...but when they came to the letters, “This invention, O king,” said Theuth, “will make the Egyptians wiser and will improve their memories; for it is an elixir of memory and wisdom that I have discovered.” But Thamus replied, “Most ingenious Theuth, one man has the ability to beget arts, but the ability to judge of their usefulness or harmfulness to their users belongs to another; and now you, who are the father of letters, have been led by your affection to ascribe to them a power the opposite of that which they really possess. “For this invention will produce forgetfulness in the minds of those who learn to use it, because they will not practice their memory. Their trust in writing, produced by external characters which are no part of themselves, will discourage the use of their own memory within them. You have invented an elixir not of memory, but of reminding; and you offer your pupils the appearance of wisdom, not true wisdom, for they will read many things without instruction and will therefore seem to know many things, when they are for the most part ignorant and hard to get along with, since they are not wise, but only appear wise.” (Plato, Phaedrus 274c-275b)
- dm2 12y agoWhat will also be interesting is how it will affect education. We were all told we have to memorize things because we can't carry the textbook around with us, that's simply not true anymore. Filling our brains with dates for civil war battles and the dates of birth/death of random authors was completely pointless. I think that more critical thinking style education will certainly be a good thing. Educational material should focus much more on how to keep kids interested in the material rather than making sure you know every detail of every event. I think the educational system needs a major overhaul. Let kids learn the subjects that interest them at their own pace rather than constant exposure to random bits and pieces. Or at least try it, now that technology is so cheap and powerful we can track and allow access to everything imaginable for education (other than instant learning, but it's probably not too far off). If I had something like Khan Academy and a tablet in school it would be amazing. Now would be a great time to be starting school, you still need teachers and parents that are willing to inspire and know how to appeal to the interests of children of course.
- justizin 12y agoright, but not committing any of history to memory, collectively, makes it pretty easy to rewrite.
- dm2 12y agoWhat do you mean? Learning date ranges is important, what years the wars started and ended (approximately), what period of time an author was born (1700s, 1800s, etc). Knowing a specific date and being tested on knowing that exact number is completely pointless. If you fill your head with dates that you do not recall often, then they can often get confused, you think you remember what date something happened and spit out the wrong one.
- ef4 12y agoNo, history is all about writing. That's pretty much its definition. The invention of history happened precisely when people decided to start writing things down for the future. We prevent the rewriting of history by distributing the writing as widely as possible. And that's precisely what the internet is doing.
- joshstrange 12y agoI've thought for quite some time now (last 5+ years, which as a 23yro seems like a long time) as the internet as an extension of my brain. I've joked to friends that I simply keep a small "cache" of "pointers" in my brain to the internet where I know I can find the information if I need it but I have little use to memorize the details. I fully understand that if the internet were to disappear tomorrow that I would be very lost but it's not something worth preparing for IMHO. While I agree with preparing for the future I do not think preparing for the fall of humanity/technology to be a good use of my time. Call me naive or stupid (or lazy), you may be right, but I find little advantage in remembering large swatches of information when it can be called up (from either local copy or the internet) at will. It's one reason I vehemently opposed the C++ exams I took in college that required me to know the boilerplate of a C++ program as there would never be a time in my life that I could imagine I would be without an IDE or the internet to generate/fetch it for me. I'm not saying that I think this is a "more advanced" way of living/existing but just that it is the way I live/exist. I have friends who have expressed similar feelings but I'd be very interested in what both people older and younger and I think/feel about this issue.
- WhoBeI 12y agoThe human brain is incredible at making connections and finding patterns. When you feed more and more information into the brain and think about it the potential for better, more accurate and more profound connections increase. You see an apple fall from a tree and understand how the planets move around the sun. What worries me is that your "pointer latency" makes it increasingly difficult to get those aha moments. Vast amounts of knowledge at our fingertips but very little understanding and wisdom. As for education systems, I (mostly) agree with this dude: http://www.ted.com/talks/ken_robinson_says_schools_kill_creativity http://www.ted.com/talks/ken_robinson_says_schools_kill_crea... I'm one of the older btw :) 35yro.
- grrowl 12y agoWhile some say "shallow knowledge", I say "abstracted knowledge"; just like the jump from straight-up experience to discussion to writing to books to public libraries, we can "fill in the blanks" with reasonable accuracy while upgrading to an exponentially larger breadth of information.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoI wonder how much IQ I gain from the web. Anybody done that experiment? Take an IQ test with and without access to the web.
- sosuke 12y agoI would imagine it to be pretty difficult to search for those shapes.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoMost IQ tests use standard questions in different combinations. So maybe not so hard? Find the image, then find the page its featured on, maybe find the answer.
- DLister 12y agoDepends does farming out the questions to mechanical turk count? Or would that be more a hive minds cumulative IQ?
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoTotally! Access to the web is the issue to be tested; not my skill at research.
- ssivark 12y agoImho, while it is not important to blindly memorize data, it is difficult to build mental models if you don't hold some information in your brain. For starters, it is not quite feasible to have all the information be stored in a secondary location (the internet/cloud) but have your brain process that information to make conclusions, to the best of its ability. Even if it were possible, in such a situation, a person would be completely dependent on the source of information, and could be easily misled by a wrong resource -- because they might have little primary data developed from their experience of the world, on which to base their decision making -- in a sense, how does one develop a sense of whether or not to believe something one reads on the internet, without regard to the reputation of the source? This is an example of what I would call critical thinking. If one is always used to having the information at one's fingertips, then how does one acquire the ability to "figure things out"? Isaac Asimov touches on something along these lines in his wonderful story -- "Profession" ( http://www.abelard.org/asimov.php http://www.abelard.org/asimov.php )
- walterbell 12y agoGreat quote from the Asimov story: "It won’t do to say to a man, ‘You can create. Do so.’ It is much safer to wait for a man to say, ‘I can create, and I will do so whether you wish it or not.’" Memory training speeds up the recognition of design patterns, http://www.patternlanguage.com/ http://www.patternlanguage.com/ .. and anti-patterns, http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/TruthAndLies http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/TruthAndLies