5 ms·
I think we need to ask: Who would own the copyright had it been another human who pressed the button? - One human sets up the camera -- another frames the sho
by Alupis 12y ago
I think we need to ask:
Who would own the copyright had it been another human who pressed the button?
- One human sets up the camera -- another frames the shot and takes the shot.
I would say the second human who framed and shot the image is the copyright holder... meaning the monkey would own the copyright had the monkey been human... but since the monkey is not human (and copyright only applies to humans), then it's public domain.
- curiousgeorgio 12y agoIf the second human didn't know a camera was involved (or what a camera even is), but had instead found a wireless remote control shutter release in his/her possession, and, not knowing what it was, proceeded to inadvertently take photos because the remote made a fun sound (as in the case with the monkey), then I think it'd be safe to say the second human had no involvement with the resulting photos. We're not talking about a monkey (or human) framing and taking photos. We're talking about a monkey pressing a button because it makes an interesting sound. There is no authorship there.
- Alupis 12y ago> There is no authorship there. Then why are we assigning authorship to a human? Just because he happened to be there? (Also, I can make a song on a guitar without knowing what it is nor how to play it -- I still hold copyright over my work).
- ASneakyFox 12y agoIn that case I claim ownership. As far as I can tell I did the same level of creative input as mr batteries. So I should be just as entitled to the work.
- davidgerard 12y agoLegal precedent is clear: it's who frames the shot and presses the button. Since the entity framing the shot and pressing the button is the monkey, but non-human animals can't own a copyright, no copyright is generated. It routinely explodes people's heads that copyright law works like it actually works, not like people wish it did.