3 ms·
Doesn't the monkey technically own copyright over the images? I mean.. just because it's this guy's camera doesn't mean he has copyright, unless the monkey tran
by Alupis 12y ago
Doesn't the monkey technically own copyright over the images? I mean.. just because it's this guy's camera doesn't mean he has copyright, unless the monkey transferred copyright to him via some sort of agreement.
- viggity 12y agoCopyright isn't assigned to the tool owner, it is assigned to the person who created the work. I use Visual Studio, that doesn't make the code I write owned by Microsoft even they "own" Visual Studio. Bad analogy, but you get the point.
- autarch 12y agoActually, I think it's a very good analogy. Here's another. If I leave my laptop running Visual Studio out and a monkey bangs on the keyboard to make a program (by accident, just as with this photo), I don't own the copyright to that program.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoYou do if its your monkey!
- swah 12y agoWhat if the monkey just press F8 and build it and that is the version you release?
- jnevill 12y agoOwnership is clearly stated as "Person", which a monkey is not.
- tmzt 12y agoBut a corporation is?
- tadfisher 12y agoThere is no "technically" about it, as the right of animals to hold intellectual property has yet to be affirmed in a court.
- guan 12y agoThe US Copyright Compendium states that “authorship”, which is a prerequisite for copyright, requires a human author. In previous cases copyright in natural patterns such as wood patterns has been rejected. If the purported author is a non-human animal, then there can’t be copyright (in the US). http://www.copyrightcompendium.com/#202.02(b) http://www.copyrightcompendium.com/#202.02(b) The Compendium reflects the rulings of the Copyright Office and a court might see things differently. Or the Copyright Office might agree that this photograph was not authored by the human. If they don’t agree, then at the very least you can’t register the copyright and get statutory damages. (Unless you sue the Copyright Office to force them to register.)
- voidlogic 12y agoThen is sounds like wikipedia is correct, a non-human took the photo, that is not disputed, not a human author, therefore the prerequisite for copyright is not met and the image is public domain.