4 ms·
One voter has little effect. Many voters together can have a big effect. But not if each one of them, individually, decides not to bother.
by snowwrestler 12y ago
One voter has little effect. Many voters together can have a big effect. But not if each one of them, individually, decides not to bother.
- pitt1980 12y agothere are many many uses of my time that can affect changes to make the world a better place if nothing else I can spend that time being a better parent and spouse voting ranks extremely low on the active uses of my time to make the world a better place
- snowwrestler 12y agoVoting takes little time (about 15-30 minutes in my precinct) but has a lasting effect for years. Measured on a per-minute basis, there are few ways you can have as large an impact as voting.
- pitt1980 12y agolittle time, and even less impact
- glenra 12y agoWhat "lasting effect" does it have, given that the vote changes nothing? Are you just referring to the effect it has on the voter, which is that it makes him or her a bit less rational?
- snowwrestler 12y agoI don't think it's very rational to say that a vote "changes nothing," but I also don't think there's anything I could post that would change your mind, so I guess we'll just agree to disagree on this one.
- glenra 12y agoAt a national level, the chance of your vote changing the outcome is less than your chance of being struck by lightning or killed by a plane falling on you. Most votes aren't even close at all - you knew what candidate your state would pick going in and it picked that by a margin of, say, a million votes. But hey, let's suppose one of those few, rare, much less than once-in-a-lifetime cases comes up where the vote is so close that your one vote WOULD make a difference. In that case we can say two things: (1) that outcome is closer than the margin of error on our vote-counting technology, so the outcome will actually get decided in the courts (2) If the country is THAT divided between the two candidates, they're probably so similarly positioned on the {net good/net bad} scale that your vote didn't really matter then either - you got to pick which of two functionally-identical candidates we got. (or if they're not, they're close ENOUGH that you have no way of being sure you made the right choice between them - you'd do as well to flip a coin. Rationally speaking, the effect of voting for a candidate is identical to the effect of rooting for a sports team. It does nothing to modify the outcome of the match, but it does make YOU have a bit more ego invested in whoever you picked.
- snowwrestler 12y agoThese sort of comparisons are often trotted out in voting arguments, but they are a misapplication of probability because a vote is not something that happens to you, it is something you do. And because votes are fungible, there is no way to pick out one vote and say that it mattered more than any other. The issue is not chance, it is apportionment: to what degree can you claim responsibility for the final outcome of an election? And what you're saying is that in elections where your portion is very small, you don't think it's worth participating. To me this seems like a rather self-centered approach to civic engagement, essentially saying "I won't participate in any process that does not sufficiently validate my importance." And is there a value at which you would think it is worth participating? That would imply that the smaller and less consequential the election, the more likely it is that you would participate. That seems like a weird way to set priorities. And it's worth noting that no matter how small each portion may be, it will still be larger than the portion of those who did not vote at all. The argument from small apportionment also assumes that everyone else still votes (that's why the portion is so small, after all). So it can't work as a general argument against the utility of voting. In fact if everyone tried to follow that strategy, any defector would wield enormous power, as one of few people bothering to vote.