9 ms·
Things Political Scientists Know (2010) [pdf]
- soneca 12y agoAnd the clickbait-title virus contaminates academic papers.
- tboyd47 12y ago"People would probably be better off if they knew more than they do about a lot of things (or at least, I am assuming so, though there is research on this sort of thing). Politics might, however, be the last thing on that list... and yet, politics is the one area in which we get irritated when other people are apathetic or ignorant." In America, anyway -- I don't know about other democratic countries -- this is so true. And as an apathetic person, let me say that it's so satisfying to hear a voice in political science say it. People seem to have this superstitious obsession with the democratic ritual. The act of filling in a circle in a ballot box is so important to them that they just cannot accept the fact that someone would choose not to participate. This way of thinking makes less sense to me than someone who's fanatic about a sports team. If you tell a fan of a football team that you don't watch football, at least he'll respect this about you. Try telling some party activist that you don't vote and see if they ever let it go. Edit: my post is being downvoted to oblivion anyway, but removed some hyperbolic language that wasn't helping my case.
- JoeAltmaier 12y ago"Completely symbolic and pointless"? I call cynicism.
- innguest 12y agoIt's symbolic because you can only choose who to vote on out of the options presented to you. It's pointless because (at least in the US) the government has too much power and it sells that power to lobbyists.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoUS Government is only a tiny fraction of whom I vote for. From State officials through City and County, School Board, even Township and Water Board. All of them affect me, including my tax rates and property rights.
- tboyd47 12y agoFair enough. "Completely symbolic and pointless" was a tad too far.
- innguest 12y ago> All of them affect me And none of them really care about you, which can be evidenced by the amount of corruption that goes on everywhere. Also, "voting" is inherently dumb because it's just "majority wins". Shouldn't the best outcome win? Why can't we have a system where we argue things out and have some heuristics for finding out what the best decision is for a given group of people? Are you sure voting for representatives, as we currently do, is the best possible way to run countries, states, cities? If not, where are we trying to find better ways? Can you then see why some don't see the value in "voting"?
- NotAtWork 12y ago> Why can't we have a system where we argue things out and have some heuristics for finding out what the best decision is for a given group of people? We do this. We just haven't resolved two fundamental problems: 1. The heuristics are not faithfully stated nor evaluated. This actually has upsides and downsides, as it allows them to be unexpectedly flexible and comprehensive at the cost of some corruption and unpredictability. This may just be a fundamental trade-off of such metrics. The heuristics are just currently embodied in little sacks of meat with some extra processes happening, because of stand-alone computers being a relatively new thing. (I'm actually not sure how much better with regards to lack of corruption and transparency we could make the heuristics than "just pick a guy to choose", because of limits in decidability and other related computer science/math.) 2. We don't know any way to define 'best outcome' besides ask everyone what they think, and resolve conflicts with some kind of strategy like "go with what the most people think is the right answer". So I really don't understand your position: it's essentially that you don't see value in participating in which heuristics are chosen, and think that people should pay more attention to your wants and desires, even if you don't advocate for them with the same strength as other people. Honestly, your position mostly sounds poorly thought out and entitled.
- erehweb 12y agoAre you apathetic to: - whether your fellow countrymen go to war? - who gets to marry? - abortion rights? If you are, then that's your right, but please don't act surprised when people who care about these things get irritated.
- tboyd47 12y agoWhat I am apathetic to is which liar gets elected into office, the red liar or the blue liar? What surprises me is that people seem to have an irrational trust in these political figures.
- snowwrestler 12y agoWho trusts political figures? Repeated polling shows that most people don't, even if they vote. Maybe you're down on voting because you think it's supposed to solve all the problems. So since it doesn't, it must be broken. The truth is that voting is just a very small part of trying to make the world look more like you think it should. It's like developing a software application. No one would expect that buying a computer would take care of everything. But you can't start until you have a computer. And while the computer isn't everything, some are still going to be better for what you want than others.
- tboyd47 12y agoIf you vote for a certain candidate, that's a sign that you believe he's going to act a certain way in office. And unless you know him personally, that can only be based on what he said on the campaign trail. So the fact that you voted for him shows that you at least trusted him to do what he said he would do.
- snowwrestler 12y agoRemember that you can often vote for or against officials running for re-election, in which case you can vote based on their actual record of work. Many challengers have records of work by which to judge them as well.
- MarkPNeyer 12y agopolitics is the primary mechanism by which society regulates its emotion. people get emotional when you say that you don't follow politics because that is how the 'politics' mechanism operates. people express anger outwards - at the out groups who are seen as 'not helping' - and upwards, where it is packaged and managed by people who are capable of handling intensely powerful emotions - many of them are sociopaths, who simply don't care. try watching house of cards with the 'politics as emotional transfer mechanism' model running. see how many decisions are made on the basis of creating or moving jobs. having a job makes people calm. not having a job makes them worried. you can start to view the capital building as the 'central emotional processor' of the nation, where emotions are packed up in intense chunks and moved around between people who believe they are just trying to get more power, but are effectively reducing emotional tension.
- tboyd47 12y agoNice analysis.
- aestra 12y agoPeople tend to think the things they really care about should be universal. You see it all the time here with the "everyone should learn how to program" camp.
- jobu 12y ago"Is the Tea Party a “real” movement, or is it “astroturf”? The speed at which this debate is bouncing around partisan circles is shocking, considering how silly the question is. If a movement is astroturf if some outside force is organizing it, then all movements are astroturf." This seems like a non-sequitur. Grassroots vs astroturf movements differ based on what's in the best self-interest of the majority of it's members. Or in some cases, astroturf means they actually have no members - only PR specialists bombarding politicians and newspapers with letters from supposedly "real people".
- randallsquared 12y ago> Grassroots vs astroturf movements differ based on what's in the best self-interest of the majority of it's members. I'm not sure what you mean by this. It sounds like you plan to calculate the "best self-interest" of members of a group, and then distinguish by whether the group's aims appear to further the result of your assessment. Is that right?
- jobu 12y agoThe article is probably right about it being difficult to define what is in the best interests of a large group, but it seems pretty obvious that civil-rights movements are by definition in the best self-interest of the majority of their members. (Think the women's suffrage movement of the early 1900's, the racial equality movement in the 1960s, or the current marriage rights movement for LGBT couples.) The Tea Party seems a little harder to tell. Some are obviously in it for fiscal self-interest (upper and middle class people that want lower taxes). However, there are some in the Tea Party because they fear government intervention even though they obviously benefit from Social Security, Medicare, etc. (At least some of that is caused by fear mongering and twisted truths from Tea Party leaders.)
- Millennium 12y agoBut who defines the self-interest of the majority of the membership? Tea Party proponents and opponents, when taken as groups, seem to have very different visions of what constitutes the self-interest of Tea Party members.
- frequentflyeru 12y agoI'll just wait for the buzzfeed version.
- asgard1024 12y agoThis seems to me as a "standard" intelectual-elitist paper which tries to insinuate that democracy, where people really decide the issues, cannot work. I haven't read it very deeply but the fact that he quotes Walter Lippmann says that lot. Also, I think he misrepresents Arrow's theorem. First of all, it applies only to ordering of preferences; if you allow preferences to be number from interval, such as range voting does, there is no problem. Second, the non-dictatorship criterion is a bit disingenuous, because who is dictator depends on their own preferences - just like majority vote is not "dictatorship of the majority".
- jarin 12y agoI gotta say, I'm impressed by how you've turned "intelectual" into a pejorative.
- asgard1024 12y agoI really didn't - I wrote "intelectual-elitist". It's their choice to have disgusting opinions. Perhaps I am too cynical, I have been reading too much Chomsky lately. :-) Edit: Let me give you a Chomsky quote: "Actually, I should say, the term "manufacturing consent" is not mine, I took it from Walter Lippmann, the leading public intellectual and leading media figure of the twentieth century, who thought it was a great idea. He said we should manufacture consent, that's the way democracies should work. There should be a small group of powerful people, and the rest of the population should be spectators, and you should force them to consent by controlling, regimenting their minds. That's the leading idea of democratic theorists, and the public relations industry and so on, so I'm not making it up. In fact, I'm just borrowing their conception, and telling other people what they think." This is what the paper appears to be advocating, as well.
- diziet 12y agoAccording to game theory in a two party system the two candidates will tend to converge in the middle (assuming single issue distribution).