3 ms·
The following quoted paragraph may illustrate the degree to which the court sided with Klinger and against the Conan Doyle Estate: http://media.ca7.uscourts.gov
by nkurz 12y ago
The following quoted paragraph may illustrate the degree to which the court sided with Klinger and against the Conan Doyle Estate:
http://media.ca7.uscourts.gov/cgi-bin/rssExec.pl?Submit=Display&Path=Y2014/D08-04/C:14-1128:J:Posner:aut:T:op:N:1392405:S:0 http://media.ca7.uscourts.gov/cgi-bin/rssExec.pl?Submit=Disp...
"The Doyle estate’s business strategy is plain: charge a modest license fee for which there is no legal basis, in the hope that the “rational” writer or publisher asked for the fee will pay it rather than incur a greater cost, in legal expenses, in challenging the legality of the demand. The strategy had worked with Random House; Pegasus was ready to knuckle under; only Klinger (so far as we know) resisted. In effect he was a private attorney general, combating a disreputable business practice—a form of extortion—and he is seeking by the present motion not to obtain a reward but merely to avoid a loss. He has performed a public service—and with substantial risk to himself, for had he lost he would have been out of pocket for the $69,803.37 in fees and costs incurred at the trial and appellate levels ($30,679.93 + $39,123.44). The willingness of someone in Klinger’s position to sue rather than pay Doyle’s estate a modest license fee is important because it injects risk into the estate’s business model. As a result of losing the suit, the estate has lost its claim to own copyrights in characters in the Sherlock Holmes stories published by Arthur Conan Doyle before 1923. For exposing the estate’s unlawful business strategy, Klinger deserves a reward but asks only to break even."
Note that the above is the official opinion of the court, and not just that of Klinger and his attorney. And although only citing it as a quoted example, Posner makes it clear that he feels Warner Brothers is using the same strategy with "Happy Birthday":
"Depoorter and Walker (id. at 345 n. 172) give the example of the Summy-Brichard Company, a subsidiary of Warner Music Group, which “receives approximately $2 million per year in royalty payments for licenses to the song ‘Happy Birthday to You,’ despite the fact that the song is most likely in the public domain,” as argued in Robert Brauneis, “Copyright and the World’s Most Popular Song,” 56 J. Copyright Society U.S.A. 335, 338–40 (2009.)
- HillRat 12y agoMy God, I love Posner's opinions, even a trivial one like this. You have to appreciate the part where he calls out the estate as having "enlisted [Amazon and other booksellers] in a boycott of a competitor of the state, and boycotts of competitors violate the anti-trust laws. ... It's time the estate, in its own self-interest, changed its business model." Ouch.
- dredmorbius 12y agoThe point is that this isn't a trivial decision. Thought it's only a very small slap on the flagrant abuses and extensions of copyright over the past century and more.
- HillRat 12y agoTrivial only in the sense that there was no question Klinger had the right to recover under 17 USC§505; the decision on the case itself was obviously more important. Even then, though, it was obvious the estate had no case in regards to the out-of-copyright work, and their argument was laughably specious. If their theory had won out, judges would be called upon to do double duty as literary critics, which no sane jurist would go anywhere near. (When a judge calls your appeal "bordering on quixotic," you aren't facing a sympathetic bench.) It is important to note that the lower court did find that the use of elements from in-copyright stories (such as Watson's athletic background, or Holmes' retirement from detective work) would constitute infringement, and that such elements were incremental expressions that were protectable. My expectation is that, until the entire canon is out of copyright, publishers will continue to pay the estate rather than have to run the risk of an author illegally if inadvertently importing still-copyrighted aspects into a story.