9 ms·
Ethereum pre-sale hits 12.7M$, still 27 days to go
- Kiro 12y agoHow do I buy it?
- joeyspn 12y agoGo to www.ethereum.org and follow the steps in the homepage. You'll need some bitcoin to buy it (fiat not accepted)...
- IkmoIkmo 12y agoIt's NOT an investment. It's a developer resource, e.g. if you're a programmer or company looking to build an ethereum project. If you don't even know how to buy it (i.e. you haven't a clue what ethereum is, that they have 1 website with all their information and their fundraiser) you shouldn't buy it because you're probably not a developer. In the same way you wouldn't buy a developer-license for the new Google Android version, or a developer-license for Google Glass. Ethers are the de facto dev-license, they're what's necessary to actually utilize the ethereum network. You don't need one. I love bitcoin and crypto can be a great investment, but ethereum isn't it. And I'm quoting the people trying to sell you this thing. They've said themselves it's not an investment.
- Kiro 12y agoThanks a lot. You just prevented me from making a big mistake. :)
- bottled_poe 12y agoCan someone please direct me to where the node software is described (or even better the source code)?
- RoboTeddy 12y agoOverall description: https://github.com/ethereum/wiki/wiki/%5BEnglish%5D-White-Paper https://github.com/ethereum/wiki/wiki/%5BEnglish%5D-White-Pa... Here's a Python client: https://github.com/ethereum/pyethereum https://github.com/ethereum/pyethereum
- jc123 12y agoI believe the C++ client is the most fully developed: https://github.com/ethereum/cpp-ethereum https://github.com/ethereum/cpp-ethereum (It also has link to the yellow paper.)
- ckdarby 12y agowow this just made me so much money ._.
- wmf 12y agoHow?
- lifeisstillgood 12y agoI'm now officially joining patio11 on the "bitcoin - wtf!" Side of the fence. Someone is pre-selling a cryptocurrency in bitcoins at 2000 of our coins to 1 bitcoin. Stop! No-one same is converting hard cash to bitcoin in order to speculate on this. Their kick starter round is not x million in bitcoin it's "oh look I have some bitcoin that massively appreciated in value, but is painful to sell. How do I take my free money and grow it?" It's another bitcoin like tulip mania. No matter how nice an idea a cryptocurrency is, it's not worth millions at pre-launch. Caveat: I may be made to look a fool by the irrationality of crowds
- chatmasta 12y agoTo be fair, Ethereum is not strictly a cryptocurrency, in the sense that its exclusive purpose is not payments. Sure, coins will have value convertible to fiat currency, but that value will be derived from cost of various applications built on the protocol. The primary purpose of Ether is to be the "fuel" for these applications. So, high interest in the crowd sale likely derives not from speculation on the value of ether/USD exchange rates, but rather on the value of the cash flow across the many applications being developed on the protocol. As long as developers build these applications, people use them, and they facilitate money changing hands in the form of Ethers, then each Ether will have a set value. Unlike with Bitcoin, consumers will also have a reason to spend Ethers, as they will be the only accepted exchange mechanism of Ethereum applications. Encouragingly, this will likely act as a self fulfilling prophecy. Investors in Ethereum are motivated to see the ecosystem of decentralized apps develop, so they will build them, and they will use their Ethers. The big problem I could foresee is that because the real value of an Ether will derive from the aggregate value of the Ether "app economy," investors may want to wait before spending their Ethers. But I suspect this will be mitigated by the fact that the apps will only accept Ether as payment. Ethereum will be successful as a protocol once it gets its "killer app." At that point, there will be no turning back and the value will skyrocket. Surely the market cap will be more than $12.7mm. In fact, by writing this comment I've just convinced myself to invest.
- vidarh 12y ago> as they will be the only accepted exchange mechanism of Ethereum applications. So if it is successful, there will be an immense potential in cloning the applications and provide alternative means of payment overlaid on an "Ethereum2".
- thinkingkong 12y agoHow difficult is it to actually create a new cryptocurrency? With 14 cryptocurrencies currently floating around, isnt the value of one over the other simply a branding problem? Edit: I had no idea there were >150. That's astounding.
- higherpurpose 12y agoOnce Ethereum takes off, there will probably be millions of "cryptocurrencies" - o rather "crypto-stock" for start-ups that crowdfund themselves through Ethereum with their own "coin". Think Kickstarter, but where you actually own part of the company, by owning their coins. When the company gets bought for $2 billion like Oculus did, the value of their coin should go way up, too, making the backers' investment worth it, too.
- mrb 12y ago14? Try 450+ https://coinmarketcap.com/currencies/views/all/ https://coinmarketcap.com/currencies/views/all/ And this list is not even exhaustive. It is dead easy to create one: fork and change a few identifiers in the source code. But to make it successful is another problem.
- simcop2387 12y agoThis probably answers your question and corrects something. There are far more than 14 crypto currencies out there: https://coinmarketcap.com/ https://coinmarketcap.com/
- nullc 12y agoA lot of the things raising headline generating amounts of money have not even created a new cryptocurrency. E.g. Look at "Bitshares" by some of the same people behind ethereum— raised money on a whitepaper. When its "investors" later needed liquidity to cash out their investments they did some search and replace on a a copy of Bitcoin to create a "cryptocurrency" which implemented none of their whitepaper features but which would be redeemable for shares in the future system (if it ever comes into existence)... It's in some ways optimal to _not_ create a cryptocurrency for these investment stunts: if they create something then there is something concrete, something with flaws and limitations, something which (hopefully!) is constrained by internal consistency, security considerations, implementability, etc. But if it exists primarily as marketing then there is no limit to the qualities which it can be claimed to have...
- brador 12y agoIs there any way to verify these have really been sold? Is there any third party involved that can verify? Something doesn't feel right and we know Cryptocurrency users are suckers for juicy hype trains. But I do like the concept of p2p distributed servers.
- nullc 12y agoAre you meaning to suggest that some of the people involved might have borrowed funds with promises to return them, or offered some parties deep discounts in exchange for temporarily putting up full prices on large amounts of share, in order to falsely prop up the 'market' value for these assets and create the social proof needed to dupe larger numbers of inexperienced investors into participating? Inconceivable!
- jarradhope 12y agoEthereum isn't about distributed servers. It's not like a VPS. Like Bitcoin is to banks, Ethereum is like to any contract or transaction in the meeting of the minds.
- FractalNerve 12y agoIs there a way to do that with Bitcoin and if so how?
- DennisP 12y agoBitcoin has a more limited scripting system. For details on ethereum script's added abilities, see the whitepaper on ethereum.org, pages 11-13.
- b1db77d2 12y agoSeeding the jar with BTC is speculated to be what Mastercoin did as well, it's not an unreasonable idea in the least. It's essentially free except for the encumbered funds being unusable for a short period.
- joeyspn 12y ago
- gexla 12y agoJust the amount of funding generated for this has to be a good sign for its success. They just funded a ton of development hours. Or I suppose they could just run with it. Do they have any further incentive to see this thing take off? Is there any penalty for disappearing with the Bitcoin?
- jamespitts 12y agoThe incentive for seeing this through is huge, potentially far greater than the millions in bitcoin already raised. If the early technical backers succeed in getting the ethereum platform widely adopted, their fuel holdings will soar in value. They will also be in a terrific position to layer new businesses on top of their work. Meanwhile, the rest of us get a very powerful new set of tools to build applications with.
- nullc 12y agoI'm curious as to what sort of applications you would be building (e.g. blockchain consensus systems cannot do I/O without using trusted parties) and why you're not already building them in the Bitcoin space. As far as funding, mastercoin, counterparty, bitshares, and others have raised millions in pre-sale funding without a whole lot to show for it (some of them having already since abandoned their projects just to do the funding cycle again). While things being created would certantly be good, some skepticism is warranted.
- Cyther606 12y agoSo what if Ethereum is lackluster from a technology standpoint? That isn't the point of Ethereum. The point is to raise a large amount of BTC. Not every potential Bitcoin contributor, Vitalik included, is OK with pouring their heart out into furthering the cause of Bitcoin, while having a grotesquely small personal BTC stash compared to early adopters of Bitcoin who did relatively _nothing_ to earn theirs. Unfairness breeds unfairness, and hyped up Bitcoin IPOs are the natural result. You don't need $20M to make a cryptocurrency. Case in point: Counterparty. I don't know why you brought them up seeing as they didn't do an IPO at all. Counterparty is actually an excellent counter to Ethereum's marketing. They've been around for roughly as long as Ethereum has been marketing itself as "Bitcoin Evolved", but as opposed to Ethereum, Counterparty has in that timeframe actually produced a working decentralized Bitcoin stock market and derivatives exchange with a marketing and development budget of roughly zero.
- Jd 12y agoReposting my review of Ethereum from Quora: Ethereum has been described by core developers as oil to Bitcoin's gold. it is similar to other metacoins in that it acts as superlayer that empowers the blockchain, that is something like when Javascript was added onto HTML. It empowers an immense number of custom applications on top of the blockchain, for purposes as diverse as contracts, derivatives, custom currencies, and filesharing. As Robert Ver said recently in Miami, if it works it is at least as innovative as Bitcoin itself. Enthusiasm is high because, unlike Bitcoin, there is immediate use value for ether within the Ethereum network. All of the applications built in ethereum consume amounts of ether along with their computational cycles. For folks looking at things from a macroeconomic standpoint, this makes Ethereum perhaps the most interesting of the new cryptocurrencies, because among other things. there is immediate use value for ether outside of trading, mining, and the other standard features of the first generation of cryptocurrencies. Is it Bitcoin 2.0? Time will tell. http://www.quora.com/Reviews-of-Ethereum http://www.quora.com/Reviews-of-Ethereum
- asdf333 12y agocorrect me if I'm wrong but the oil analogy breaks down when you look at the fact that there is nothing special about ethereum. it was conjured from thin air and can be conjured even more easily the second time. oil runs out and its not easy to make more. ethereum running out? no worries! just create a new currency ethereum2, issue 100billion and use the blockchain to power more apps. In fact you could just have several ethereum clones going at once.
- EGreg 12y agoHow are they raising the funds? Can others do it?
- tomp 12y agoWeirdly enough, opening this page locks my Google Chrome at 100% CPU, and it keeps going even after I close it, until I actually restart Chrome.
- TomGullen 12y agoAs far as I can tell there will be a total of 10^18 ethers in total. At this stage, 1 BTC ($600 USD) for ~2,000 ethers seems like a really high price for something that hasn't been launched yet.
- kolinko 12y agoThis is no longer true. They modified the algorithm, and right now the amount of ether produced will depend on the amount of ether sold in a presale. In other words - nobody knows now how much ether will there be.
- TomGullen 12y agoAh ok. Personally not comfortable buying any until I know the total supply available, or a better idea of the total supply.
- IkmoIkmo 12y agoI'm a pretty big proponent of bitcoin and enthusiastic about 2.0 applications. But I've got serious doubts about Ethereum. For one it's still pretty much vaporware, little has been released and there's a ton of hype that puts style over substance. For example you'll hear 'turing complete' used 500 times in any piece about Ethereum, but speaking to core developers it turns out that this isn't really significant at all. Besides this there have been some doubts about the development and governance of Ethereum. Let's be clear. Bitcoin is mostly developed by developers funded by the foundation which has a total budget of about $1.5m a year for 2013 and has been doing this for half a decade. Ethereum has already raised as much money as the BF spends in a decade on development, legal, lobbying, evangelism etc. In short, they've got way more money than they need. And then there have been some complaints about how the team handled things, e.g. an investment round they tried to do earlier but failed. And how there's no real reason to need such a large amount of expensive ethers for actual development purposes, particularly not a long time before actual development start. Don't get me wrong, not trying to hate on the team. But I can't find a good reason why people buy ethers like they do. They're supposed to be for development, not as an investment, and we really don't need so many of them. It's the equivalent of Google selling developer Google Glasses for $10k a piece, and regular joes buy 10 of em 'just to hold as an investment, who knows it might take off.' It's ridiculous. Only then it was a pre-order, and there'd be no way to start developing for it, the team behind it is talented but unproven, and in a classic hype scheme the price goes UP over time, not down, despite it being already overpriced and sold as an investment instead of as a dev-resource.
- joeyspn 12y ago> For one it's still pretty much vaporware, little has been released and there's a ton of hype that puts style over substance. This is vaporware for you? https://github.com/ethereum https://github.com/ethereum You've got a 100% working testnet and hundreds of interesting apps/projects with released code in GitHub. Obviously the Ethereum team is not going to release "all the code" immediately if they want to keep the first-mover advantage. It's just about keeping a competitive advantage before clones start popping up like mushrooms. (common sense) > But I can't find a good reason why people buy ethers like they do. They're supposed to be for development, not as an investment, and we really don't need so many of them. I know a lot of people like me are buying ETH for time-to-market reasons. We already have toy-ether in the testnet, but this is a whole different thing. Believe it or not, there's a lot of people building things for ethereum. If you are serious about launching something on top of Ethereum, and like the idea, why not support the final stage of development? This is a crowdfunding campaign. That's all. Obviously there's a bunch of other people just trying to get some ether for speculation. This is normal, and can't be prevented, just like in bitcoin (march'13 & november'13, remember?). I'm not recommending to buy ether to anyone unless they believe in the project and want to see a team pushing the boundaries of cryptocurrencies development.
- amalag 12y agoI think mining based crypto-currencies are not the way forward. Consensus based protocols like are far more practical.
- DennisP 12y agoI've yet to find documentation describing those protocols clearly. Do you have any links? (Of course there were consensus protocols already in distributed systems research, but generally they've relied on having a known set of nodes.)
- amalag 12y agoRipple is trying it, but they have issues. As far as I know the issues are not technical, but business related. https://ripple.com/wiki/Consensus https://ripple.com/wiki/Consensus
- oillio 12y agoThere is also Maidsafe: http://maidsafe.net/ http://maidsafe.net/ They are building a distributed file store system. They use consensus algorithms to ensure data integrity. There is a specification for a crypto-currency on top of that. I do not believe the consensus algorithm has been fully implemented, but what they have looks promising. The documentation is not great, but here is a link to more technical detail about how data is stored in the system: https://github.com/maidsafe/MaidSafe-Vault/wiki/Documentation https://github.com/maidsafe/MaidSafe-Vault/wiki/Documentatio...
- chipsy 12y agoMy analysis of Ethereum: It's economically limited. Ignoring the implementation, we could conservatively say that some interesting web applications are convertible into the "Dapp" form. Right now, these applications are presented as free to the user(free sign-up, free service) and the cost burden lies almost entirely on the service provider, while on Ethereum the user must pay some of the computation cost of their own transactions. Why is this a problem? Surely everyone can have their personal devices mine and produce ether and then the cost of everyday use is hopefully negligible. But even if that were plausible, there's enough of a power differential between personal devices and large server farms that the latter is going to have a huge cost advantage. From this advantage market forces will seek ways to leverage out a monopoly within the Ethereum platform - to enable spammers, extract tolls, mine for personal information, or any other conceivable mechanisms of earning a profit by crushing competition. It's the position Bitcoin is facing now with the mining pool monopoly. There will be a market and it will have a price, but it won't be a huge, global one, not if it's an essentially centralized system doing centralized things underneath an inefficient blockchain layer. In summary, currency design is hard. Proof-of-work mining basically favors capital pooling by letting the richest buy their work - although they may add some measure of anonymity, the resulting power dynamics are identical to those of gold. Changing the proof metric to another computationally-focused one only changes the cost basis, not the bottom line. As such I'm very sour on proof-of-work today as a decentralization tool. I would consider proof-of-stake or other metrics to be in a fundamentally different category, although they also need answers for the distribution problem.
- DennisP 12y agoProof-of-stake could end up being part of Ethereum, and the team is putting a lot of thought into it. For example: https://blog.ethereum.org/2014/07/05/stake/ https://blog.ethereum.org/2014/07/05/stake/ https://blog.ethereum.org/2014/01/15/slasher-a-punitive-proof-of-stake-algorithm/ https://blog.ethereum.org/2014/01/15/slasher-a-punitive-proo...
- jaekwon 12y agoThat's a big if. Vitalik is mostly looking at PoW ATM.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- rglover 12y agoIf this works it's a great idea and will serve a wonderful purpose. I'm a big supporter of Bitcoin (and my own buy in came long after I was aware of it), but Ethereum doesn't seem baked enough to warrant throwing (at the current price) 1 BTC at something that isn't fully operational. Definitely something to keep an eye on, though.
- midas 12y agoWhat happens to all the bitcoins that are being sent in now if ethereum fails? In startups, investors almost always have a liquidation preference, which means that if things go south they get their money back first (or at least what's left of it). I haven't heard any mention of this and I'm wondering how this is structured? If the ethereum founders were able to fail spectacularly and still walk away as millionaires that'd be quite a perverse incentive structure!
- grubles 12y agoHere is your answer from Vitalik Buterin himself: http://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/2bssfx/ethereum_scam/cj8q962 http://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/2bssfx/ethereum_sca...
- midas 12y agoYikes! Thanks for sharing. It's a bad sign for the crypto community that the market doesn't demand better terms. You can debate price forever but nobody should argue for misaligned incentives. I'd prefer projects like this go one step further and destroy the bitcoin invested up-front. It doesn't make sense to do ex post (now in this case), but ex ante it signals a commitment to the new coin and a genuine bet on its future value. Full disclosure: I hold some bitcoin, so other people destroying theirs might benefit me ever so slightly :)
- obscuren 12y agoHi guys I'm one of the core developers and will I'll answer some the questions. There seems to be some misguided information and claims that are, fortunately, not true. > but speaking to core developers it turns out that this isn't really significant at all. I'm one of the 3 core developers and I'm pretty certain I've not met or talked to you, and I can't imagine the other two making such claims either. > Ethereum has already raised as much money as the BF spends in a decade We are a different tech but so happen so share and exist in the same space. Comparing us to the BF or Bitcoin in general is just downright wrong. You're comparing apples to oranges. > For one it's still pretty much vaporware, little has been released I've been relentlessly working on this for the past 7-8 months and so has Gav & Vitalik. All 3 of us have made remarkable progress if I may say so. Right now we have 3 clean room implementations with 99.99% consensus and operate on the same testnet blockchain. Vaporware? I beg the differ. * Go - myself * C++ - Gavin * Python - Vitalik The Go, C++ and Python implementations have full interoperability. A 4th, Java, implementation is being developed by Roman but hasn't got full consensus yet. > Obviously the Ethereum team is not going to release "all the code" immediately All of our code is available on GH actually (https://github.com/ethereum https://github.com/ethereum) > Are you allowed to create TPC/IP listen sockets? This is undefined. We have been _very_ explicit regarding I/O (in any form), it's simply not allowed, period. > Specifically, arbitrary code execution by strangers. I'm not sure if you're familiar with the model we're using but arbitrary execution isn't a problem considering we do not allow any form of I/O. The arbitrary code, or contracts, are "triggered" by sending it a transaction. Once triggered it will run according to a set of rules that have to be goverend at all time. It's part of the consensus engine; it's "all in or nothing". Once mined, the miner will announce the new block, node's will verify the transactions and execution and can accept or reject based on their findings. > Obviously it's not vaporware but there are many discussions about their implementation behind the scenes such as "Ethereum “Dagger” PoW function is flawed" Vlad is currently working on the PoW. For code see https://github.com/ethereum/mining https://github.com/ethereum/mining I don't mind a good bit of scepticism but the amount of false claims and downright incorrect information that some of you have been posted really is below the HN standard. Most (if not all) of the answers are available online, just put a bit of research in to it.