5 ms·
20 years would be culturally terrible. That would make it so just around the time your kids are old enough for you to introduce them to the great comics, cartoo
by tzs 12y ago
20 years would be culturally terrible. That would make it so just around the time your kids are old enough for you to introduce them to the great comics, cartoons, movies, music, and books of your childhood it would enter the public domain and become widely used in advertising and low budget productions. You are not going to be able to share the magic of, say, Calvin & Hobbes, with your kids if your kids have already been saturated by those characters as TV pitchmen for toys and junk food.
- mikeash 12y agoI don't see any correlation currently between things that are in the public domain and things that are used on TV to pitch toys and junk food.
- tzs 12y agoYes, but isn't that because the edge of public domain is very far back? Some random character from the early 1900s that no one today recognizes is not going to be all that useful. Move that edge to be just 20 years back, and it picks up a lot of things that are still well known. 20 years is not nearly as long as it sounds. Harry Potter, for instance, is already 17 years old. I bet a lot of advertisers 3 years from now would jump on the chance to use Harry Potter characters.
- mikeash 12y agoThere are plenty of classic, well-known characters in the public domain. Sherlock obviously being one, given the context of the discussion. Frankenstein. Robin Hood. King Arthur. Jesus.... On another note, it doesn't affect your point all that much, but while Harry Potter the character would go into the public domain in 2017, the first movie wouldn't go into the public domain until 2021. In that interval, you could use the characters but you couldn't replicate their likenesses from the movies without some sort of agreement.
- eikenberry 12y agoI think you have it exactly backwards. A reasonable length copyright (like 10-20 years) would be awesome for culture. You'd see loads more great new comics, cartoons, movies, music books all remixing, reworking and drawing inspiration from an renewed and thriving public domain. Advertisers and branding wouldn't find much use for them because they were public domain. They gain value from these things by limiting the use through exclusive deals enabled by copyright.
- tptacek 12y agoHe, quite reasonably I think, doesn't want to see loads more Calvin and Hobbes cartoons. Because they won't be created by Bill Watterson. They'll be created by PepsiCo to sell sugar water.
- tzs 12y ago> Advertisers and branding wouldn't find much use for them because they were public domain. They gain value from these things by limiting the use through exclusive deals enabled by copyright That's one way advertisers can gain value from using a character. Exclusivity strengthens the association between the character and the product being advertised. Without exclusivity, many advertising characters probably would indeed be of little value and advertisers would probably not use them. I think, though, that this would mostly apply to characters that were created for advertising, or that were outside characters that were not very significant to the public. If the Michelin Man were used to pitch donuts, for example, I'd find it weird, because I only associate the Michelin Man with Michelin tires. However, for characters that had significant public interest before they were used in advertising, I don't think exclusivity is very important. For instance, Michael Phelps (yes, I know he is a real person, not a character, but that doesn't change the point) has done ads for Subway Sandwiches and for Speedo, and I don't think either diminishes the other.
- dragonwriter 12y agoTwenty-year-old (and even much newer) commercially successful comics, cartoons, movies, and music are, in fact, widely used in advertising, etc. -- heck, with comics and cartoons, they are used as pitchmen for toys and junk food from day one. So, I think the cultural terror you refer to is the status quo even with effectively perpetual copyright.
- tptacek 12y agoCalvin and Hobbes isn't used to promote toys and junk food.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> Calvin and Hobbes isn't used to promote toys and junk food Sure, if you are going to be hyperspecific about that one particular example and that one specific use, but the issue was more general about works, and, as for that work, while it may not used to promote toys and junk food, its first titular character is used in rather ubiquitous window decals that seem to present at least as much of the same problem. The cultural context for a succesful work, with regard to its specific characters, but also more generally, is never going to be the same when you want to introduce your kids to it as when you were introduced to it yourself, particularly if you encountered the work when it was first introduced to society (or when first became popular, which may not be the same time). Trying to restrict other people's freedom in order to preserve that cultural context -- as by adovcating long copyright terms for that purpose -- is never going to work.
- tptacek 12y agoI'm not being hyperspecific about that one particular example. The comment you chose to reply to was specifically about that one particular example. Long copyright terms seem to be doing just fine for Bill Watterson.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> The comment you chose to reply to was specifically about that one particular example. Not, it wasn't. It made the following general claim about a problem that would exist without long-term copyright: >> That would make it so just around the time your kids are old enough for you to introduce them to the great comics, cartoons, movies, music, and books of your childhood it would enter the public domain and become widely used in advertising and low budget productions. << > Long copyright terms seem to be doing just fine for Bill Watterson. Perhaps its doing fine for him, but its not preventing characters -- Calvin particularly -- from Calvin and Hobbes from being ubiquitously used in our culture in a way which shifts the context in which someone newly introduced to the source works might experience them. Sure, its not specifically "marketing toys and junk food", but rather expressing preferences, but its not fundamentally different from the perspective of the kind of cultural context concern raised generally in the post I was responding to.