3 ms·
Unfortunately, quite a lot of browser changes are required to prevent information leaks when using Tor, and it's not clear that Chromium can feasibly be made su
by makomk 12y ago
Unfortunately, quite a lot of browser changes are required to prevent information leaks when using Tor, and it's not clear that Chromium can feasibly be made suitable or where the developer time to do it would come from. (That's I think part of the reason TorBrowser is based on Firefox ESR - they can't keep up with the new features otherwise. I don't believe Chromium has equivalent extended-support releases; in order to get security fixes you have to upgrade to new versions with new features and new information leaks.)
If you screw up and miss something, the FBI might not even need to exploit a bug in order to find users' IP addresses, they could just use documented browser features to get users to connect to their honeypot using their real IP addresses.
- mike_hearn 12y agoThis is an artifact of how Tor works. VPN services don't suffer from this issue because all traffic gets routed via the VPN at the operating system level.
- makomk 12y agoEven then there's the issue of various browser and OS fingerprinting attacks which the current Tor Browser goes to significant effort to prevent. Tor actually supports a VPN-like mode, at least on Linux, but it can only protect against some classes of attack.
- pcwalton 12y agoRight. I don't believe that process sandboxing would have prevented what the FBI wanted to do here: unmask the identities of Tor users. I would be surprised if compromising a renderer at the moment didn't give you access to enough information for law enforcement to figure out who was accessing the site. (See the list of current leaks on the Site Isolation description [1] just to name a few.) As a practical example, the FBI could slurp usernames and passwords from other sites the user has been to, then subpoena them to determine if they'd ever logged in without Tor, and so forth. [1]: http://www.chromium.org/developers/design-documents/site-isolation http://www.chromium.org/developers/design-documents/site-iso...