5 ms·
Wait, if you work overtime in the U.S. you do not get compensated for it?
by Semaphor 12y ago
Wait, if you work overtime in the U.S. you do not get compensated for it?
- georgemcbay 12y agoIt depends on your job and other factors, but sometimes the answer is, sadly, yes. My mom is a soon-to-retire nurse and she was a salaried employee who, if she worked overtime, made either time-and-a-half (1.5x) or double-time (2x) pay depending upon the situation. But software developers, for all of the talk of ninjas and rockstars and whatnot, are a socially low and easily exploited class that make decisions against our own interests (laughing off the idea of unions, etc); so we often work up to 1.5 to 2 times (60-80 hours is very common) over our official salaried hours for free.
- baddox 12y agoYou certainly don't seem to think very highly of software developers.
- georgemcbay 12y agoFor whatever it is worth, I am a software developer and I'm as guilty as any of working 80 hour weeks, especially in the first 10 years of my career. I'm just older now (41 this year) and while I still work as a software developer and have avoided the management route (since I still love coding), I've become somewhat jaded on the business end of things. Don't get me wrong, I think in certain situations (eg. developer is a founder or has meaningful preferential equity in a company) that working very long hours toward a goal without directly being paid for those hours is perfectly acceptable; but I cringe when I think of how many hours of sleep I missed in my younger days for a pat on the back or token meaningless non-monetary perks when I was a common-stock-holding pleb being constantly diluted out of equity in even the moderately successful companies.
- throwawayh3d8 12y agoSounds bitter. Software developers are certainly not regarded as socially lower than a nurse, quite the opposite (at least in Europe). But I _do_ agree that, compared to many other professions prestiges is low. I also agree that it's time for unions, although simply owing the company collectively may work better. More importantly, people should not allow themselves to be exploited and realise that doing so is just as bad for them as for their fellow developers.
- georgemcbay 12y agoNot really bitter, just somewhat jaded. I don't know how it is in Europe, but in the US it is kind of a complex situation where we are externally not regarded as socially lower (from the outside it is all very glamorous and we are all Silicon Valley millionaires) and we do make decent baseline wages (though outside of a few companies like Google there tends to be a glass ceiling on our earnings unless we become something other than software developers, eg become tech managers) and (rather importantly right now) we do have a very high level of employability relative to many other professional fields. But all that aside, we are still often exploited as a resource (IMO) by the "ruling class" of business people/MBA types/investors/etc in ways they would not allow themselves to be exploited.
- hueving 12y ago>I also agree that it's time for unions That will definitely not help bring prestige to the field. Professions that require unions are seen as being so easy to enter that they need to form unions to avoid the effects of the free market.
- ceallen 12y agoDoctors and lawyers regulate who can enter their field. Doctors even control how many students med schools can accept each year. They seem to still be 'prestigious' professions. They were just smart enough to avoid the word 'union', since it's been tarnished by 50 years of political attacks. I'd also trade in a lot of prestige for the guarantee of employers not having overtime as a free resource that employees are expected to give with a smile.
- talmand 12y agoJust because a group of people got together to agree on something work-related doesn't necessarily make them like a union. But I agree on the prestige thing, I'm a non-union web developer and I don't feel much prestige in my position.
- johnward 12y agoHealthcare is a high demand field, especially nursing. They seem to be able to negotiate shorter work weeks like working 3 10 hour days and being paid for 40 hours, etc. It's somewhat physically and mentally demanding. Software is in high demand but still a middle class job (similar to nursing). It's very mentally demanding. The physical demand is different as it's a problem of not being active enough to be healthy. Not to mention that in software you are likely spending a significant time working outside of normal working hours if it's for your company or just to increase your skills/learn something new. How else are you supposed to have the required a super awesome github profile to show when you go for an interview?
- gnopgnip 12y agoIn CA you have to make 84k a year for the computer professional overtime exemption. If you are making under that you are still getting overtime pay. There are many jobs that do not meet the requirements to be exempt also.
- BillyMaize 12y ago>so we often work up to 1.5 to 2 times (60-80 hours is very common) over our official salaried hours for free. Take this with a grain of salt, it really depends on where you live. I live in the Ohio area and of everyone I went to college with and everyone I have ever worked with I have never met someone that has worked more than 45 hours a week.
- baddox 12y agoIf you're salaried, there's generally no such thing as "overtime" (other than this law, apparently).
- jlarocco 12y agoThe opposite holds, too, though. Salaried employees make the same amount whether they work 30 hours a week or 50. That said, most people try to average out to around 40 hours, because they usually agree to five 8 hour days.
- Semaphor 12y agoCould someone explain to me why this and the other comment regarding salaried employees are downvoted?
- johnward 12y agoYes. Companies tend to abuse this in some cases and in other cases it's more lenient. Currently I will work overtime, without pay, if I project requires it. I will also take a few hours to go to a doctor appointment during the day. So it balances out. Previously I had to work over 50-60 hours regularly without over time pay. That probably goes against what is expected of an "exempt" employee and I probably should have been compensated. I left that position for obvious reasons. Generally in the US if you are paid a guaranteed yearly salary, meaning not paid hourly, you do not get overtime pay. One exception I've experience is in retail. For example the manager of our deli department would get paid 1/2 time (not time + 1/2) for overtime.
- ulfw 12y agoSilicon Valley wouldn't exist if those would be paid. It's one of the small 'perks' of making a 6 digit salary. You work so many unpaid overtime hours that your actual hourly wage isn't THAT high anymore. (especially if you also take only 10 vacation days into account etc)
- walterbell 12y agoA counter-argument is that overtime implements a necessary feedback loop against poor management and project planning. Overworking creative staff may not be optimal for innovation.
- ulfw 12y agoIt clearly isn't. I highly doubt people who work 10-12hr days actually really get efficient creative work done for those hours.
- michaelochurch 12y agoSilicon Valley wouldn't exist if those would be paid. If that's the case, then Silicon Valley doesn't deserve to exist. The only people for whom it's reasonable to expect unpaid overtime are genuine founders with real control over the company and their place in it, and who will get real rewards if it succeeds, You work so many unpaid overtime hours that your actual hourly wage isn't THAT high anymore. Maybe you do. Except on projects with direct benefit to your career, it's a waste of time and you'd be better off to stop. You don't get more respect by being a chump. You just get loaded with more grunt work. You want your bosses to think you have leadership potential, not that you're a hard worker who can be used as a garbage disposal for stuff no one else wants to do, or who will accept abuse downwind of others' mistakes (understaffing, bad planning, etc.) especially if you also take only 10 vacation days into account Don't work for shitty companies. Three weeks is the absolute minimum.