4 ms·
The actual complaint (http://zenmagnets.com/images/Complaint%20Counsel%27s%20Second%20Amended%20Complaint.pdf http://zenmagnets.com/images/Complaint%20Counsel%2
by smacktoward 12y ago
The actual complaint (http://zenmagnets.com/images/Complaint%20Counsel%27s%20Second%20Amended%20Complaint.pdf http://zenmagnets.com/images/Complaint%20Counsel%27s%20Secon...) indicates that this company includes with some of its products a printed warning reading, in part,
> Strong magnets can cause fatal intestinal pinching. Place swallowing magnets on your don't do list along with breathing water, drinking poison, and running into traffic.
If the safety level of your product can be reasonably compared to drowning, being poisoned, or getting hit by a truck, you probably shouldn't be surprised when the product-safety people show an interest in it.
Moreover, of the three things the warning compares their product to, only one -- poison -- is an example of an actual product you can buy (nobody's selling home drowning kits), and that one only gets by with a warning in cases where it has a substantial beneficial use. Bleach, for instance, is sold with a warning label, but that's because bleach has substantial benefits as a cleaner of clothes and surfaces. Those benefits provide an argument that they outweigh the risk it poses if swallowed.
What are the practical, non-entertainment benefits of magnet balls? If there aren't any -- if they're a toy, a novelty -- it seems completely fair to hold them to a higher standard. A toy is the definition of a non-essential product. So if your toy carries a risk of killing somebody, well, there's plenty of other toys out there that don't.
- amandle 12y ago> only one -- poison -- is an example of an actual product you can buy (nobody's selling home drowning kits) They're also not selling magnet ingestion kits
- phaus 12y agoYou can buy water and cars too. A set of zenmagnets is no more a suicide via intestinal pinching kit than a gallon of water is a drowning kit. There are millions of things on the market that you can kill yourself with; when would you say that personal responsibility should come into play? Also, magnet sets are educational as well as entertaining.
- JamisonM 12y agoIf you leave a gallon of water on a table unattended it is very unlikely any passing child will use that gallon of water to drown themselves. All this pretending that the practical differences between this product and all these other things is trivial drives me a little crazy.
- GeneralMayhem 12y agoIf I leave a handful of magnets sitting on a table unattended in my apartment, the odds that a child will eat them are absolutely zero, since neither I nor anyone I know has kids. If they did, I probably wouldn't let the kids in my apartment if they're still at the putting-random-things-in-their-mouth stage and their parents can't keep them from eating other people's things.
- phaus 12y agoWhat kind of a shitty parent leaves small objects unattended around small children? Only a complete moron would do that. What about scissors? Pencils? Knives? Everyone has these things in their homes, and you could just as easily leave them on the table as you could a set of magnets. What drives me crazy are people who want the federal government to micromanage every aspect of their lives, even as it repeatedly proves to us that it is too corrupt/incompetent to do pretty much anything right.
- pstuart 12y agoThere's plenty of shitty parents around, but the type of parent who is interested in magnetic spheres is not likely to be a shitty parent.
- JamisonM 12y agoScissors, pencils, knives: All things safer than these magnets. Empirically true. The bad parent argument is garbage. If I visit someone's house or bring one of my little ones with me to my accountants or lawyer's office I don't expect to need to be ultra-vigilant, it should be a generally safe environment. I want to live in a society where that is true.
- davepage 12y agoWhat is the practical benefit of a back yard pool (drowning apparatus), beer stein (poisoning apparatus), or a sports car (trauma apparatus)? [I assume this must be a troll, since if this were taken to its logical conclusion, it advocates a Soviet style command and control society. No laughing, smiling, or running with scissors allowed.]
- throwaway5752 12y agoYour slippery-slope approach is fatuous. It is a completely nihilistic approach to any sort of legal system that involves regulations and penalties for breaking them. It is a completely fair point to ask where on the realm of regulated toys buckyball-style magnets fall. Someone doesn't have to be a troll just because they disagree with you. Also, what is with your last sentence? Are you suggesting that not allowing running with scissors is indicative of creeping authoritarianism? You would have been disappointed with every teacher I had, then. edit: thanks for the downvotes. A useful reminder to me to never discuss anything with libertarians.
- beedogs 12y ago> Also, what is with your last sentence? Do you have issues with hyperbole? You seem to have taken it literally.
- sgnelson 12y agoI guess humor should be banned too.
- andrewfong 12y ago> What are the practical, non-entertainment benefits of magnet balls? If there aren't any -- if they're a toy, a novelty -- it seems completely fair to hold them to a higher standard. By the same token, we could argue that movies should be banned because the images can trigger PTSD and epileptic seizures, and movies have no practical, non-entertainment benefits. It's one thing to say that a product should be re-designed to provide the same utility in a safer manner if that's an option. But it is not the government's place to make wholesale subjective decisions about utility to begin with. That is, it's one thing to require that Ford fix the design flaw in the Pinto that made it conducive to explosions because no one really wants an exploding car. It's another to ban cars altogether because public transit provides a safer alternative to personal automobiles.
- javert 12y agoUpvoted even though I disagree because I think you make the best argument for regulation. The problem is, it isn't safe to have non-elected bureaucrats making law, either. But that is not something I can get around by being cautions or well-informed. Of course, it also isn't safe to have elected representatives pass massive bills that they haven't read. So I'm not saying that being elected magically makes everything OK.
- smsm42 12y ago>>> What are the practical, non-entertainment benefits of magnet balls? Who cares? In a free country, any benefit that I see for myself would be enough to allow me to purchase the item, without explaining it to you or anybody else. How is it that you decided you have the right to define what is and is not beneficial for me? What gave you that right? How is it fair for you to tell me "I think you're not smart enough to handle a couple of metal balls without killing yourself" and feel all smug and righteous as if you've saved my life, instead as a petty busybody who just made my life (and a life of thousands other people) a little worse for no reason at all, while shuttering perfectly good company, and causing a lot of loss and waste of money and effort? What exactly allows you to feel you're being anything even in the general direction of "fair" when you take on yourself to decide my needs for me? Do you enjoy other people telling you what is and is not of benefit for you?
- Torgo 12y ago>What are the practical, non-entertainment benefits of magnet balls? Keep your laws off my balls, nanny-stater.