5 ms·
Oh, ugh. Why not "human fonts" or "people fonts"? (Or "natural fonts" or "handwriting fonts" or...) The problem I have with this is that if you help people ba
by Mz 12y ago
Oh, ugh.
Why not "human fonts" or "people fonts"? (Or "natural fonts" or "handwriting fonts" or...)
The problem I have with this is that if you help people based on the their status of being homeless, then do they stop qualifying once they are off the street? That kind of thing is what keeps poor people stuck. It's why the American welfare system is broken. You first have to qualify as "poor" and often some other thing to get assistance. Countries that just, say, provide national healthcare for all citizens, because you exist, help reduce the gap between rich and poor. Stuff like this helps widen it.
We need to think about how to remove barriers so all people can live well and all that but you need to treat very carefully with programs which are framed such that you are basically rewarded for having a problem. That just tends to promote having that problem. (That's what the American welfare has done: It changed the social contract to reward being a poor, single mom such that it increased the incidence of poor, single moms in the population. Great job, that.)
- iamdave 12y ago>Why not "human fonts" or "people fonts"? If the road to hell is paved with good intentions, then the lanes are striped with "person first" language (and all of its mutations).
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- Mz 12y agoI really don't know what you mean. This is an area I have studied, both formally and informally. How it is framed matters. The history of what went wrong with the American welfare system is deeply rooted in the fact that it was designed to "help poor, single moms" in an era when having a child out of wedlock was scandalous and just not done. It changed the social contract to frame it that way and made it far more acceptable to have children out of wedlock. That framing occurred at a time when most poor, single moms were widows -- ie "the deserving poor" -- not women who had given birth outside of wedlock. It was done in an unthinking manner and we are still living with the consequences decades later.
- iamdave 12y agoIt's mostly a sound-byte of cynicism targeted at people who promulgate 'person first' correctness without the backdrop of understanding the nuanced impact rhetoric has, or the willingness to dig into those impacts like you have. I personally have little patience for those who simply say "You shouldn't say that, say this instead" without the fortitude or intellectual honesty to back up what they're invariably ordering me to say or not say. But this really isn't the venue for that kind of discussion. I respect that you took the time to understand these different sociological phenomenons, so I apologize if it seemed like my comment was a dig at you personally-it wasn't.
- barrkel 12y agoIf you think having children out of wedlock is linked to US welfare system incentives, how do you explain global trends? I think it has more to do with female equality and increased earning power. But it's a complex multi-vectored phenomenon not really suited to an off-topic thread here.
- Mz 12y agoI haven't studied global trends. Nor am I suggesting that trends in the U.S. have only one factor influencing them. That's kind of a bogus rebuttal.