5 ms·
Because we are getting things back in return. Israel is a nuclear state with good relations with us. US has weapons contracts which help defend Israel... one of
by dragontamer 12y ago
Because we are getting things back in return. Israel is a nuclear state with good relations with us. US has weapons contracts which help defend Israel... one of the very very few countries that the US exports to. Culturally and historically, the state of Israel was established by the Allies post WW2. So there is a moral obligation as well for the Allies (US, France, UK, etc. etc.) to watch out for what Israel does today.
Ultimately, Israel is a bastion for Western values in the middle east. They take a lot of flak (suicide bombs, etc. etc.) that would be otherwise aimed at Europeans or Americans. Its super-practical for the US to keep Israel strong.
Imagine if you will when ISIS establishes itself as a pseudo-country. Do you think ISIS will be more concerned with Israel (who have a military within marching distance), or with Europeans / Americans that they've sworn to destroy half-way around the world? Who will they attack first?
Besides, if Israel falls, their nuclear stockpile will cause some major issues.
- ZanyProgrammer 12y agoOr, alternatively, they are an outpost of European colonialism, which the US should in no means be obligated to defend. Edited to Add: The idea of Zionism was a product of late 19th century colonialism. Hence a lot of pre-WW2 immigration to Palestine was from Europe. I don't think a lot of those early immigrants gave much consideration to the people already living there who weren't Jewish
- dragontamer 12y agoSo you're the type to not care about historical or cultural connections between countries. I understand that. But I have there a multi-pronged argument. Please address the other issues if you actually want a serious response. My post wasn't very long, and its such a shame that you were only able to read a subset of it.
- ZanyProgrammer 12y ago"Culturally and historically, the state of Israel was established by the Allies post WW2." Is demonstrably not true. A substantial amount of immigration was the product of the late 19th century Zionist movement. Ever hear of the Balfour declaration? If Israel is ever in danger of being destroyed, they will undoubtedly use their Sampson option, and probably just nuke the rest of the Middle East (possibly some of Europe as well, and undoubtedly Mecca and Medina). That's not the kind of Western values I support.
- dragontamer 12y agoStrike Two. You take another swipe, and you cannot divert your attention away from a specific word that I used in my original post. Classic Conspiracy Theorist: you have an inability to read my entire post and address my more powerful points. Instead, you focus on the points that cause you the most emotional response. Lemme help focus your attention... Please address this point. Between Israel and the US, who do you think will ISIS attack first? Anyone with a map can tell you that Israel is far closer and far more of a threat to ISIS than the US right now (especially with our "hands off" approach to Syria and Iraq). Israel takes the flak from a lot of militant extremists, so we don't have to. Its a practical arrangement.
- ZanyProgrammer 12y ago"Between Israel and the US, who do you think will ISIS attack first?" You really think ISIS will ever attack the US? In what manner? Though I suppose it'd be blowback from invading Iraq in the first place. Israel and the US mess up the Middle East, then proclaim its our sovereign right to mess it up some more.
- dragontamer 12y agoISIS is an offshoot of Al Qaeda. They will be able to attack us in a similar manner as the Boston Marathon attack. If a 9/11 style infiltration of this country were to happen, they would easily affect us in that manner. I'd rather not discuss how I'd attack the US. But needless to say, we are quite vulnerable to a smaller-scale 9/11 style attack, where foreigners invade us and plant bombs at mundane locations. There are plenty of festivals, infrastructure, and gatherings that are vulnerable in the US to another "Boston Marathon" massacre. And unlike Boston, the majority of places in the US don't have simultaneous access to six world-class hospitals + highly-educated medical population to care for the wounded. Keep that in mind, the casualties number was low because Boston hospitals were so close and world-class in their care abilities. In most cities, random dudes on the street wouldn't know to pinch specific arteries to save your life. Boston was a unique place with medical know-how and lots of highly-trained medical response at the ready. http://www.vosizneias.com/128409/2013/04/16/unlikely-hero-in-cowboy-hat-saves-lives-at-marathon-finish-line/ http://www.vosizneias.com/128409/2013/04/16/unlikely-hero-in... If such an attack happened anywhere else, I guarantee you that more people would have died / been injured.
- digitalzombie 12y ago> Israel is a nuclear state They've never confirm this, only that it is believe that Israel possess nuclear weapons. > Culturally and historically, the state of Israel was established by the Allies post WW2. So there is a moral obligation as well for the Allies (US, France, UK, etc. etc.) to watch out for what Israel does today. There shouldn't be any morale obligation at all when they, the Jewish people chose the spot to become Israel. We, USA, didn't assign it for them. US, historically, didn't even care about Israel when they were attacked, the British were the only one that really back them up. US ties between Israel are more powerful later on, so this statement is false in term of morality. > Ultimately, Israel is a bastion for Western values in the middle east. And yet they are condemn by the majority in the UN except for USA veto. > Do you think ISIS will be more concerned with Israel (who have a military within marching distance), or with Europeans / Americans that they've sworn to destroy half-way around the world? Who will they attack first? Total fantasy. This fantasy is also fear mongering, in term of "what ifs". Even if this fantasy come true, you don't think Nato or those US carriers that are station nearby isn't going to bomb them like Korsovo? And how smart are they to operate nuclear weapons? How long will it take them to learn how to use it? > Besides, if Israel falls, their nuclear stockpile will cause some major issues. Once again fear mongering. Let's look at it this way, they got nuclear weapon, so they got a free pass for their horrible behavior against USA? The President and John Kerry?
- dragontamer 12y agoI appreciate your serious response. Let's look at it this way, they got nuclear weapon, so they got a free pass for their horrible behavior against USA? The President and John Kerry? It isn't horrible behavior. It is standard behavior that has been going on since the dawn of Israel. We catch their spies all the time, and they catch our spies all the time. US / Israel relations are funny like that. We don't really trust each other, but we both need each other.
- nayefc 12y agoYou don't need each other. All what Israel does is alienate the US and protects Israel's horrific acts and occupation of the Palestinian people.
- peterashford 12y agoIt's because of Israel's actions towards the Palestinians that the Arab world hates the West so much - after all, the US funds and condones it.
- dragontamer 12y agoErm... no. Iran hates us because we messed their country up good. Installing dictators, destroying their democracy, stealing their oil... etc. etc. US Foreign Policy in the 50s and 60s were freaking terrible. Plus, the US is seen as highly ignorant. Saudi Arabia is our ally, but they fund Al Qaeda, support Salafi / Wahhabi Muslims which spawned Bin Laden. We funnel money into Saudi Arabian princes who then funnel money into ISIS and Al Qaeda and piss off all of the other Muslims around. Trust me, we don't need Israel for the Middle East to hate us.