5 ms·
LG's Smartwatch Shows Android Wear Operating System Has a Long Way to Go
- codeka 12y ago> Android Wear seems still in the experimental stage, but this app is not labeled a beta. This is the impression I get, after using one for about a week. Not only does it seem rather unfinished, it's also quite buggy (some notifications never disappear, the navigation integration is basically unusable, and there was a point where I was getting no notifications and had to clear data for the Google Play Services app to get them back). However, when it does work, it works brilliantly and I'm kind of lucky that it doesn't look monstrously big on my wrist, so I think I'm going to stick with it for now.
- k-mcgrady 12y ago> Android Wear seems still in the experimental stage, but this app is not labeled a beta. That seems to be how Google is doing things now. Look at Google Glass. It's listed on the Play Store as 'explorer edition' and marketed on the page not as an experimental product but as something hikers, cyclists, photographers etc. should use. It's actually quite dishonest especially considering it costs £1,000.
- Zigurd 12y agoTwo things make it worthwhile: 1. Replying by transcribed voice to Hangouts messages, including SMS, by speaking into the watch. This works even in very loud environments. That's pretty amazing. 2. Google Now notifications that I have to be on my way to my next meeting. It's not amazing, but it is very convenient to take notes and to-dos by voice when driving, since I don't usually wear a headset all the time when driving. This is the best general-purpose voice note-taking setup I have used. I have not found it to be buggy. To the contrary, it handles being in and out of range of the phone very well. I never have to fiddle with Bluetooth settings to get it to connect. I'm not that keen on the round watch-faces either. While the UI might work on a round display, there is nothing about the UI that would actually use roundness in any useful way. That is, apart from analog-style watch faces, there are no other "gauge" metaphors in the UI or any other UI element that wants to be on a round display.
- gaius 12y agoIt's not clear to me what the target market for this is, esp. given you need a phone as well. A whole generation has gotten used to telling the time by looking at their phones (ironically, exactly the same gesture as using a pocketwatch). The rise of the wrist watch in the mass market is tied to some very specific events in history (lots of people being issued them in WW2). Who is going to buy this and why?
- jbuzbee 12y agoI've got a Pebble - It's much easier for me to glance at my wrist to get the date, time, weather, or to tell who that email came from rather than fishing my phone out of my pocket - especially when driving. On the downside, it's a pretty ugly watch, but when I accidently let the battery run down I miss it.
- hadoukenio 12y agoChange to a watchface that includes the battery charge. Better yet, install Pebble Canvas and create your own watch face.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- hyp0 12y agoYes, and other wristwatch devices (calculators, computers) haven't taken off. Even if it was self-contained. Perhaps many people don't like wearing watches. I don't. A heads-up display seems much more useful and convenient, solving the shrinking-display problem.
- couchand 12y agoAm I the only one that thinks voice interfaces are a scourge on technology? Leave them to science fiction. It's already bad enough with people walking around with their bluetooth headsets chatting away looking literally insane. But call me a luddite.
- nnnnni 12y agoI use voice control for one thing: to send text messages while driving. It's a lot safer to say "text bob i will be there in fifteen minutes" then "send" than to try to type while driving. It's also (understandably) illegal to type the messages while driving in many areas!
- VLM 12y agoIt's telling that I find it less frustrating to find a stop sign or parking lot, than to suffer thru using speech. Error rate is too high. Getting angry while driving is no fun. Also I can call someone with one button press on my car. Much less distracting, and much faster, than trying to text/email.
- neumann 12y agoAgreed - I have yet to successfully send a text through voice commands. Or navigate. And I quickly realised it was dangerous to try, because I would inevitably have to look down to see what the phone is actually doing.
- bane 12y agoFor people who have one. What's the battery life been like?
- pdx6 12y agoAbout 3 days assuming you have the display off when it is not in use. About a day if you like to leave the screen on.
- bookwormAT 12y agoI leave the screen on and I'm at about 40% in the evening.
- jotm 12y ago"operating system for wearable devices like smartwatches" /facepalm Please, just focus on Glass and preferably other wearable displays, so we don't need to waste a ton of money and time on something that will never be anything other than a fad.
- jotm 12y agoIf someone could explain why smart watches (especially with their own OS, I get phone-pairing, but standalone just seems stupid) are a good idea, I'd be glad to read and upvote it.
- Zigurd 12y agoThey are a good idea because they expand the physical interface to smartphones. In general mobile devices face the challenge that they can't be too large. So you will find wearables, sensors, radio beacons, and other technologies used to make the interaction "surface" larger.
- jotm 12y agoOK, I get that problem, but AR glasses will solve it and many others, making smart watches and possibly any LCD displays obsolete. In my opinion, smart watches are a DOA product, no point in pushing for a market for them. Imagine a perfected version of these with an optional front cover so you only see the displays when needed: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oOBo05xvSVk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oOBo05xvSVk
- Zigurd 12y agoI've got both an LG AndroidWear watch, and Glass. At first, I thought "Glass is radical enough, and watches won't be." But I wear the smartwatch almost every day and I've only found Glass really useful for recording PoV video for tutorials and reviews. Glass needs a "killer app." At this stage of development, Glass is too obtrusive and has too limited battery life. I could see some high-value enterprise apps for Glass. AR glasses are a step or three beyond that.
- weego 12y ago"oh best take my phone out of my pocket, my watch is ringing".
- bookwormAT 12y agohaving a second screen for notifications and short information bits is really useful. After a month with the LG Watch, I'm convinced this is an essential addon to use with a smartphone. It feels really stupid now to think that my phone would make some kind of noise to inform me that something new happened, and that I should probably get it out and unlock it to check if this is maybe something I want to act on right now. Android wear is smartly not about "an Android phone on your wrist". It acknowledges that your wrist is a great place to glance at information, that this is what watches have always been used for, and provides a dead simple interface for exactly this usecase. It's the calculator apps and the pizza ordering apps (stupidly featured at I/O) that put this great product in danger of being misunderstood.
- hyp0 12y agoBTW: you can check some notifications without the unlocking step (at least, in 4.2.2). On the lockscreen, swipe left. There'll be a "+". Unlock on this screen, and you get a choice of apps to show on it (email, messaging, calendar etc). You can have several such screens (it seems, one app per screen). A long press gives allows deletion of that screen.