8 ms·
Twitter's User Problem: Fastest Gains Are People That Don't See Ads
- humility 12y agoTwitter's User Problem: No smart people at helm!
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- gdudeman 12y agoThis is sort of a silly problem since Twitter started at 100% off-Twitter and has exceeded all predictions at bringing people into their own experience. There are numerous, straightforward solutions to this. Twitter can require third party apps to show ads, for instance. Twitter can continue to copy functionality from third party apps and then squeeze them down. Or Twitter can worry about this once they are monetizing the bulk of their user base at 99% of the potential. I think this is genuinely a challenge for Twitter to solve, but I suspect (hope!) internally they spend much more time worrying about getting more users, how to meaningfully innovate and how to make Twitter more essential for the majority of their "sometimes" users.
- opendais 12y agoThe simplest solution, honestly, is to just require an application token and bill based on API calls. The only issue is dealing with fraud but that is the same risk you deal with in any business.
- iLoch 12y agoIIRC you do need an app token to make requests to the Twitter API, at least for users' timelines. So like gdudeman said, the solution is straight forward - requiring third party apps to show promoted tweets is an easily solution to this problem. They would just include these promoted tweets in with the other tweets in the feed API endpoint (do they really not do this as it stands? Seems like such an obvious thing to do.) Perhaps there's a technical reason for them not doing this, or maybe it's political.
- pogue 12y agoThe only trouble is that Twitter seems to be taking the opposite approach and blocking third party clients from functioning all together. http://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2011/03/twitter-tells-third-party-devs-to-stop-making-twitter-client-apps/ http://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2011/03/twitte... http://mashable.com/2012/08/16/twitter-api-big-changes/ http://mashable.com/2012/08/16/twitter-api-big-changes/
- tomjen3 12y agoNot just do they put severe limits on how many users you can get, they also have strict limits on how you are allowed to display the tweets (most importantly you are not allowed to merge feeds from different social networks into the timeline) which means I can't make the app that I wanted (which would take all the users accounts and merge them together). Their ability to do this, incidentally, is why I hate oAuth.
- dools 12y agoI see promoted tweets and I use Hootsuite ...
- aaronbrethorst 12y agoShrug. 'Real' native ads forthcoming, I guess. Or more API restrictions. Or both.
- cj 12y agoOn another note, as an advertiser on Twitter I'm surprised that I'm not allowed to create ads to be displayed to users in countries like India, Indonesia, Brazil, Russia, Mexico, Philippines, Vietnam, Germany, Turkey, Italy, Ukraine, Argentina, Poland, Peru, Saudi Arabia, Chile, Belgium, Greece, and all lesser populated countries. Since Twitter removed the option to create ads that target users worldwide, it's impossible to create a campaign that displays ads to users in less populous countries. Has Twitter made a deliberate decision to not monetize their "long tail" foreign users?
- tormeh 12y agoThat's a pretty fat long tail, if you ask me.
- goblin89 12y ago> as an advertiser on Twitter I'm surprised that I'm not allowed to create ads to be displayed to users in countries like India, Indonesia, Brazil, Russia, Mexico, Philippines, Vietnam, Germany, Turkey, Italy, Ukraine, Argentina, Poland, Peru, Saudi Arabia, Chile, Belgium, Greece, and all lesser populated countries. Yet rest (or don't) assured that users in at least couple of those countries do observe promoted tweets, pinned here and there in their timelines. Apparently there is a way.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- timerickson 12y agoTwitter… consider this: The 3rd-party experiences are simply better than your native ones, and not because of their lack of ads. Additionally, your own Tweetdeck and (seemingly abandoned) Twitter for Mac don't display ads.
- pogue 12y agoTwitter's support for Twitter power users, like those who use Tweetdeck has been abysmal. After buying it out, they turned off a bunch of great features the original client had and now rarely issue any updates. I assume they are trying to drive visitors to use the 'official' Twitter site, but it just doesn't make a whole lot of sense. No Tweetdeck user views ads, even though Twitter owns and operates the software. The only alternative for PC users is Hootsuite, and it is browser based. For anyone who wants to have multiple columns open at the same time or have notifications of direct messages or @replies, Tweetdeck is (essentially) the only game in town.
- stevengg 12y agomaybe its not the best idea to have a business model based on misclicks.
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 12y agoTwitter's Users' Problem: Deliberately locking themselves into a monopoly waiting to be abused.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- eps 12y agoI am guessing Twitter doesn't yet see 3rd party clients not showing ads as a big issue, because if it were, they would've shoveled them anyway through a simple T&C change. For larger client developers it'd be an offer they could not refuse, because they are as dependent on T for their revenue as it gets.
- erikb 12y agoWell, if Instagram is making money from Twitter users, why is Twitter not asking Instagram for a share? It's a quite straight forward idea and I don't see why there should be a problem. If so many people share from Instagram to Twitter then certainly Instagram wouldn't have a problem paying for the API, right?
- icebraining 12y agoAnd what if they refuse? Is Twitter going to block their links? Sounds like a bad PR move to me.
- ASneakyFox 12y agoIf the official Twitter app wasn't so bad I would use it. Twitters problem for me is how hard it is to browse its content. Its website has the same problem. I think they need to look more in to how people want to use their service. I'm sure its different for different kind of users. Eg some one following celebrities vs some one folllowing businessses vs some one following politics
- latitude 12y agoTwitter should really allow advertising to your existing following. I have an account for one of my projects that I use to announce new releases and updates. This happens once every few weeks, so I would pay for an option to stick my tweet at the top of my followers' feeds for, say, a week. If Twitter would then also allow people to unstick a tweet after reading it (or opt out of sticked tweets altogether), I think it'd be a great and welcome feature to have for everyone involved - TWTR gets paid, I get more eyes on my tweet and others won't miss my updates, which is what they followed me for to begin with.
- 1337biz 12y agoThis could really work! I think Twitter is much more about building an public identity than let's say Facebook. If they would allow their user to run minimal budget campaigns this could become much more successful/relevant than the typical Twitter ads.
- frostmatthew 12y ago> If Twitter would then also allow people to unstick a tweet after reading it I really like your idea of a stickied tweet but they should probably automatically unstick it once you've seen it.
- sp332 12y agoThere isn't really a way for Twitter to know if you've seen it if you don't interact with it in some way.
- frostmatthew 12y agoOf course there is (that's how they're calculating the impressions figure in your analytics).
- sp332 12y agoHow the heck does twitter know if I looked at a particular tweet?
- RexRollman 12y agoPersonally, I don't use Twitter anymore because I don't care for many of the changes they have made. I'm not talking about the advertising but the UI changes that is too busy. And the last time I created an account, Twitter had greatly complicated its settings, not to mention constantly badgering me to follow people. Twitter, Gmail, and Flickr all followed the same path: nice, functional interfaces that were needlessly complicated over time.
- plg 12y agoIs there any reason why we can't design a federated (non-centralized) version of twitter that doesn't depend on a business model of monetization? Every ad I see on twitter contributes to (what I assume is) my eventual abandonment of the service.
- kaoD 12y agoBitChirp[0] is a Twitter clone using BitMessage's infrastructure (though I'm not sure if BitMessage could ever handle Twitter's scale). Also Twister[1] based on BitTorrent + a blockchain for user registration. But of course these will never take over Twitter's kingdom. [0] https://bitchirp.org/ https://bitchirp.org/ [1] http://twister.net.co/ http://twister.net.co/
- frostmatthew 12y ago> Is there any reason why we can't design a federated (non-centralized) version of twitter that doesn't depend on a business model of monetization? Another alternative would be a business model that doesn't include advertising. App.net[1] attempted this, but clearly that didn't work out too well. [1] https://alpha.app.net/ https://alpha.app.net/
- ef4 12y agoThere's no fundamental reason. I think the internet swings back and forth between periods of openness and periods of walled gardens. We're in a walled garden period. My gut says it won't last forever. Our current walled gardens succeeded by refining the user experience of the open web they supplanted. They made it easy for normal users to do the things that only advanced users were able to do before: easily publish your own stream of content, find other people's content you care about, aggregate other people's content, and then let everybody generate new content that references the previous content. None of that is new functionality, but Facebook and Twitter fixed the user experience and taught normal people how to do all of that. But now that the bar has been raised and the average user groks the benefits of "social networking", there's nothing to stop the technology from eventually being commoditized. As for business models, a decentralized competitor doesn't actually need a business model, because their infrastructural costs could be zero. "HTTP" doesn't have or need a business model.
- rythie 12y agoI'd happily pay for the ability to use third party clients & no advertising on the main site. Anyone who doesn't want to pay can still use official apps and the website with ads. To me that would be a better solution than just slow killing all the third party apps for everyone.
- brianbreslin 12y agoIt looks like this would imply the next phase will be twitter either killing off third party apps for good (seems like their MO) or creating a federated ad network to insert into these third party streams (they should have done this 4 years ago).
- mark_l_watson 12y agoIn general I have a feeling of unease using "free" services, but it is nice to not have to pay for what I think services are worth (e.g., I would value Gmail at $8/month, Google+ at $3/month, Twitter at $2/month, Facebook at $3/month, Blogger at $5/month). One real value of Twitter, Google+, and Facebook is the quality of what people you are following post. The other (and larger for me) value is promoting my blog. Every time I write a new blog entry, I shamelessly promote it on social media. This is probably a crazy idea, but I wouldn't mind if these services had "hybrid" paid services: Pay a relatively small monthly or yearly fee, still see just a few advertisements, but much fewer advertisements than the free versions that are more geared to my interests than those advertisements that might make more money for the companies providing the series.
- pyvpx 12y agoyou are an extreme minority, statistically and financially.
- hyperbovine 12y agoWhy? Paying for the products you used was the dominant way of doing business for the last 5000 - 15 years of human history.
- GhotiFish 12y agoFortunately for businesses that existed those last 5000 - 15 years, copying a document wasn't free. Information couldn't be mass produced at a scale that renders the notion of supply meaningless. Businesses now have to compete with open source or decentralized services that cut them out. When money enters the equation, people immediately start shopping, they start asking "Is this an expense that is necessary?" That plus the amount of uncertainty john q public has on transmitting money online (a reticence I share to be honest), makes paying small fees a large barrier to entry. Besides, if I've learned anything, I've learned that just because you paid a company money, doesn't mean they won't turn around and sell you up the river. The barriers of trust for a service that's free and non-free are exactly the same.