2 ms·
The gambler's fantasy is a fantasy when you're trying to use it to predict a coin flip, not what another human will do. The penalty kicker has to make the same
by pessimizer 12y ago
The gambler's fantasy is a fantasy when you're trying to use it to predict a coin flip, not what another human will do. The penalty kicker has to make the same decision after looking at all previous results, and also may be making decisions about where to kick based on the direction of the previous kicks.
If the kickers attempt to second-guess the "this side is due for a kick" behavior by goalies, the goalies can try to second guess the kickers by knowing that they are intentionally trying to avoid even distributions over a moving historical window. It's the classic endless paper-rock-scissors strategy discussion.
- jameskilton 12y agoFrom the OP, 70% of goalies chose the opposite direction of the previous kick after 3 kicks. That's the "gambler's fallacy".
- jdminhbg 12y agoIt's not, because the direction the penalty taker chooses is not a random event. It may not be the optimum strategy, but it's not the gambler's fallacy.