3 ms·
Since I started paying attention, the definition has changed from “QoS on the last mile” to “slowing certain protocols” to “blocking competitive services” to “b
by nitrogen 12y ago
Since I started paying attention, the definition has changed from “QoS on the last mile” to “slowing certain protocols” to “blocking competitive services” to “blocking any services” to “not building enough capacity” to “fast lanes that aren’t CDNs” to “throttling any user” to “paying for interconnect”.
Effective net neutrality regulation has to address all of those things. If it seems like the goalposts have shifted, it's because ISPs have kept pushing the boundaries of what they can get away with in their quest to gouge their customers and extort Internet companies.
A neutral ISP only has to provide two things at minimum:
1. Guaranteed minimum throughput at peak times, with customer-controlled QoS determining which packets get dropped, and no discrimination on source, destination, protocol, or content that cannot be disabled by the user for free.
2. Sufficient upstream bandwidth, to those third-party services and networks customers are paying to use, to satisfy all minimum guaranteed demands under #1.