7 ms·
Gentrification May Actually Be Boon To Longtime Residents
- GigabyteCoin 12y agoThe pinnacle example of this imho is the 202 year old Parisien Au Richelieu Boulangerie (bakery) that closed it's doors recently in Paris due to rent increases because of it's proximity to the ever popular Louvre Museum. Even Paris is becoming too Parisienne for Paris! http://eater.com/archives/2013/01/02/the-oldest-bakery-in-paris-shutters-due-to-high-rent.php http://eater.com/archives/2013/01/02/the-oldest-bakery-in-pa...
- raldi 12y agoAnd yet when this fancy boulangerie opened in a modest neighborhood in 1812, that was a textbook example of gentrification.
- GigabyteCoin 12y agoTouché.
- forsaken 12y agoThis is only talking about people who own their homes. A lot of gentrification is happening in areas where historically the residents were suppressed from owning real estate. My own knowledge is mostly around the Portland, Oregon area, but there is a documented history of minorities being unable to purchase property, get loans, and lots of other institutional things that stop people from actually owning the land. For them, gentrification is definitely a bad thing. Edit: Reference here on page 25: http://aaablogs.uoregon.edu/visualculturesymposium/files/2011/02/Milo_Petruziello_2010_Project.pdf http://aaablogs.uoregon.edu/visualculturesymposium/files/201...
- spindritf 12y agohe also found that a lot of renters actually stay — especially if new parks, safer streets and better schools are paired with a job opportunity right down the block. That squares with the recent study[1] by the Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland. "We're finding that the financial health of original residents in gentrifying neighborhoods seems to be increasing, as compared to original residents in nongentrifying, low-priced neighborhoods," says Daniel Hartley, a research economist with the bank. He looked at the credit scores of original residents and found that they went up — regardless of whether they rented or owned — compared with residents who stayed in nongentrifying neighborhoods. From the OP. [1] http://www.clevelandfed.org/research/trends/2013/1113/01regeco.cfm http://www.clevelandfed.org/research/trends/2013/1113/01rege...
- gipp 12y agoThat seems like pretty clear-cut survivor bias.
- kens 12y agoIf you read the above link [1], it's not survivor bias: "Another way to cut the data is to compare movers and nonmovers across gentrifying and nongentrifying neighborhoods. Interestingly, there is a slightly larger increase in credit score (1.5 points more) associated with residents of the gentrifying neighborhoods who moved to a different neighborhood relative to those who lived in a gentrifying neighborhood but did not move. So it appears that, on average, movers are even slightly more positively affected by gentrification than nonmovers."
- gipp 12y agoFair enough. I just Ctrl-F'd 'bias' and had nothing, guess I could have been more thorough. That paragraph still fails to specify whether this applies only to homeowners and renters, or whether that still holds when looking just at rentership. We have "original resident renters living in gentrifying neighborhood benefit", and we have "movers overall benefit", but that doesn't necessarily imply "original resident renters who (were forced to) move benefit."
- johnrob 12y agoAgreed. Home owners in gentrified areas can't afford to move anywhere else (that isn't far away), so of course they stay put.
- anifow 12y agoGentrification is happenning in Toronto outside of the downtown core, albeit very slowly. The main effect is you have families cashing out and moving further and further away from the city to put the real estate price differentials to good use (bigger house, or cash in bank). In the current environment, it actually makes zero sense to buy residential property for the sake of renting it out, so the only ones who are long time owners. Over time, they too will cash out and it will be harder to find rentals until the neighbourhood either increases in status to command higher rates (like what happened in Kensington Market or in the Bellwood neighbourhood), or the property prices start falling to a low enough level that it makes sense to buy rental property again.
- jaman12 12y agohrm, this is not happening very slowly and has been going on for quite some time. It stretches all the way up into North York and is happening all through the GTA. Due to the free flow of capital and the visas that Canada was handing out to immigrants with significantly large amounts of capital you could come to Canada with millions and buy up a few properties to then rent them out. It makes sense to move your capital away from a highly unstable middle eastern/Asian country where you don't trust the ruling elite or you yourself are corrupt and fear reprisal. How do I know this? I've talked to a quite of few of these people; the highest number of properties that one person has owned and rented out for monthly income is 4 and he was considering bringing in a few more million from his bank in Dubai because he realized that the UAE has little future when global warming gets out of control. I can go on about the CPC members I've talked to, etc. Further more I know bankers that work for the chartered banks here and the stories they tell me of HNWI are simply ridiculous. Basically all this foreign capital tremendously augments the market, driving up prices for younger Canadians entering the real estate market for the first time -- this is the other side of the coin for those that didn't already have real estate downtown. Long term it does look good. Capital inflows are being clamped down due to the visa program being pulled and more capital restrictions on banks, which means that all of these prices will not be sustainable along with the fact the at some point interest rates will be going up (Carney did his damage before moving off to replace King because of the Libor market rigging at the BoE) and he has been doing similar stuff to England's housing market. Those of us who did not purchase properties outright have this to deal with once interest rates shoot up: http://www.cbc.ca/news/business/current-inflation-is-killing-off-the-canadian-middle-class-don-pittis-1.2711415 http://www.cbc.ca/news/business/current-inflation-is-killing... http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/middle-class-canadians-just-how-stretched-are-you-1.2572714 http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/middle-class-canadians-just-ho... At the end of the day gentrification in Toronto means less disposable income for those who can barely afford to have rents extracted from those that moved in their foreign capital. Although it's not as bad as the US where hedge funds are starting to buy up properties en masse.
- byerley 12y agoObviously this doesn't apply everywhere, but gentrification is really rough on students. Between tuition increases, rent increases, and high demand for student neighborhoods because they're "hip", students moving to certain areas are being pushed farther and farther away from the actual school (because of both price and availability). DC is particularly bad in this regard.
- shaftoe 12y agoIt's always hilarious to see arguments that people fixing up a run down neighborhood is terrible. That improvement is unfair to the people who ran it down or didn't own anything there to begin with. Let's just have things stay crappy and life will be fair to all.
- gress 12y agoIt's always depressing to see casual dismissals based on the just-world fallacy and misrepresentation.
- infosample 12y agoshaftoe, as a thought experiment consider why the neighborhood is run down. Did the people run down the neighborhood because that's what they like? How was the economic situation for these people? How were the schools, the hospitals, the law enforcement? Was there housing discrimination? How were their politicians? What was the funding like compared to other neighborhoods? In other words, how was the neighborhood before it was crappy and how did it become so?
- otterley 12y agoHow are these matters relevant to the opinion that improving neighborhoods is a good thing?
- infosample 12y ago"That improvement is unfair to the people who ran it down" Assumption 1: The residents are the people who ran down the neighborhood. Assumption 2: Gentrification improves the neighborhood. My previous comment addresses the first assumption. Feel free to disagree. If a neighborhood is just real estate, assumption two is valid. If a neighborhood is a community of people, and gentrification moves a lot of the people, you have not improved the neighborhood, you displaced it. Once we question these assumptions, perhaps we can address the root problems.
- 12y ago
- wallflower 12y agoThis article conveniently sashays around the real effects of gentrification due to the "entitlement" mentality of the more recent newcomers. For example, I heard of a neighborhood ballpark that was used for decades by Latino children to play ball. The newcomers with dogs would chuck their dog's droppings over the fence and onto the ballpark. Latinos who used to play dominos outside at another park. Until they were continually harassed by cops to stop gathering in a public area to play dominos. Seems like the newcomers didn't like the bodega feel when they were out walking their dogs. See also: "Inside the Barista Class" http://www.theawl.com/2014/03/the-service-economy-trap-inside-brooklyns-barista-class http://www.theawl.com/2014/03/the-service-economy-trap-insid...
- forrestthewoods 12y agoIt's entitlement all the way down. People who live somewhere feel entitled to stay there indefinitely because they were there "first". People who don't live there feel entitled to buy their way in because that's how supply and demand work.
- infosample 12y agoI don't think people who live in bad neighborhoods feel entitled. The choice is often moving from one bad neighborhood to another. Moving is expensive and a hassle for everyone, it's no wonder people don't want to move without a strong incentive.
- forrestthewoods 12y agoDefine bad? Do you mean bad as in poor or bad as in dangerous and unsafe. I mostly hear gentrification in the context of poor neighborhoods rather than unsafe.
- infosample 12y agoI don't think gentrification is happening in dangerous and unsafe neighborhoods. It's my opinion that is where many displaced residents move. Note: opinion, not fact. I actually agree with your overall point - unless you own, you shouldn't feel entitled to stay. You should, however, be entitled to a safe neighborhood and legitimate opportunity.
- danohuiginn 12y ago'"To my surprise," Freeman says, "it seemed to suggest that people in neighborhoods classified as gentrifying were moving less frequently."' Well, duh. With rents rising, your only chance to stay in the neighbourhood is to cling on to your existing contract. Look at a fully-gentrified neighbourhood; the only low-income residents will be those who have been living in the same home for decades, with a rental contract that protected them from rent increases.
- hyperpape 12y agoA good possibility, but many cities don't have rent control and/or give landlords lots of leeway to raise rents. You'd have to break it down by city to see whether the effect was limited to cities with rent control.
- danohuiginn 12y agofair enough. I'm mainly thinking of a European context -- tenants rights in the US being much weaker, the same pattern may not apply there.
- pessimizer 12y agoThere's no link to the first study, but I'm pretty sure the results of the Cleveland Fed are a result of the batty definition of gentrification used: "For the purpose of this analysis, I will say a neighborhood is gentrifying if it is located in the central city of a metropolitan area and it goes from being in the bottom half of the distribution of home prices in the metropolitan area to the top half between 2000 and 2007. Housing prices are a good measure of gentrification since they provide a summary of the various amenities in the neighborhood. Changes in neighborhood amenities such as increases in school quality or decreases in crime should be reflected in changes in neighborhood home prices." Again: Entirely based on home prices (reasonable), but not on home price improvement, but instead based on passing from the lower half of the entire distribution of prices in a metropolitan area to the upper half. This could happen if housing prices declined in an area if the mean price in the metro declined slightly faster. This is not what normal people are talking about when they refer to gentrification.
- 616c 12y agoAnyone who has met long-time residents of Washington DC knows that yeah, if you are white and rich it is working great for you. If you are black, it is not. I could write a thesis, and maybe DC is exceptional, but this is wishful thinking. I lived in a very gentrified area of Washington for period. It was very weird. You are pushing out the poor people and you both want to pretend you do not notice. I believe saying the opposite is disingenuous.
- delinka 12y agoCan someone help me understand the problems with gentrification? Do renters feel entitled to stay in their neighborhoods even when their leases end? When owners need to perform remodels on [unoccupied] aging homes? The only real issue that comes to mind is the owner of a home on a fixed income having to pay higher property taxes because the area around them is improving. I can think of lots of ways to mitigate this problem ... but I'm asking about other problems of which I know nothing.
- trysomething 12y agoNature has endowed mankind with diverse faculties, fallible reason and variable fortune, and so in a free society there will by necessity be "winners" and "losers". Those of you who reflexively oppose gentrification ought to consider what type of society you want to live in. Do you believe that individuals have the right to make decisions that could affect their own lives beneficially or adversely? One such decision is to rent or buy property. There are clearly potential benefits and drawbacks to either choice. I may value stability of residence and the chance my chosen property will appreciate, and therefore choose to buy, and so put capital down and strain my credit. Alternatively, I may want to bootstrap a small business or startup using the same capital and credit, and therefore choose to rent. When, in the name of stopping the "evil" of gentrification, you propose to severely restrict what a property owner can do, such as through rent control, you are also proposing to restrict the original choice to rent or buy. You are thus limiting the opportunity of the less fortunate to buy when and where the price is low and sell if and when the price gets high. In the name of protecting the vulnerable, you prevent them from advancing to a better station in life. It's very easy to consider the benefits of laws and regulation while ignoring the costs.