3 ms·
The nation needs an intelligence community. In the modern world, that's non-negotiable. But having said that, there are a few breaches of trust that warrant ex
by DanielBMarkham 12y ago
The nation needs an intelligence community. In the modern world, that's non-negotiable.
But having said that, there are a few breaches of trust that warrant extreme action, and this is one of them. This isn't some low-level analyst using his pull to get out of a parking ticket. This is the executive branch of government running an intelligence operation against another branch of the government.
There's no known universe in which this is anywhere near being acceptable. And even if you buy the lone wolf scenario thrown out here, it still means that the agency had an atmosphere in which it seemed okay to do this -- and it was done with little or no oversight. In fact, this is a much worse scenario, because it implies that lone wolves all over the agency are doing all sorts of things on their own initiative. God knows what.
Congress, kicking and screaming, is going to have to grow a set of balls and publicly tear apart the intelligence apparatus again. We are probably going to need new constitutional amendments to address property rights and the idea of "personal papers" in the digital age. Computers are extensions of people's minds. They are not like music players or VCRs. Not at all.
This whole mess has been an example of how the political class will put off making a decision that might involve risk as long as possible. I keep wondering what more has to come out, and how much is enough.
Sadly, I think we're not there yet.
- sroerick 12y agoWhat do you think about the open intelligence movement?
- DanielBMarkham 12y agoNever heard of it. The title sounds interesting.
- ianstallings 12y agoHere is some more info on a figure behind the open source intelligence movement below. It's not just intelligence that they want to reform, it's the entire system. http://www.theguardian.com/environment/earth-insight/2014/jun/19/open-source-revolution-conquer-one-percent-cia-spy http://www.theguardian.com/environment/earth-insight/2014/ju...