4 ms·
> Someone just attempting an offline wikipedia on their own HDD is always going to have to go to serious complexities unless there is some form of back system i
by pyre 17y ago
> Someone just attempting an offline wikipedia on their own HDD is always going to have to go to serious complexities unless there is some form of back system in place to access.
Not necessarily. The problem is that if I wanted to do a full offline version of Wikipedia (sans media) there are no incremental updates. IIRC, you would have to re-download the whole thing, even for articles with no changes (or minor/insignificant changes). That's what makes the 'on demand' aspect of a 3rd-party offline Wikipedia app the best model from a bandwidth conservation point of view.
I agree that Wikipedia could do something like this with at least the text-only portions of the site. I feel that they would run into a lot of legal troubles with the media though. Lots of the media is user-submitted, but things like logos, trademarks, 'fair-use' of copyrighted material could get them into a lot of legal battles if they tried to sell/distribute an offline version.
Even with the text portions of the site, I'm sure they would end up with a few lawsuits from large contributors here and there. Even if the lawsuits were frivolous.
Even on an official Wikipedia product, you'll have to think about the bandwidth consumption that would happen from these devices phoning home for updates. While it might help them cut down on actual page hits to the site, it might not as people will probably have to access this from a laptop, and would still use the web browser on their cell/smart phone to do a quick lookup on a spur of the moment topic.