4 ms·
> Individuals can learn how to deal with the symptoms of autism and how to appear "normal" to others, but that doesn't make it a cure. How can you know that? I
by astrange 12y ago
> Individuals can learn how to deal with the symptoms of autism and how to appear "normal" to others, but that doesn't make it a cure.
How can you know that? I mean, you seem to be just restating the status quo against this article, but they've provided evidence against it, and you're not providing any evidence for it.
It doesn't seem like the kids have to do anything consciously such that they'd "become autistic" again if they stopped.
What's most interesting to me is that they can't tell what's going on inside young kids just by observing them.
- 6581 12y agoDSM-5 explicitly states that diagnostic criteria may apply "currently or by history". This makes a cure for autism impossible by definition.
- cma 12y agoNewer history can exclude a diagnosis based on older history.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- voxic11 12y agoAnd yet it seems to be wrong.
- ashleyp 12y agoThere is NO evidence of a cure for Autism. Not even this article is evidence.
- gohrt 12y agohttp://www.logicallyfallacious.com/index.php/logical-fallacies/27-appeal-to-definition http://www.logicallyfallacious.com/index.php/logical-fallaci... Even ignoring the fact that DSM has major changes in every revision... That's totally unhelpful. Use words to communicate, not confuse. If I say "two plus two is five", and then explain it by counting "one, two, three, five", it's clear that I am using a different word, but I have the same idea as the common "two plus two is four". When you seek to compate with a definition to empirical data, if the definition doesn't match, that means that the words we are using need to be clarified, not that the empirical data is wrong. (The data might be wrong, but "appeal to dictionary" is not a persuasive argument.
- 6581 12y agoThe problem is that the only broadly accepted definitions of autism we have are in the DSM-5 and ICD-10. In a broader sense, this shows a fundamental flaw of psychology. I'm not saying I agree with the diagnostic criteria, but it's all we have.
- DanBC 12y agoIt's a shame that my sceptic-hackles were raised before I'd finished reading this article or any of the research. There is so much really harmful nonsense pushed as "cures for Autism", and some of it is pushed with poor quality studies, that I am wary even of seemingly good interventions like this one.
- makomk 12y agoAutism affects a bunch of stuff like sensory processing, planning, reasoning... Those underlying differences don't go away when someone learns to cope with the symptoms, and they will cause problems if their coping strategies ever fail or cease to apply for whatever reason.
- Maken 12y agoI can't speak for other people with similar experiences, but that's how I operate right now. As I grew up I learned how I'm supposed to interact with other people and how to control myself in certain situations. I don't think I'm "cured" by any means, but I'm able to do normal social interaction and my autism isn't apparent at all.
- PhasmaFelis 12y ago> How can you know that? I mean, you seem to be just restating the status quo against this article, but they've provided evidence against it, and you're not providing any evidence for it. Hi, autistic person here. I was always relatively high-functioning, in some ways. I was always better than my peers at math and reading, but my social disability was crippling. In retrospect, I had a lot of the standard characteristics--repetitive movements, ADD, obsessive behavior, freaking out if things didn't fit my plans or expectations--but the inability to recognize social cues was the one that caused me the most trouble and pain. And I fixed it. At some point in middle school, another autistic boy in my special-ed class was really annoying me, and I realized that he was acting exactly the same way I did. I could recognize it in him, but not in myself. So, to gloss over 20 years of effort and practice and failure, I taught myself to see myself as an outside observer, to judge my own behavior--first broadly, and slowly narrowing down to tone, word choice, and body language--as I would judge someone else's. I'm pretty social these days. Most people don't know I'm autistic unless I tell them (which I do if it comes up; I'm not ashamed of it). A lot of the folks in the article would probably say that my autism had been cured. And they'd be full of shit. I still obsess over minutae. Properly focused, it can be a genuine joy. It still really, seriously troubles me when plans are changed at the last minute, but most of the time I can take a deep breath and move on. I still stim, but I can suppress it around strangers. And, sometimes, with the right sort of data-analysis problem, I can apply the sort of absolute, crystalline clarity that people normally associate with Rain Man. I am an autistic person who has learned good coping strategies. So are "B." and Mark Macluskie and Matt Tremblay and the rest. The article repeatedly mentions lingering autistic traits, like Mark's tactile aversions and Matt's flapping, but somehow they don't count. In this mindset, autism is a sickness, and if you're no longer visibly sick then you must not be autistic. That's bullshit. Autism is in the way your mind is shaped. It has good sides and it has bad sides. Some people, with the right treatment and insights, learn how to accentuate the good and minimize the bad. That's not a "cure," it's dealing with life.