9 ms·
The Other Aging of America: The Increasing Dominance of Older Firms
- zwieback 12y agoWow - didn't expect the numbers to be so high in the high-tech sector. I'd love to see the data of the last two years. It feels like the majority of activity in tech is in startups but economically that's totally untrue.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- seabee 12y agoTo me it feels like the majority of progress and innovation in tech is in startups, but the majority of activity is uninnovative. For example, a lot gets done in the enterprise software market, though most of it is very boring and uncreative from a technical perspective.
- lkrubner 12y agoRelated, and worth reading: http://www.moneyandbanking.com/commentary/2014/6/23/growth-and-dynamism-troubling-facts http://www.moneyandbanking.com/commentary/2014/6/23/growth-a... excerpt: "Market economies are characterized by high turnover of both workers and firms. This “churning” is part of the process of “creative destruction” that shifts economic activity to more productive uses. The U.S. economy has typically stood out for its level of dynamism. But recent research has highlighted the long-term slowdown in the U.S. pace of gross job creation and job destruction (see top panel below), at least part of which has been associated with the decline in firm startups" It's easy to get a rosy view of things, reading Hacker News, as Hacker News is attached to one of the few parts of the USA business community that remains dynamic. But it is important to take a wider view. The bulk of business activity in the USA has seen a decline in dynamic new formation. The decline started around 1980 and has gotten worse over the last 30 years. Here is another one worth reading: http://www.brookings.edu/research/papers/2014/05/declining-business-dynamism-litan http://www.brookings.edu/research/papers/2014/05/declining-b... That one looks at specific cities. The news is troubling and grim. The trend is more than 30 years old, and appears to be accelerating.
- _delirium 12y agoEven in tech I think it's easy to overstate the level of dynamism. A lot of the buzz is around startups, but a huge amount of the industry is owned by fairly old companies. Digging through the Forbes 500 list, there are 10 companies of the top 100 that I would consider "tech". They are (with year of founding): #5 Apple (1976), #17 HP (1939), #23 IBM (1911), #34 Microsoft (1975), #35 Amazon (1994), #46 Google (1998), #53 Intel (1968), #55 Cisco (1984), #69 Ingram Micro (1979), #82 Oracle (1977). By decade that's: 2 from the '90s, 1 from the '80s, 4 from the '70s, 1 from the '60s, 2 pre-WW2. Looks like the '70s were a good time to do a tech startup. :)
- rodgerd 12y agoAnd the companies from the 70s (Apple, Microsoft, and Oracle) are doing their damndest to make sure they kill one from the 90s (Google).
- muzz 12y agoThe second paper is somewhat of a canard. There are fewer "firms" than 30 years ago largely because of fewer small players in areas like retail and construction (for example, fewer Mom-and-Pop shops and more market share to WalMart, etc). Noah Smith wrote a good rebuttal: http://noahpinionblog.blogspot.com/2014/05/declining-us-dynamism-story-or-non-story.html http://noahpinionblog.blogspot.com/2014/05/declining-us-dyna...
- ThomPete 12y agoIt still means less jobs netto and this is only going to keep declining.
- UweSchmidt 12y agoDominance of large players could be a major reason for a less dynamic economy, so your link is not really a rebuttal. Can you clarify?
- muzz 12y ago
- protonfish 12y agoThis seems like another symptom of the widening income gap. You need money to start a new venture and the average worker no longer has much to spare. Meanwhile large corporations have increased power and influence acquire/stifle competition.
- mhb 12y agoOr it could be a symptom of an increasingly risk-averse society which encourages its government to promulgate ever more regulations to keep us "safe". Big/rich companies are favored by that, so the causality isn't obvious.
- watwut 12y agoAmericans tend to be incredibly risk-averse when it comes to physical risks and terrorism, but they seem much less risk averse when it comes to money. Given the same personal financial risk, Americans seem more likely to start risky business.
- muzz 12y agoOr it could be that there are fewer anti-monopoly laws, and that's resulted in huge megacorporations, especially in areas like banking.
- gcp 12y ago...not to mention things like the patent system, which also help the established.
- PaulHoule 12y agoOne thing I've noticed is that vc backed companies in my field don't last more than 5yrs. Maybe 2/3 get acquired, 1/3 get shut down, but I see so few survivors I won't offer a probability estimate.
- Iftheshoefits 12y agoThe goal of VC backed companies today is to cash out as much "value" (ROI) as possible, as soon as possible. VC firms aren't meant to last; they're meant to enrich (a very select few).
- PaulHoule 12y agoIt is funny to compare today to the old days, say the 1980s, when public investors made fortunes investing in companies like AAPL and MSFT. These were startups that became "old companies". Compare that to FB, we have to wait another 20-30 years to really know, but it's hard to see FB growing the way AAPL and MSFT did.
- michaelochurch 12y agoThis is damning data, proving that the "startup revolution" of the past 20 years and of the Valley is a fraud. Of course, many of us already knew this, but it's nice to see data that proves our point. The main role of the VCs, at this point, is not to empower companies but to fund the competition (an extortion dynamic: "take our terms or we throw 'rocket fuel' to your competitors, who might crash and burn but will take you down before they do"). Subtle distinction. Management-wise, VCs take away far more than they add. The money (ahem, other peoples' money) that they infuse should be a commodity, but they're going to fight as hard as they can to make it not so. Thus, they've created a "startup" economy in which they: * Build crappy "throwaway" companies not built to last, with the hope that one will latch on to a genuine new technical idea and go 100x. * Increase the entrepreneurial activity of one sector, slightly, in one location while draining the rest of the country and society. Also, the power of the VC oligarchy is enhanced by the fact that bank loans (the traditional way of starting a business) are completely broken at this point. Getting a bank loan requires personal liability, which makes it a non-starter for anything that might actually fail. Business is becoming a generational aristocracy at this point. You don't need to look any further than the absurd propping-up of boy kings Lucas Duplan and Evan Speigel. (They even look like Joffrey Baratheon!) I don't have any prima facie dislike for capitalism. In fact, it's a necessary core component of any advanced society. But corporate capitalism is a dinosaur and it's time to go Yucatan on its ass.
- scarmig 12y agoI love that I can tell the author of a comment by the end of the first sentence =) Spot on, though. I would take a bit issue with your last point: imagining a good capitalism and a bad capitalism, and saying the issue is just we just got dealt a bad capitalism, is strikingly similar to socialists who say the same about the USSR--"but that wasn't real socialism!" Especially since many people approve of capitalism as it exists today and would argue that this is how it's supposed to be. I'd also question terming it a dinosaur. The distinguishing characteristic of corporate capitalism is an amazing ability to adapt, survive, co-opt possible threats, and shift costs onto individuals outside the system. It's the most robust creature on the planet right now.
- arbuge 12y ago
- pessimizer 12y agoThe stability of incumbents is an inevitable result of government corruption. edit: The first company that is successful in a space will accumulate the money and the clout to keep competitors out of the industry and influence regulation to protect their position. The only worry such a company has is that a larger, more incumbent company in a related industry will undercut them by taking a loss, either through expensive lobbying or aggressive underpricing. Since Reagan, the US has openly been reducing taxes and extending subsidies and bailouts to the largest companies, and finance/media rules have been gradually dismantled enabling politicians to take better advantage of indirect payments. The reason incumbents have been more successful since 1980 is a direct result of government corruption, and is no different than similar patterns within other corrupt economies. edit2: I forgot the incumbent option of buying the competition though the furious M&A that has also increased steadily during the same period, along with increasing weakness of antitrust legislation which encourages the behavior. It's sad that we live in a time (due to computing and the internet) when starting or expanding a new or small business is less capital intensive than it has been in history, yet the incumbents have used regulation to make themselves more entrenched than they've been in nearly 100 years.
- rayiner 12y ago> The stability of incumbents is an inevitable result of government corruption. I strongly disagree. What makes it hard to compete with Microsoft in the consumer PC/office suite space? What makes it hard to compete with Apple or Samsung in the phone/tablet space? What makes it hard to compete with Amazon in the retail space, or Oracle in the DB space? IBM in the IT consulting space? Intel in the desktop CPU space? Google in the search space? Are these companies protected by "government corruption?" Large companies have certain disadvantages, but in general have overwhelming advantages. Take Apple or Intel, who can throw massive money at manufacturing R&D. An upstart competitor simply can't build a similar product at a similar price point. Take Microsoft, which can exploit massive network effects, or Amazon, which can exploit tremendous efficiencies of scale in logistics. Even in the purely online world, there are benefits to scale, either network effects like Facebook's, or being able to deliver better results because of the sheer volume of data a company like Google has access to. Consolidation is the natural direction of a market economy, because at the end of the day the market favors efficiency and scale, and Wal-Mart is efficient in a way thousands of little mom & pops aren't. Indeed, if anything, technology accelerates the effect. It's much easier, in a world with internet, instant messaging, etc, to run a 100,000+ employee company efficiently than it was say 50 years ago. As technology gets better, the equilibrium point at which diseconomies of scaling bigger outweigh economies of scaling bigger gets pushed further out.
- triangleman 12y agoI have not had a chance to read the paper, but I would be surprised if the findings really tell us about some new trend in the U.S. economy. Here are the 30 companies that were in the Dow Jones Industrial Average, 30 years ago [1], with an asterisk indicating the companies that are still in the DJIA: Allied-Signal Incorporated Aluminum Company of America American Can * American Express Company * American Telephone and Telegraph Company Bethlehem Steel * Chevron Corporation (formerly Standard Oil of California) E. I. du Pont de Nemours and Company Eastman Kodak Company * Exxon Corporation * General Electric Company General Motors Corporation Goodyear Inco * International Business Machines International Harvester International Paper Company * McDonald’s Corporation * Merck & Co., Inc. * Minnesota Mining & Manufacturing Owens-Illinois Glass Philip Morris Companies Inc. * Procter & Gamble Company Sears Roebuck & Company Texaco Incorporated Union Carbide United Technologies Corporation U.S. Steel Westinghouse Electric Woolworth Only 10 of the 30 companies are still in the Down Jones. Some of these companies may be represented in merged companies under new names, but you can still see the huge change in the makeup of the U.S. economy compared to 30 years ago. This is not to say that income inequality is not a big problem, but I believe that it's premature to say that the U.S. economy has lost its dynamism and competitiveness. [1]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Historical_components_of_the_Dow_Jones_Industrial_Average http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Historical_components_of_the_Do...
- Retric 12y agoGlobalization killed several of those, but that's not a recent change. 4 being steel or aluminum companies. Walmart seems to be the only real disruption on that list. AT&T was split up and now occupies 2 spaces (AT&T, Verizon). Texico is part of Cheveron which is still on the DOW. So one split and one merge. Several like Philip Morris are on the S&P 500. (allied-signal incorperated = Honneywell, E I du Point = DoPont, Goodyear, GM, union carbide is part of DOW, Owens-Illinois) PS: If anything the average age significantly increased.
- supercanuck 12y ago* Next to E. I. du Pont de Nemours and Company which is DuPont.
- 12y ago
- bjones53 12y agoI was disappointed that the article didn't acknowledge the impact globalization has likely had on the increasing number of 'Older Firms'. Global markets bring massive opportunities, but large corporations are better positioned to succeed in a global marketplace. Global markets also means global competition - for jobs and for entrepreneurs.
- juliangamble 12y agoFirms spend much more of their time on survival. Arguably they have incorporated the market-based cycles of creation and destruction inwardly. ie they have absorbed this cycle. In technology we see this in two areas: 1. In Outsourcing and the rise of contractors http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Business_process_outsourcing_to_India http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Business_process_outsourcing_to... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Information_technology_outsourcing http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Information_technology_outsourc... This enables the business to spend money on product maintenance and product development. Then the business can shut this off when cashflow stops. (But the firm keeps going!) 2. We see the rise of Product Management http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Product_management http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Product_management This is a kind of 'management science' devoted to starting, maintaining and stopping products. (But the firm keeps going!) The point I'm making is that firms are getting older because they can incorporate the cycles of creation and destruction internally. You might argue this is good for the shareholder in the medium term.
- thomasmarriott 12y agoScale is underrated. Cumulative advantage.