5 ms·
Starting a debate by immediately framing anyone who disagrees with you as an apologist and their arguments as false equivalencies (you mean "equivalances" by th
by mike_hearn 12y ago
Starting a debate by immediately framing anyone who disagrees with you as an apologist and their arguments as false equivalencies (you mean "equivalances" by the way) is neither helpful to good debate, nor going to persuade anyone.
You don't have to stretch out your reading very far to discover that lots of news sites, especially outside the USA, are flooded with comments from people who have been posting to them for years and yet are deeply skeptical about the current wave of anti-Russian stories being pumped by western media. This isn't being "pro Putin", it's about realising that our own governments are so deeply and nauseatingly hypocritical that anything they say can be safely assumed to be the opposite of the truth.
E.g. whilst the western media is busy trying to claim that only evil authoritarian Russians would be so draconian as to forbid anonymous blogging, the NSA is busy de-anonymizing any blogger or any other internet user they wish bypassing the systems of law and democracy entirely. Is that really a false equivalence, or is it just pointing out the painful and obvious truth?
- BugBrother 12y agoNote that the democratic world's media are very heterogeneous. It isn't often they agree on much (see the Viernam war, Israel, Iraq war, etc in European media). On this subject, most everyone do agree. Again note -- that is unusual. Maybe unique. And you claim that is a conspiracy, based on that there are lots of spin used on every subject by everyone with a finger in a pie? That is exactly what Putin's media writes -- the whole [non dictatorial] world is in a conspiracy against Russia. Because they hate Russia! (I can tell you how unanimous this is in Sweden: Most of the left wing extremists don't support Putin re Ukraine. These people in Sweden are USA haters which have never supported a democracy in a conflict with a democracy...)
- mike_hearn 12y agoBoth Iraq and Israel are absolutely notorious for being subjects where all major western news outlets toe or toed the political line. Whilst Israel is treated somewhat neutrally outside the USA, the puppy-like behaviour of American media is so extreme it is itself worthy of news articles: http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2014/jul/31/american-media-israel-bias-netanyahu http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2014/jul/31/america... The runup to the war in Iraq is widely considered to be one of the western media's biggest and most damaging failures, including by those outlets themselves: http://www.salon.com/2007/04/10/media_failure/ http://www.salon.com/2007/04/10/media_failure/ http://www.theguardian.com/world/2004/may/27/media.iraq http://www.theguardian.com/world/2004/may/27/media.iraq http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Media_coverage_of_the_Iraq_War http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Media_coverage_of_the_Iraq_War With respect to your assertion that "most everyone do agree", did you read my comment? It's very much NOT the case that everyone agrees on this. Here's the Guardian's view: http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2014/jul/30/guardian-view-sanctions-against-russia http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2014/jul/30/guardia... Hardly a ringing endorsement of sanctions. Now go look at the comments section. Pick comments pointing out western hypocrisy and take a look at the posting history of those accounts. For instance, check out TheGreatRonRafferty. Posting on the site for years, thousands of comments. Many other views like his expressed there. If you think this is all the work of the FSB you're delusional, I don't know how else to say it.
- huhtenberg 12y agoYou can't say these things on HN. It's not nice. Putin is a villain, period. Who are you to spoil the bashing with your rational arguments?
- VMG 12y agoFor sarcasm to work it must mock something that does exist.
- huhtenberg 12y agoAre you saying that strong anti-Russian bias doesn't exist on HN? You must be reading it in some filtered form.
- dictum 12y agoConflating "anti-Putin" with "anti-Russian" doesn't help your argument.
- VMG 12y agoThere probably is an anti-Putin sentiment, but there are good reasons for that. In any case, the post you replied to wasn't even pro-Putin and hasn't been punished by any anti-Putin bias on HN.
- true_religion 12y agoJust because people don't like a particular person doesn't mean they are biased against them. Their dislike could be rooted strongly in the actions the person has committed. By the way, its very difficult to prove bias against a single person as opposed to a group. With a group, you can show bias easily by pointing out someones dislike for a member of the group who only shares superficial traits with the rest of the group (e.g. ethnicity/nationality/gender/etc.). But for a person? Even if you're suspicious of every seemingly innocuous action of them, it can be justified by saying they have lost your trust due to actions in the past.
- 12y ago
- tptacek 12y agoYou don't see the irony of complaining about a "false equivalence" complaint in the same comment where you attempt to compare Russia, where bloggers will have to register with the state and are forbidden to use services outside the state's jurisdiction, with the US? NSA's actions have been indefensible, but they aren't the same as Russia's. Your comparison is itself a textbook false equivalence.
- mladenkovacevic 12y agoNo they are not the same as Russia's but are they any better? Forced registration vs. forced de-anonymisation. At least in Russia's case there is some input required from the blogger. With the NSA you just have to sit back and let them do all the hard work. Better customer service I guess. Either way, arguing over whose government is less tyrannical is probably not the conversation we should be having. But the OP certainly had a point when he stated that preemptively calling out "apologists" is a bad debate technique. EDIT: Also he wasn't complaining about false equivalences (the post he was replying to was doing that). He was complaining about certain genuine equivalences routinely being called out as false.
- tptacek 12y agoYes, what the US is doing is bad, but it is better than what Russia is doing. "Ask a simple question", &c.
- mladenkovacevic 12y agoThanks for falling back to "Whatever.. my opinion is better than yours." It's always a treat to see the resilience of subjective convictions on display.
- pessimizer 12y ago>You don't see the irony of complaining about a "false equivalence" complaint Complaining about "false equivalence" complaints that have yet to have been made, rather. Just like the PHP people who preemptively defend PHP in threads before it has been criticized. The PHP people have an excuse though: they're punch drunk from being constantly attacked. Attacking Russia is attacking from the herd, and very easy to do. The last thing anyone who cares about truth should be doing is discouraging dissent from the herd. I have to say that the tradition of accusing people of setting up false equivalences by daring to even compare any aspect of America the Incomparable to places like Iran, Russia, or China is a reprehensible one, too. The confidence in the tautological superiority of every aspect of the US to every aspect of every other country is why clearly broken things about the US can remain broken for decades (like health care, etc.) It also exposes a sensitivity (thus a recognition) of the critique. In all forms of analysis that I'm aware of, the way you examine things that are broken or eccentric is to compare them to things that work correctly or in a straightforward manner through noting the differences. If you do that between the American and Russian media, you will quickly realize that you're working with two horribly broken systems, and it's about as worthwhile as comparing a kick in the nuts to a punch in the face.
- mpyne 12y ago> the NSA is busy de-anonymizing any blogger or any other internet user they wish bypassing the systems of law and democracy entirely. Western governments routinely de-anonymize citizens. E.g. when a serial killer finally gets tracked down despite taking pains to remain anonymous, we normally consider that upholding justice, not subverting law and democracy. So while the NSA has certainly done some horrible things, merely trying to de-anonymize reasonably suspicious actors isn't necessarily one of them. And even if we assume the NSA were unreasonably de-anonymizing people as a matter of course, their job would certainly be a hell of a lot easier there if the U.S. could force bloggers to register after 3,000 hits!
- dinkumthinkum 12y agoNo, this is nothing at all but a paltry false equivalence. Let's say the big bad NSA was all you they are .... You've already lost this false equivalence. In that case, what would the NSA do to a blogger, the answer because the US has something called the Constitution, and though you may cynically, the US couldn't throw someone in jail for whatever the NSA dredges up or whatever while in Russia, the same is not the case. There are not any real credible cases of people being poisoned for thought crime.