2 ms·
> It's interesting that gmail is the least likely used for fraud, why is that? I spent several years working on the Gmail abuse team. Gmail is used less for fr
by mike_hearn 12y ago
> It's interesting that gmail is the least likely used for fraud, why is that?
I spent several years working on the Gmail abuse team. Gmail is used less for fraud than other providers because we were better at fighting abuse than our competitors: as simple as that. Yahoo had a rather hollowed out abuse team for a long time, from what I understand, they didn't invest in it at all. And I think at Microsoft the Hotmail and Passport (i.e. login system) teams were much more compartmentalised than we were inside Google. At least this is what I heard on the grapevine, though I have no clue if it's accurate.
Google does many, many things to combat abuse of Gmail accounts. There's no silver bullet, it's not as simple as "Google phone verifies every account" (it does not and never has), or "if you send more than X messages you get Y". The abuse system is a massively complex pile of interlocking systems, analyses and heuristics.
You can get a good readout of how various teams at the different companies do here:
https://buyaccs.com/ https://buyaccs.com/
As you can see currently Outlook.com accounts currently sell for $10 per thousand. Gmail accounts are about $100 per thousand, an order of magnitude more expensive. Getting higher than that is very difficult against good opponents (and the guy who runs buyaccs.com is good, although these days he acts more as a reseller than an account creator himself). The reason is, at these prices it's feasible to simply phone verify every single account by hand using cheap SIM cards. Google does terminate accounts that have phone verified - it's just one more signal - but it's one of the best ones and so it becomes significantly more dangerous when spammers are phone verifying in bulk. In practice it's not a big deal because $100 per thousand is high enough that many business models (like simple spamming) become unprofitable.
As an example of techniques Google uses: machine learning, manually written logic, real time statistics, randomly generated and obfuscated signal gathering Javascripts, offline clustering pipelines and a team of people with big screens around their office with lots of graphs on them. Those people keep an eye on the system around the clock and if they see e.g. an unexplained spike in account creations then they will manually investigate what was going on. They are very good at quickly identifying mistakes made by account creators and clustering the accounts by hand.