4 ms·
"Not perfect" means broken, since such cherry picking can easily pile up to hundreds and thousands like EFF said in the post. There is no doubt about the amount
by shmerl 12y ago
"Not perfect" means broken, since such cherry picking can easily pile up to hundreds and thousands like EFF said in the post. There is no doubt about the amount of bad patents. Demonstrating what is bad is however very useful.
- zak_mc_kracken 12y agoI don't know what system you have in mind to replace software patents, but I'm pretty sure it won't be perfect either, which, by your own definition means that your solution is just as broken. Surely we can agree that "not perfect" is not equivalent to "broken"?
- ArtDev 12y agoA single patent can bring a business to its knees or stifle a whole potential new industry. When it comes to patents, "not perfect" means "very broken".
- zak_mc_kracken 12y agoSo what's your perfect system?
- nitrogen 12y agoNone at all.
- zak_mc_kracken 12y agoWhat's your evidence that it's perfect? For example, a startup with hardly any funding comes up with a very innovative idea to tackle a problem, they start working on it with very little funding. Facebook grabs the idea, implements it in a month, exposes it to a billion users and the startup just dies. What's the incentive for the next innovators to create a startup in such conditions? "What's the point of trying to create something novel since Facebook or Apple will just copy us and crush us". Not exactly a perfect system now, is it?
- rfrey 12y agoIt's unlikely the hypothetical startup would be protected from that sad outcome by the current system.
- shmerl 12y ago> Facebook grabs the idea, implements it in a month, exposes it to a billion users and the startup just dies. That makes an assumption that software patents should be used for preventing others from "grabbing the idea". That's invalid. You can protect your software with copyright, or for example make it open and ensure contributions from derivative works with copyleft. But to be competitive one doesn't need software patents which cause all kind of crooked damage.
- noonespecial 12y agoEven if the startup had the patent, it is unlikely they would have the millions it would take to enforce it against Facebook. Far more likely the opposite. Facebook collects hundreds of patents and uses rotten lawyer tricks to avoid ever competing with startups bringing real innovation.
- zak_mc_kracken 12y ago> Even if the startup had the patent, it is unlikely they would have the millions it would take to enforce it against Facebook They wouldn't have to, it's much cheaper and faster for Facebook to just acquire them. Make no mistakes: whenever you read in the news that Big Company just acquired Small Company, a lot of this is justified by the patents that Small Company filed. It is much faster and cheaper for Big Company to acquire that company, its patents, its team and its products than spending years in court suing them.
- shmerl 12y ago> a lot of this is justified by the patents that Small Company filed. That's bunk. It can happen that companies are acquired for patents. But the above was the case when it's acquired for technology. That's a very different thing.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- shmerl 12y agoYes, it's hard to make a perfect system, because it's not easy to define what should not be patentable (since it's broader than just software and criteria should be more generic to be applied well). Declaring software unpatentable can solve part of the problem, but it's not a generic solution, rather a workaround. However it's clear that banning software patents at least would already improve it. I.e. such workaround is better than the current level of broken.