4 ms·
a relatively privacy friendly way is to compare accounts to ip addresses. You obviously expect there to be some nat-ing going on but it should be relatively co
by x0x0 12y ago
a relatively privacy friendly way is to compare accounts to ip addresses. You obviously expect there to be some nat-ing going on but it should be relatively constant over time. That is, if in your entire network you've seen, say, 10 accounts from a given ip and all of a sudden 5 accounts interact with a given shop, it's probably fraudulent.
You can monitor characteristics the browser reports, including user agent strings.
You can use techniques like differences in rendering of canvas drawings to images to fingerprint browsers. In fact, I'd bet good money this is a great signal: what you're trying to do is not fingerprint, but detect when the reported user-agent has been overridden. Few people override user-agents.
Then you can go on to ways to bury identifiers in browsers. For example, etags on cached objects may be ok if you aren't using it for advertising and clear it in your privacy guidelines.
You can also fingerprint with time deltas, though this may be patented. Briefly: computers synchronize to milliseconds, I think. If you are careful, you can probably detect sub-millisecond clock skew between a client and your server. This should not be constant across devices.
etc etc etc
- TheLoneWolfling 12y ago...And then you start flagging businesses, ISPs, even entire countries as fraudulent. The number of NATs there are make that sort of correlation... difficult. For that matter, there are people that use UA "spoofing" for non-nefarious purposes. Me, for one.
- x0x0 12y agoum, no you don't, and yes i've done something similar before While I'm sure there are valid reasons for ua spoofing, I'd bet it's a great signal for fraud.
- thaumasiotes 12y agoSpeaking as someone who's spent a lot of time in China... flagging entire countries as fraudulent isn't the end of some ridiculous slippery slope -- it's a thriving practice today. I have to hide my IP address to interact with the internet in almost any interesting way.
- x0x0 12y agoyeah, for a while I blackholed china and india with ipfw. Hacking attempts against my server fell like a rock. I felt a tiny bit bad, but if these countries / isps can't police their subscribers, what do they expect. Eventually I got rid of wordpress/php and just use nginx to serve static files so I felt secure enough to drop the firewall rules.
- paulhauggis 12y agoVietnam is pretty bad too. I spent a month in Vietnam and I was blocked from most forums. I had to use a USA-based vpn.
- bruceboughton 12y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User:82.148.97.69/header http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User:82.148.97.69/header >> This IP address [82.148.97.69] is registered to Qtel. It is the IP address for many people in Qatar, if not the entire country.
- robk 12y agoOne quick and relatively easy win is logging IP addresses of historical logins or attempts. It's quite easy then to look for patterns that are skewed in a strange way. It's hard to automate but extremely valuable for human intervention. In the case of ecommerce it's a bit easier since you can flag "good" accounts potentially and use that to weigh the analysis. In the case of simple account creation it's hard since you can't really ever call an account "good" necessarily except perhaps with a long usage history. In the past we took down botnets this way - most low to mid-grade fraudsters had a limited # of IP addresses (probably multiple PCs or such in a cafe or call centre environment) so it was fairly easy to look at all accounts that had been created from that block of IP addresses (or created elsewhere but had repeated logins from these IPs) and then sanity check by looking at quality of the accounts to see whether non-fraud had happened. I suppose in the case of S.S. their data is quite robust across multiple sites.