3 ms·
> MOOC movement (or at least where it has seen success), tends to focus on self-motivated, usually high-aptitude students. But, almost by definition, those attr
by visarga 12y ago
> MOOC movement (or at least where it has seen success), tends to focus on self-motivated, usually high-aptitude students. But, almost by definition, those attributes do not describe most students
I think MOOC's could benefit from face-to-face coaching. Students need someone to see them, to acknowledge their efforts, to monitor their progress and give them encouragement or advice when needed. This is the job of a coach, or educational counselor, not a teacher.
The teacher can very well be teaching the course on video, but the student needs to be observed by a real person in order to get that special feeling that motivates and makes the whole process efficient. A bunch of counselors distributed to major cities could serve a lot of students taking online courses, but they need to feel accountable to a person, not just a website. It's easy to do that and fits well with the online delivery model.
MOOC's could be a great solution to life-long learning and keeping up to date with relevant skills. Especially in computer science, a 4 or 5 year college program is too long - by the time the students finish, many specific technologies they learned might be already obsolete. Instead, coming back for a course or two every year might work much better in the long run.
MOOC's might still work out if they could be coupled with employment from the start - let Coursera or Udacity partner up with various companies and create relevant courses, and use this opportunity to teach and rank the participants and in the end, offer jobs to the ones that are up to par with their skills. This would make MOOC's much more valuable than what they are now.
- glesica 12y ago"Students need someone to see them, to acknowledge their efforts, to monitor their progress and give them encouragement or advice when needed." I agree with this wholeheartedly. It is always important to remember that students are people and that most people are extremely social creatures who want to interact with other people directly, in a bidirectional, real-time way.
- clavalle 12y agoBut does that interaction have to come in the form of a rigid and traditional teacher to student series of interactions? Or could study groups fill that need?
- RyanMiller 12y agoIn 100 or 200 years from now, I think we can be certain that teaching won't even resemble what we do today. Not to mention just how little we've applied scientific research to modern education. We have a long way to go before we see how usable and powerful our tools for information become.
- glesica 12y agoI am not certain of that. Not even a little bit. I don't think teaching will be identical, but I don't see how it can change that much. Human contact is important, that necessitates a "teacher" of some kind. One-on-one instruction isn't efficient, that necessitates classes. I mean, teaching is basically the same today as it was 200 or even 400 years ago despite truly massive increases in technology. I don't see how another hundred years or so will really change human nature enough to necessitate a paradigm shift in teaching.