3 ms·
There's cultural incentive to report results that are favorable even if they are wrong. This has the unfortunate side effect that research coming out of China
by bane 12y ago
There's cultural incentive to report results that are favorable even if they are wrong.
This has the unfortunate side effect that research coming out of China needs to be taken with a grain of salt and extra doubly carefully verified.
It's nothing the scientific method can't handle (we're seeing the start of the verification steps here), but knowing that lots of research coming out of China is misrepresented it introduces another layer of healthy skepticism that it needs to be verified before being accepted as a thing.
Suppose University of Shanghai produces a result, and the University of Beijing confirms it. Rather than accept the result, it's likely that before it's declared "SCIENCE!" a NASA or MIT or whoever is going to want to have verification from someplace that doesn't have a long history of misrepresenting scientific claims.
This is going to be treated differently than if the original work was done at say...CERN and the confirmation was done by CalTech.
- alan_cx 12y ago"There's cultural incentive to report results that are favorable even if they are wrong." Indeed, but unfortunately in western capitalism there is sometimes a financial incentive to report results that aren't favourable even if they are wrong. A bit like what happened with the banks, or with tobacco companies.
- greeneggs 12y agoI don't think NASA has the same credibility as an MIT or Caltech. From their arsenic-based lifeforms [1] to their D-Wave "quantum computer," [2] NASA seems to work on a lot of fringe science. [1] http://science.nasa.gov/science-news/science-at-nasa/2010/02dec_monolake/ http://science.nasa.gov/science-news/science-at-nasa/2010/02... [2] http://www.nas.nasa.gov/quantum/ http://www.nas.nasa.gov/quantum/